Proving the divergence theorem with the Dirac delta function

6 replies · 6K views · last reply
Clara Chung
Messages
300
Reaction score
13
Textbook page section 1.5 The Dirac Delta Function, showing equations 1.83 to 1.85: v = (1/r^2) r-hat, its divergence computed as zero, and the surface integral over a sphere of radius R giving 4 pi.

How do you prove 1.85 is valid for all closed surface containing the origin? (i.e. the line integral = 4pi for any closed surface including the origin)
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page section 1.5 The Dirac Delta Function, showing equations 1.83 to 1.85: v = (1/r^2) r-hat, its divergence computed as zero, and the surface integral over a sphere of radius R giving 4 pi.
    upload_2019-2-13_19-59-47.png
    30.7 KB · Views: 4,949
I would say by inspection, if you note that for a non-spherical surface the R would in fact be a function: ##R(r,\theta,\phi)## and that ##R(r,\theta,\phi)## factors cancel out using the rules of algebra, leaving an integral of angles only.

Since the ##R(r,\theta,\phi)## factors cancel, then you can choose R to be a spherical surface with no loss in generality.

Perhaps, @Mark44 or @fresh_42 have a more rigorous set of steps.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Clara Chung
Clara Chung said:
View attachment 238665
How do you prove 1.85 is valid for all closed surface containing the origin? (i.e. the line integral = 4pi for any closed surface including the origin)

You can use the divergence theorem. Take any volume that includes the origin. To avoid the problem at the origin you could remove a small spherical cavity at the origin. The total surface integral is zero and the surface integral of the small cavity is ##-4\pi##.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Cryo, Clara Chung and jedishrfu
PeroK said:
You can use the divergence theorem. Take any volume that does not include the origin. To avoid the problem at the origin you could remove a small spherical cavity at the origin. The total surface integral is zero and the surface integral of the small cavity is ##-4\pi##.
Printed page of a physics textbook showing equation 1.99, the divergence of r-hat over r squared equals 4 pi delta cubed of r, and the generalised equation 1.100 with separation vector z, boxed.

How to get 1.100 from 1.99? I can't find the derivation in the book...
 
Attachments
  • Printed page of a physics textbook showing equation 1.99, the divergence of r-hat over r squared equals 4 pi delta cubed of r, and the generalised equation 1.100 with separation vector z, boxed.
    upload_2019-2-14_0-47-2.png
    25.3 KB · Views: 1,716
Clara Chung said:
View attachment 238678
How to get 1.100 from 1.99? I can't find the derivation in the book...

That's just a substitution ##\vec{r}## to ##\vec{r} - \vec{r'}##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Clara Chung
PeroK said:
That's just a substitution ##\vec{r}## to ##\vec{r} - \vec{r'}##.
How do you do the substitution? Why is it ok to let ##\vec{r}## = ##\vec{r} - \vec{r'}## ? They are not equal..
 
Clara Chung said:
How do you do the substitution? Why is it ok to let ##\vec{r}## = ##\vec{r} - \vec{r'}## ? They are not equal..

In general, if ##f'(x) = g(x)##, then ##f'(x-a) = g(x-a)##. It's a simple application of the chain rule.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jedishrfu