Raising a generation of Really Bad Readers?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chris Hillman
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Generation
AI Thread Summary
Concerns have been raised about the declining reading and writing skills among new members in online physics forums, attributed to the influence of text messaging and informal communication styles. Many users express frustration over these newcomers' inability to follow simple instructions, leading to inappropriate posts and misunderstandings. The discussion highlights a perceived generational gap in communication, with older members lamenting the lack of effort in using proper language. Despite these worries, some argue that language evolves and that the current trends may not be as detrimental as feared. Overall, the future of forums like PF may depend on the willingness of new users to engage with more formal communication standards.
  • #51
The Semiotics of Shawn

Integral said:
How did the topic of this thread change from "poor readers" to internet scamming?

ShawnD said:
I didn't read the OP. That's how.

So in a sense, Shawn is still on-topic, he's simply illustrating the phenomenon we are discussing :wink:
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #52
ShawnD said:
I didn't read the OP. That's how.
So, Integral's post was nullified since they were still on topic, since Integral's statement was nullified so was the above post, but if the above post was nullified then Integral's post wouldn't be nullified, creating an endless cycle of nullifications... Yes, I make no sense...
 
  • #53
That's because you are reading too carefully :wink:
 
  • #54
:smile: :smile:

I guess this is GD after all!
 
  • #55
ShawnD said:
I didn't read the OP. That's how.

Chris Hillman said:
So in a sense, Shawn is still on-topic, he's simply illustrating the phenomenon we are discussing :wink:

:smile: I needed that laugh!
 
  • #56
mgb_phys said:
Posted in the Mathematics survival kit book review - this has got to be a wind-up!

My favorite part of this was when she said, "I'm a brighter student, but..." haha, maybe she should show that...
 
  • #57
Astronuc said:
And I disagree with the assertion that "But the thing is, civilization tends to get smarter, every generation." We seem to have achieved a plateau at the moment, or perhaps if we consider the current president - we've taken a giant leap backward. Certainly there are the few percent of the population who might be considered smarter than those of the same age a few decades ago - but that is a small minority in the population.

Thats an interesting point which can probably be attributed to the increased standards in education during the last 200 years both in Europe and the US. This certainly gives the impression that every successive generation is getting cleverer, but in fact what is actually happening is that more people are exposed to a better quality of education. If you look at some of the great academics of the past such as Newton and Gauss, and perhaps the Greek philosophers, they certainly wouldn't be considered stupid when compared to modern counterparts.

I abhor text style writing. When I text someone I use full words and punctuation. The problem with text speak is that it may be quicker to type, but it certainly isn't quicker to read. Not to mention the fact it makes you look like an idiot.
 
  • #58
Kurdt said:
I abhor text style writing. When I text someone I use full words and punctuation.
I was starting to think that I was the only one that did that. I get so frustrated with people that text me that I end up just calling them, in less than a minute we can solve what would take half an hour by text.
 
  • #59
Evo said:
I was starting to think that I was the only one that did that. I get so frustrated with people that text me that I end up just calling them, in less than a minute we can solve what would take half an hour by text.

You're certainly not alone there.
 
  • #60
Kurdt said:
I abhor text style writing. When I text someone I use full words and punctuation. The problem with text speak is that it may be quicker to type, but it certainly isn't quicker to read. Not to mention the fact it makes you look like an idiot.

I do that too, and people think that I'm stupid and couldn't figure out how to write in text style.:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Back
Top