Recommendation for a book on Hamiltonian Mechanics

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a request for practical examples of Hamiltonian Mechanics, particularly in relation to Box 25.4 from the textbook "Gravitation" by Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler (MTW). The original poster seeks recommendations for books with numerous examples and exercises to enhance their understanding of Hamiltonian Mechanics. Participants suggest resources, notably Tong's online lecture notes and Greenwood's "Classical Dynamics." The conversation clarifies that the poster initially referenced the wrong box number and highlights the importance of generalized momenta in the context of the Hamiltonian for Newtonian Gravity. The poster expresses gratitude for the insights gained from the recommended materials and acknowledges the need for further study in Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics.
TerryW
Gold Member
Messages
222
Reaction score
20
Homework Statement: Practical examples of Hamiltonian Mechanics sought
Relevant Equations: Hamilton Jacobi Equations, MTW

Hi,

I'm currently a bit stuck on Box 24.2 in MTW. I really need to get a better understanding of Hamiltonian Mechanics to be able to work my way through this and I wondered if someone could give me a recommendation for a book on Hamiltonian Mechanics with lots of examples and exercises. If same person could also answer a couple of questions on the actual contents of Box 24.2, that would also be greatly appreciated.

Cheers


TerryW
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi Terry,
Monday through Wednesday? Not sure everyone knows what MTW stands for. Can you expand?
 
  • Haha
Likes MatinSAR, robphy and Mondayman
WWGD said:
Monday through Wednesday? Not sure everyone knows what MTW stands for. Can you expand?
I assume MTW = Misner, Thorne & Wheeler Gravitation.
 
renormalize said:
I assume MTW = Misner, Thorne & Wheeler Gravitation.
Correct:smile:
 
Frabjous said:
42.
It helps if you actually ask the questions.
 
Well, my main question was seeking suggestions for a good book on Hamiltonian Mechanics and I haven't had any response on that. If anyone had come forward with a suggestion and then maybe offered help with the questions thrown up by Box 24.2, I could then set out my issues with maybe some hope that some help would be forthcoming.

TerryW
 
I' recommend Tong's online lecture notes on this topic. I used them to better understand Schrodinger's derivation of his equation.
 
Greenwood Classical Dynamics.
Are you sure it’s Box 24.2?
 
haushofer said:
I' recommend Tong's online lecture notes on this topic. I used them to better understand Schrodinger's derivation of his equation.
Thanks for the recommendation haushofer.

Cheers

TerryW
 
  • #10
Frabjous said:
Greenwood Classical Dynamics.
Are you sure it’s Box 24.2?
Thanks for your recommendation Frabjous.

You're right, it's Box 25.4 which is causing me the problems, starting with the Hamiltonian for Newtonian Gravity!! Why are the r^2 and (rsin𝜃)^2 in the denominator rather than the numerator?
 
  • #11
They are using generalized momenta, not regular momenta:
##p_i\equiv \frac {\partial L} {\partial {\dot q}_i}##
where ##p_i## is the generalized momenta and L is the lagrangian.
 
  • #12
Frabjous said:
They are using generalized momenta, not regular momenta:
##p_i\equiv \frac {\partial L} {\partial {\dot q}_i}##
where ##p_i## is the generalized momenta and L is the lagrangian.
Thanks for pointing this out. Not immediately obvious but maybe I really do need to do a bit of work on Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics.

Cheers

TerryW
 
  • #13
Frabjous said:
They are using generalized momenta, not regular momenta:
##p_i\equiv \frac {\partial L} {\partial {\dot q}_i}##
where ##p_i## is the generalized momenta and L is the lagrangian.
In the Tong lecture notes recommended by Haushofer there is a line on p21 which really switched a bright light on for me. The line is "... ##p_i = \frac{\partial L}{\partial q_i}## is called the generalised momentum conjugate to ##q_i##. (It only coincides with the real momentum in Cartesian coordinates).. Now I get it!

I still have a couple of issues with the content of Box 25.4 - I'll post these shortly.


Regards


TerryW
 

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
13K
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
6K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top