Relativistic Calculations for De-Broglie Wavelength

3 replies · 9K views · last reply
IWantToLearn
Messages
95
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


At what energy will a non-relativistic calculation of the De Broglie wavelength of an electron be in error by 5%? What is this energy for a proton? Comment on your results.

Homework Equations


I have two (seemed to be) logical answers for this question, but with different values

how to resolve this, there must be at least one wrong answer

i need a resolution [/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


Solution 1
Handwritten derivation comparing classical and relativistic de Broglie wavelengths, showing K = mv^2/2, p = sqrt(2mK), the relativistic p = sqrt(K^2/c^2 + 2mK), a 5% error condition, and K values for electron and proton.

Solution 2
Handwritten derivation: (lambda_c - lambda_r)/lambda_r = 0.05; then ((h/mv) - (h/gamma m v))/(h/gamma m v) = 0.05; then gamma - 1 = 0.05; then k_e = (gamma - 1) m_e c^2; then k_e = 0.026 MeV.
 
The second approach has the right relativistic de-Broglie wavelength. It depends on the momentum, not on "the energy above the rest energy plugged into the nonrelativistic expression".
 
As far as i understand, there is nothing in the first approach states that the De-Broglie wavelength depend in anything but the momentum
in the first approach i replaced the momentum by the kinetic energy, and this is a valid replacement

please explain your point
 
You replaced momentum by the kinetic energy in nonrelativistic mechanics. It won't give the right result for relativistic speeds.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: IWantToLearn