Resistor value given capacitance and EMF with a resistance R after 3ms

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the resistance R in an RC circuit, given a capacitor's capacitance and charge after a specific time. The relevant equation for the voltage on a charging capacitor is highlighted, emphasizing the relationship between charge, capacitance, and voltage. A participant initially misapplies the formula, resulting in an incorrect resistance value, but later revises their approach using the correct equations. The importance of solving equations symbolically before substituting numerical values is also stressed for clarity. Ultimately, the conversation aims to guide the correct application of the RC time constant in solving the problem.
kalm1307
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
A capacitor with capacitance C=5.90 μF, initially uncharged, is connected to a source with emf ε=28.0 V and to a series resistance R. After 3.00 ms the charge on the capacitor is 100 μC. What is the value of resistor R in Ohms?
Relevant Equations
T=R/C
T=R/C
So:
0.003s=R/100μC
R=3*10^-7Ω
I am really confused with the equations I have to use
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
kalm1307 said:
Homework Statement:: A capacitor with capacitance C=5.90 μF, initially uncharged, is connected to a source with emf ε=28.0 V and to a series resistance R. After 3.00 ms the charge on the capacitor is 100 μC. What is the value of resistor R in Ohms?
Relevant Equations:: I am not sure

I tried with T=R/C
So:
0.003=R/100μC
R=3*10^-7
I am really confused with the ecuations I have to use
The equations you have shown are not very helpful, especially since you have not described them and have not included units. :smile:

So on a problem like this, just think in terms of the RC time constant charging equation (can you show that?), and how the voltage on the capacitor involves the charge value that the problem is asking about.

Can you please try again, post the Relevant Equations with units, and show your new attempt? Thanks!
 
berkeman said:
The equations you have shown are not very helpful, especially since you have not described them and have not included units. :smile:

So on a problem like this, just think in terms of the RC time constant charging equation (can you show that?), and how the voltage on the capacitor involves the charge value that the problem is asking about.

Can you please try again, post the Relevant Equations with units, and show your new attempt? Thanks!
I have corrected everything you told me, do I have to post again my doubt?
 
kalm1307 said:
I have corrected everything you told me, do I have to post again my doubt?
I have no idea.

The relevant equation for the voltage on a charging capacitor in an RC circuit is:

$$V(t) = V_s (1- e^\frac{-t}{RC}) $$

Can you use that to figure out what the voltage is at the time specified, and translate that to the charge?

1651368632003.png

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electric/capchg.html
 
I tried this equation:
Q=C*Vb*(1-e^(-t/RC)
And I solved the equation for R as follows:

100*10^-6C=5.0*10^-6F*28V(1-e^(-0.003s/R*(5.9*10^-6F))
R=546.92Ω
 
berkeman said:
I have no idea.

The relevant equation for the voltage on a charging capacitor in an RC circuit is:

$$V(t) = V_s (1- e^\frac{-t}{RC}) $$

Can you use that to figure out what the voltage is at the time specified, and translate that to the charge?

View attachment 300868
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electric/capchg.html
I tried this equation:
Q=C*Vb*(1-e^(-t/RC)
And I solved the equation for R as follows:

100*10^-6C=5.0*10^-6F*28V(1-e^(-0.003s/R*(5.9*10^-6F))
R=546.92Ω
 
kalm1307 said:
100*10^-6C=5.0*10^-6F*28V(1-e^(-0.003s/R*(5.9*10^-6F))
R=546.92Ω
I think that is close to correct, but it's extremely hard to read without LaTeX formatting, plus I think you incorrectly put C=5.0uF as the first term on the RHS instead of 5.9uF.

It is also best to solve the equations symbolically first, and then substitute in the numbers in the last step to calculate the answer. In LaTeX:
$$Q(t) = C V(t)$$
$$Q(t) = C V_s (1-e^{- \frac{t}{R C}} )$$
$$\frac{Q(t)}{C V_s} = 1-e^{- \frac{t}{R C}} $$
$$e^{- \frac{t}{R C}} = 1- \frac{Q(t)}{C V_s}$$
Then how do you simplify the LHS to get rid of the exponential so that you can keep working toward finding R?
 
(BTW, if you click Reply to my last post, and toggle the "[ ]" BB code setting thing above the Edit window, you can see how easy it is to post these kind of math equations with LaTeX.)
 
Last edited:
  • #10
berkeman said:
It is also best to solve the equations symbolically first, and then substitute in the numbers in the last step to calculate the answer.
This! It doesn't just give you the answer, it tells you a bit about how the equations work out.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
Back
Top