Reversing digits, then adding and finding divisible integers of result.

  • Thread starter Thread starter VinnyCee
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Integers
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the divisibility of the sum of a two-digit number and its reversed digits. It is established that this sum, represented as 11(x + y), is always divisible by 11, 1, and the sum of the digits (x + y). Participants debate whether the problem is ambiguous in asking for three positive integers, as the results can yield four divisors depending on the digits chosen. The conversation highlights that while 1 and the number itself are always divisors, the inclusion of distinct integers complicates the answer. Ultimately, the consensus suggests that the problem may be flawed or misleading in its requirements.
VinnyCee
Messages
486
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



If you find the sum of any two digit number and the number formed by reversing its digits, the resulting number is always divisible by which three positive integers?


Homework Equations



None.


The Attempt at a Solution



\left(10\ x\ +\ y\right)\ +\ \left(10\ y\ +\ x\right)\ =\ 11\ x\ +\ 11\ y

Where x is the tens place and y is the ones place. This is divisible by 11, and 1 (as are all integers) and x + y.

\therefore\ x\ +\ y\ ,11\ ,1\ |\ 11\ x\ +\ 11\ y
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Was there a question in there? Did you determine the 3 numbers?
 
VinnyCee said:

Homework Statement



If you find the sum of any two digit number and the number formed by reversing its digits, the resulting number is always divisible by which three positive integers?


Homework Equations



None.


The Attempt at a Solution



\left(10\ x\ +\ y\right)\ +\ \left(10\ y\ +\ x\right)\ =\ 11\ x\ +\ 11\ y

Where x is the tens place and y is the ones place. This is divisible by 11, and 1 (as are all integers) and x + y.

\therefore\ x\ +\ y\ ,11\ ,1\ |\ 11\ x\ +\ 11\ y

The number is pretty likely to be divisible by itself as well as 1 and 11, isn't it? Kind of a trick question.
 
Dick said:
The number is pretty likely to be divisible by itself as well as 1 and 11, isn't it? Kind of a trick question.

Well, if we include one and itself, we are up to 4 numbers (11 and x+y).

So, either they're being generous, asking only for 3 of 4, or they don't count 1 and itself, which would mean we're still missing one.
 
DaveC426913 said:
Well, if we include one and itself, we are up to 4 numbers (11 and x+y).

So, either they're being generous, asking only for 3 of 4, or they don't count 1 and itself, which would mean we're still missing one.

Well, 11+11=22. The only divisors are 1,2,11 and 22. I count four. So that's the max for the minimum number of divisors. Don't think any can be missing. 1 divides everything. So that's probably the one I would throw out. But every number divides itself as well. Tough call.
 
Dick said:
Well, 11+11=22. The only divisors are 1,2,11 and 22. I count four. So that's the min. Don't think any can be missing. 1 divides everything. So that's probably the one I would throw out. But every number divides itself as well. Tough call.

22??

22 isn't one of them.34,43 = 77, divisible by 1,7,11,77
27,72 = 99, divisible by 1,9,11,99
etc.
 
DaveC426913 said:
22??

22 isn't one of them.34,43 = 77, divisible by 1,7,11,77
27,72 = 99, divisible by 1,9,11,99
etc.

11 isn't a two digit number? This is getting silly.
 
Dick said:
11 isn't a two digit number? This is getting silly.

Oh sorry. I thought you were claiming 22 was a common divisor. As in: any 2 digit number and the sum of its reversed version would be divisible by 22. My error.:blushing:
 
DaveC426913 said:
Well, if we include one and itself, we are up to 4 numbers (11 and x+y).

So, either they're being generous, asking only for 3 of 4, or they don't count 1 and itself, which would mean we're still missing one.

Yes, there are 4 positive numbers, 2 fixed, and 2 depending on the choice of digits.
However, these numbers do not have to be distinct.

Note that with the choice "10", the resulting number is 11, and we only get 1 and 11 as divisors.
In all other cases, there are 3 distinct numbers guaranteed: itself, 11, and 1.

So either we get one number for free, or the problem is broken.
 
  • #10
I like Serena said:
Yes, there are 4 positive numbers, 2 fixed, and 2 depending on the choice of digits.
However, these numbers do not have to be distinct.

Note that with the choice "10", the resulting number is 11, and we only get 1 and 11 as divisors.
In all other cases, there are 3 distinct numbers guaranteed: itself, 11, and 1.

So either we get one number for free, or the problem is broken.

Ha! That's good. Attention to detail is even more important to exposing lame problem statements than I thought.
 
Back
Top