Science fiction stuff that could never happen

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
10 replies · 3K views
hsdrop
Messages
324
Reaction score
114
I would not mind hearing about some of the things that we have either read or watched in the sci-fi world that could never happen in real life (pet peeves and/or total imposables) just to have a little fun debunking and setting strate some of the thing that we have all seen that other may believe could happen just to give an example superpowerd superheroes like the x-men
 
Physics news on Phys.org
My pet peeves definitely include spaceships that are described or depicted as if they are moving like an aircraft or a ship. Most sci-fi movies or games that includes spacecraft s usually goes to great lengths to get it all wrong leaving the general public behind with all the wrong idea of how it actually works. There are even space games out there that sports zero physical realism in this regard. I largely blame George Lucas for this sad state of affairs.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: hsdrop
nop star trek and other early show like blake's 7 flash gordon were doing the flying in space thing well before star wars and yes i would have to say that is a bad miss leader in all spaceship type shows
 
"Bring the ship to a complete stop Mr Sulu".
"But captain..."
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Noisy Rhysling
"Standard orbit Mr Sulu".
"Captain, if we lose power the ship will spiral into the planet in two hours".
 
"Captain the ship has lost all power, we only have enough air for 4 hours".
"Oh no, but thank the Lord we still have gravity".
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: hsdrop
how about laser blasters that show a short beam of light slow enough to see it traveling and able to dodge it lol
 
Iron Man's suit doesn't have inertia dampeners, yet he doesn't go splat inside of it.
Superman's arms don't have inertia dampeners, yet the people he catches just over the ground don't go splat in them.
Cobra's floating ice fortress sank when broken up.
Star Trek's computer terminals are all made of explodium.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: CalcNerd
hsdrop said:
how about laser blasters that show a short beam of light slow enough to see it traveling and able to dodge it lol

Technically, they arent lasers, but some kind of plasma projectile, although i heard there are real lasers called turbo lasers that couldn't be dodged easily.
 
jackwhirl said:
Iron Man's suit doesn't have inertia dampeners, yet he doesn't go splat inside of it.
They don't come right out and say that his suit is equipped with inertial dampeners, but I always thought it had to have them. Otherwise, as you said, he wouldn't have made it out of the testing phase shown in the first film. He would've been squished meat in a can. That said, even inertial dampeners are pretty far fetched based on what they're expected to do.

Star Trek's transporter system is extremely dubious as it's depicted on the show and movies. I don't see how the agony of being disintegrated at one location and replaced by a copy of yourself at another location would ever be practical or desirable. Maybe with inanimate objects, but not living organisms.
 
hsdrop said:
how about laser blasters that show a short beam of light slow enough to see it traveling and able to dodge it lol
Or one that can be stopped in mid-air while simultaneously freezing the person that fired it.