Solve Derivative Homework: f(x), g(f), P(2,3)

  • Thread starter Thread starter stanton
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Derivative
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a calculus problem involving derivatives and tangent lines. The original poster presents a function relationship f(x)/3 = g(f) and a tangent line to f(x) at the point (2,3) described by the equation y=2.1x-1. Participants are tasked with finding f '(2), g(2), and g '(2).

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the meaning of the tangent line equation and its implications for the derivative of f(x). There is uncertainty about whether f(x) itself is represented by the tangent line or if the line describes the slope at that point. Various interpretations of the problem are discussed, including the relationship between f(x) and g(f).

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided clarifications regarding the interpretation of the tangent line and its relationship to the derivative. Others have attempted to derive expressions for g(x) based on the given relationships, while questioning the role of g in the context of the problem. The discussion reflects a mix of interpretations and attempts to clarify the problem without reaching a consensus.

Contextual Notes

Participants express confusion regarding the notation and the implications of the equations presented. There is also mention of the need to clarify the problem statement and the specific values to be found, indicating that the original poster may have omitted details in their initial posts.

stanton
Messages
74
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



(i)f(x)/3=g(f)
(ii)The tangent to f(x) at x=2 (point P(2,3)) has equation y=2.1x-1
Find the value of f '(2)
Find the valus of g(2)
Find the value of g '(2)

Homework Equations



Chain rule, I guess?
d/dx x [f(g(x))]=f'(g(x))g'(x) I think this is it?
dy/dx=dy/du x du/dx

The Attempt at a Solution



What I want to know is that what does (ii)mean? does it mean line tangent to f(x) at x=2 is [ y=2.1x-1]? (in other words, the equation for slope of f(x) is y=2.1x-1 at x=2)
Or does it mean f(x) has an equation y=2.1x-1 at x=2?
So I had two solution to this prob.
1. regarding that f '(x) is y=2.1x-1, plug the value 2 in the equation, so the answer is 3.2
2. regarding that f(x) is y=2.1x-1 at x=2, f '(x) is 2.1. so the answer is 2.1
Help me. How should I interpret the question?

As I did not understan whether f(x) is y=2.1x-1 or equation of slope is y=2.1x-1, I am stuck now. But if f(x) is y=2.1x-1, I can plug 2 in g(x) like this to solve problem a:
2.1x-1/3=2.1(2)/3=1.4
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
(ii) means that the line that is tangent to the graph of f(x) at the point x=2 has the given equation. To solve, you need to understand the connection between tangent lines to graphs and the derivative.
 
stanton said:

Homework Statement



I was given a problem and I cannot understand it.
(i)f(x)/3=g(f)
Shouldn't this be f(x)/3 = g(f(x))? Also, what are you asked to find?
stanton said:
(ii)The tangent to f(x) at x=2 has equation y=2.1x-1
And I was given a problem saids [Find the value of f '(2)]

Homework Equations



Chain rule, I guess?
dy/dx=dy/du x du/dx

The Attempt at a Solution



What I want to know is that what does (ii)mean? does it mean line tangent to f(x) at x=2 is [ y=2.1x-1]? (in other words, the equation for slope of f(x) is y=2.1x-1 at x=2)
Or does it mean f(x) has an equation y=2.1x-1 at x=2?
It means the first possibility. The tangent line to the graph of y = f(x) has this equation: y = 2.1x -1.
stanton said:
So I had two solution to this prob.
1. regarding that f '(x) is y=2.1x-1, plug the value 2 in the equation, so the answer is 3.2
Yes, but what you want to say is that f(2) = 3.2.
stanton said:
2. regarding that f(x) is y=2.1x-1 at x=2, f '(x) is 2.1. so the answer is 2.1
Help me. How should I interpret the question?

Homework Statement



And I also need help with other problem based on (i) and (ii)

a)Find the valus of g(2)
b)Find the value of g '(2)
Since f(x)/3 = (1/3)f(x) = g(f(x)), can you describe what function g does to an input value? Knowing that will enable you to write a formula for g(x), and will enable you to do the 2nd part.
stanton said:

Homework Equations



d/dx x [f(g(x))]=f'(g(x))g'(x) I think this is it?
Yes, this is what you want, but it's not "d/dx" times [f(g(x))]; it's d/dx of [f(g(x))]. You're taking the derivative, with respect to x, of [f(g(x))]. d/dx is not a number, so it makes no sense to talk about multiplying something by it.

Your chain rule formula should look like this: d/dx[f(g(x))]=f'(g(x))g'(x)
stanton said:

The Attempt at a Solution



As I did not understan whether f(x) is y=2.1x-1 or equation of slope is y=2.1x-1, I am stuck now. But if f(x) is y=2.1x-1, I can plug 2 in g(x) like this to solve problem a:
2.1x-1/3=2.1(2)/3=1.4
 
Thank you so much. I was very confused. So f'(2) is 3.2, right? For f'(x) at x=2 is 2.1x-1
Also , I figured out the f(x). I fogot to enter coordinates in my post when x=2 :(2,3)
I pluged this in equation y=ax+b. So 3=2a+b
And the slope is given as 3.2
f(x) has this equation at x=2: y=3.2x-3.4 So g(x) is y=3.2x-3.4/3
Therefore, g(x)=1.06x-1.1
I pugged the value 2 in g(x) and got 2.2 And I got g' (x)=-1.1
And g(2)=1.02
Am I doing right so far?
And Thank you for your all the advices and help. I really appreciate it.
 
Last edited:
stanton said:
Thank you so much. I was very confused. So f'(2) is 3.2, right?
Right. I inadvertently omitted the '. I meant to say that f'(2) = 3.2.
stanton said:
For f'(x) at x=2 is 2.1x-1
No, f'(x) at x = 2 (i.e., f'(2)) is 2.1*2 - 1 = 3.2, not 2.1x - 1.
stanton said:
Also , I figured out the f(x). I fogot to enter coordinates in my post when x=2 :(2,3)
I pluged this in equation y=ax+b. So 3=2a+b
And the slope is given as 3.2
f(x) has this equation at x=2: y=3.2x-3.4 So g(x) is y=3.2x-3.4/3
Therefore, g(x)=1.1x-1.1
You're way off here. I assume you're talking about the problem where you need to find g(2) and g'(2), right?

You need to find the formula for g(x) from f(x)/3 = g(f(x)). My question again is what does g do to an input value? You need to answer this before attempting to find g(2) and g'(2).


stanton said:
I pugged the value 2 in g(x) and got 2.2 And I got g' (x)=-1.1
And g(2)=1.1
Am I doing right so far?
And Thank you for your all the advices and help. I really appreciate it.
 
I think I went in the wrong way with solving g(2) and g'(2). I reinterpreted the question. Could you check this for me?
y=2.1x-1
f' (x)=2.1
If we integrate f' (x) with respect to x,
f(x)=2.1x+C
Plug coordinate(2,3)--> f(x)=2.1x-1.2 g(x)=0.7x-0.4
So g(2) is 1. g' (x)=0.7
And sorry, to bother you, I can't understand your question. I don't see any role of g. :(
 
This is what I was working with:
stanton said:
(i)f(x)/3=g(f)
(ii)The tangent to f(x) at x=2 has equation y=2.1x-1
And I was given a problem saids [Find the value of f '(2)]
<snip>
And I also need help with other problem based on (i) and (ii)
a)Find the valus of g(2)
b)Find the value of g '(2)
It complicates things when you post more than one question in a post. Also, when the problem is spread out all over the post. Use the first section for "the problem statement, all variables and given/known data." No part of the problem statement should be in the attempt at a solution section.

So what exactly is the problem you're trying to solve?
 
I fixed my post :) In first section(problem statement) I put my problems that I am trying to solve.
 
Please answer the question I asked in post #5:
You need to find the formula for g(x) from f(x)/3 = g(f(x)). My question again is what does g do to an input value? You need to answer this before attempting to find g(2) and g'(2).
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K