Solve math problem w/ no algebra

  • Thread starter Thread starter johnnyies
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Algebra
AI Thread Summary
Daniel has 54 stamps, while Sherry has 47, based on the total of 101 stamps they share and the fact that Daniel has 7 more than Sherry. The problem can be solved without algebra by using a trial-and-error method, adjusting estimates based on the total and the difference in their stamp counts. By subtracting 7 from the total and dividing by 2, one can find the equal share, which leads to determining Daniel's count. An alternative approach involves a binary search method to narrow down the possible number of stamps Daniel could have. This demonstrates that the problem can be approached with basic arithmetic and logical reasoning rather than formal algebra.
johnnyies
Messages
93
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Daniel has 7 more stamps than Sherry. Together, they have 101 stamps.
How many stamps does Daniel have?

Homework Equations


let x equal how many stamps daniel has

x - 7 + x = 101
2 x = 108
x = 54

101 - 54 = 47

The Attempt at a Solution


Now, we can easily solve this w/ some algebraic equations, but how can we do this without any algebra, or just at an elementary school understanding of math?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Trial and error would work fine...why?
 
Easy,

You take the total number of stamps, and take the extra 7 away.

101-7 = 94

Now they have an equal number of stamps, so let's split them in half equally.

94/2 = 47

Now they each have 47 stamps, but Daniel has 7 more so,

47 + 7 = 54.

Stamp count:

Sherry: 47
Daniel: 54
 
johnnyies said:

Homework Statement


Daniel has 7 more stamps than Sherry. Together, they have 101 stamps.
How many stamps does Daniel have?

Homework Equations


let x equal how many stamps daniel has

x - 7 + x = 101
2 x = 108
x = 54

101 - 54 = 47

The Attempt at a Solution


Now, we can easily solve this w/ some algebraic equations, but how can we do this without any algebra, or just at an elementary school understanding of math?


I do understand that you want this to be as comprehensive a possible,
try not to use x to represent the stamps Daniel has , instead we may use "d" as the student can establish an relationship. And soon they adopt the use of algebra unknowingly. (=
 
Daniel has 7 more stamps than Sherry. Together, they have 101 stamps.
How many stamps does Daniel have?

same suggestion as gabbagabbahey.

We know Daniel cannot have more than 101 stamps. So assume that he has 50 stamps, Sherry would have 50-7. Total equals 50+50-7 which is less than 101.

Next assumption 60. Sherry would have 60-7 and total 60+60-7 which is more than 101.

Next assumption 55...

This is not trail and error to be honest. It is more like binary search. You keep on reducing the interval like I went from 50 to 60, then 50 to 55, .. then 52.5 to 55
 

Similar threads

Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
32
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
69
Views
8K
Back
Top