Solving Pressure in U-tube with Different Densities

4 replies · 5K views · last reply
songoku
Messages
2,522
Reaction score
395

Homework Statement


Two liquids A and B of densities 1.0 g cm-3 and 0.8 g cm-3 are poured into an U-tube as shown in the figure below. Find x !

U-tube diagram with liquid B filling the bottom and rising into both arms, liquid A in the right arm above the dashed reference line, height x marked on the left arm, a 20.0 cm vertical span marked on the right, and points P and Q on the dashed line.


Homework Equations


[tex]P = \rho g h[/tex]


The Attempt at a Solution


Is it possible liquid A is on top of liquid B because A has higher density than B?

Or do I misinterpret the question? Is it possible the question means density of A is 0.8 g cm-3 and B is 1.0 g cm-3 because there is no word "respectively" ?

Thanks
 
songoku said:
Is it possible liquid A is on top of liquid B because A has higher density than B?
Sure, why not? Look at the diagram. Note that the height of liquid A is less than that of liquid B. There's a reason for that!
 
The statement looks correct, A is more dense than B. At the line PQ the pressure is the same. So more height of liquid above point P is needed to maintain the pressure the same as at point A.
 
Hi Doc Al and kuruman

Oh so it's possible that liquid with higher density is on top of liquid with lower density. I always think it's impossible.

I get it now. Thanks a lot Doc Al and kuruman ^^
 
songoku said:
Hi Doc Al and kuruman

Oh so it's possible that liquid with higher density is on top of liquid with lower density. I always think it's impossible.

I get it now. Thanks a lot Doc Al and kuruman ^^

Just imagine an iron piston pressing down on water in the U-tube and you'll see why it's possible.