Star Delta Line/Phase Voltage Confusion

  • Thread starter KMoran28
  • Start date
  • #1
6
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

As I am new to this forum, I must apologise if I have began this thread in the wrong category but I have a bit of a problem.

I don't necessary study physics, I study Electrical Installation at college. As a result we overlap on some physics topics

We have recently covered Star Delta. Now, I understand that in Star the Line and Phase current are equal and line voltage is *sqrt 3 times the phase voltage. And vice versa for delta.

I am somewhat experiencing some doubt as to what line current actually means. It is always between the phases of a load? Or can it also be between the line and neutral?

Any help would be appreciated
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
I am somewhat experiencing some doubt as to what line current actually means. It is always between the phases of a load? Or can it also be between the line and neutral?
Sometimes our thinker gets its gears confused.

You said current but it seems you're asking about voltage.
Voltage is measured between two points
Current is measured at one point.



[PLAIN]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/48/3-phase_flow.gif/357px-3-phase_flow.gif[/SIZE][/COLOR] [Broken]

220px-3_Phase_Power_Connected_to_Delta_Load.svg.png


It[line current] is always between the phases of a load? Or can it also be between the line and neutral?
I would say: "Neither. Line current is in the lines between source and load."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3
6
0
Sometimes our thinker gets its gears confused.

You said current but it seems you're asking about voltage.
Voltage is measured between two points
Current is measured at one point.



[PLAIN]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/48/3-phase_flow.gif/357px-3-phase_flow.gif[/SIZE][/COLOR] [Broken]

220px-3_Phase_Power_Connected_to_Delta_Load.svg.png



I would say: "Neither. Line current is in the lines between source and load."




So just to clarify the is the line VOLTAGE across all three phases

....but the PHASE voltage is between line and neutral.?

I maybe over thinking this haha
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
In three phase power the term "Line Voltage" is taken to mean between two lines not line to neutral.

It is good practice to name your voltage so as to define the two points between which you intend to describe or measure it

VL-L for line to line volts
VL-N for line to neutral volts

Rigor in your naming conventions will keep your thinking straight
and will make you aware of how many folks aren't rigorous in their naming, calling lines "phases", and when naming voltages omitting the second measurement point .
 
  • #5
6
0
In three phase power the term "Line Voltage" is taken to mean between two lines not line to neutral.

It is good practice to name your voltage so as to define the two points between which you intend to describe or measure it

VL-L for line to line volts
VL-N for line to neutral volts

Rigor in your naming conventions will keep your thinking straight
and will make you aware of how many folks aren't rigorous in their naming, calling lines "phases", and when naming voltages omitting the second measurement point .


I'm sure you are right in what you say but my course is at a fairly basic level and the exam format I have will most likely Label them as Line Voltage (VL) and Phase Voltage (VP) which can cause confusion.

Would it be possible to send you an email of a practice exam question? We marked it in class but I'm not so sure about it now
 
  • #6
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
So just to clarify the is the line VOLTAGE across all three phases

....but the PHASE voltage is between line and neutral.?

I maybe over thinking this haha
not overthinking at all.

Again, voltage is between two points
Line voltage is between any two lines, and usually all 3 line to line voltages are the same.

Phase voltage is a term i reserve for the internals of a device, like one generator winding.
That's because the windings can be connected star or delta.
In star machine, phase voltage is going to be line to neutral
in delta machine phase voltage is going to be line to line.

This is an example of words leading the mind to the correct (or incorrect) physical concept.
Most folks look up at a transmission line and call those big wires "phases". I call them "Lines" for a reason.
When you look at a transformer
10Kv_SC_B_11_series_three-phase_resin-insulated_dry-type_power_transformer-300x292.jpg

it's pretty apparent that "phase" refers to a winding and its branch of the core.

This dual use of the term "phase" , once for a winding and once for the external wires, leads the mind to also mix up the physical concepts of phase and line currents and voltage.

So my advice is -
depart from convention and reserve the term "phase" for an individual winding or load element
use "line" for the three wires connecting devices together,

and after the concepts are firmly planted you'll raise your eyebrows when you encounter less than rigorous naming
but you'll be able to figure out what the author meant.

Laviosier: "In correcting our language we reason better"
 
  • #7
6
0
When you say 'line voltage is between any two lines' does this therefore include between Line and Neutral in, say, a star connected load?

Sorry if these questions seems a little stupid but I'm determined to get this locked in my brain :)
 
  • #8
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
Would it be possible to send you an email of a practice exam question? We marked it in class but I'm not so sure about it now
sorry, you posted while i was typing....

indeed it causes confusion. My AC circuits instructor cautioned us boys about this very point and taught us rigor first thing.

I'd say post the practice question here. Who knows, we might have somebody else interested.....

220px-3_Phase_Power_Connected_to_Delta_Load.svg.png

This picture makes it clear to me why one should use "phase voltage" inside the device and "line voltage" outside devices.
If you cover up both devices , the term "phase" voltage is irrelevant because you have only three "lines".
Were there a neutral, i'd use VL-N for voltage measurements to there.
On left device Vphase = VL-N . On right device Vphase = VL-L .
Once you have that concept nailed you can write it on the exam using whatever nomenclature your class prefers.
I sometimes used exams to pass to teachers advice on how to avoid such confusion : "Professor : Please See Reverse for suggestion to improve pedagogical methodology, yours truly....."
 
Last edited:
  • #9
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
Sorry if these questions seems a little stupid but I'm determined to get this locked in my brain :)
good for you. i hope post immediately prior answered the question.

Line to neutral should be VL-N
again, voltage is between two points which should be (but too seldom are) unambiguously defined.
Hmmm..
Voltage is defined as potential difference and it takes two points to have a difference.
Too bad Mr Volta didn't have a compound last name, if he had then the name of the unit Volt would be two words not one, leading the mind to the concept of two points.

What's in a name, eh ?
 
  • #10
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
What's in a name, eh ?
I see irony here.

Ampere is distinctly two syllables
yet an amp is the charge flowing past a single point per unit time.

Volt is distinctly one syllable yet is the potential difference between two points.
Try for a few days calling them "volt-ahs"
 
  • #11
6
0
https://twitter.com/3Collector/status/590162401670070272 [Broken]

Here you can find the question, any help is appreciated. I seem to grasp the concept but this question is playing tricks with my mind! Is the answer actually A? Or is it C?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #12
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CDCtk4gWgAEY1cT.jpg [Broken]

Aha ! "Line voltage" ?

Poorly worded question.
Line to line
or
line to neutral ?

By convention, "Line voltage" is taken to mean "line to line", did teacher not cover that ?

So which meter is connected between two "Lines" ?

What's in a name, eh ?

Observe even Wikipedia is weak on defining their naming convention up front
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-phase
until they get to their "definitions" paragraph
In a star (wye) connected topology, with rotation sequence L1 - L2 - L3, the time-varying instantaneous voltages can be calculated for each phase A,C,B respectively by:

9b8d53cac430cdaf2ac804f3ac209e3d.png

5c0afb7de40ff60fb1cdbbcbc5a13ee7.png

5252ec11981795bfaa598ebc5291e510.png
Now that's clear.
So i'd write immediately underneath that question:
"Professor - Author has failed to distinguish between voltage 'line to line' or 'line to neutral'. C measures the former and A the latter. Your humble student, my name, "
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #13
6
0
Perfect! I will run this by him tomorrow - hopefully he will be able to make some sense of it!

Suppose a question like that came up again, would I be right in assuming its referring as Line to Line? It seems pretty lazy on the exam boards part.
 
  • #14
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
Suppose a question like that came up again, would I be right in assuming its referring as Line to Line? It seems pretty lazy on the exam boards part.
I want to say "yes"
It was fifty years ago i took the course.

Mention to teacher you have it on good authority that
"When slide rules roamed the earth, term 'line voltage' was taken to mean line-to-line not line-to neutral . Is this today's convention ?"

Reason i say that is, some months ago i got a surprise in a thread on "Power Factor".
That term is used by some authors nowadays to mean 'a factor to calculate RMS power of arbitrary waveforms' , as opposed to VIcos(theta) . New math ?
A bit used to mean 1/8dollar, too .

back on topic - I agree with you, it's sloppy notation.



old jim
 
  • #15
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,875
I hope you take away from this an appreciation for the value of rigorous upfront definition of terms. It's one thing i look for in textbooks.
 
  • #16
135
63
I had a question similar to this a while back; Jim Hardy helped me on that one so thanks again Jim from all of us beginners.

I just wanted to chime in with an addendum to the issue of clearly defining your question. First of all, it's asking for voltage so B and D are irrelevant since they're not between two points. But more important is that the question fails to define line-line or line-neutral. Which brings me to the point I'm trying to make: always qualify your work! This is something that I deal with all the time. People simply give numbers with no labels attached to them. I know it seems like a pretty elementary thing to say but as you get out working in the field you can become so into a routine you start making the mistake of just listing results without qualifying them. Heck, the guy who wrote that question got it wrong because he wasn't specific enough. My advice is that while you're in school label literally everything, even things that don't necessarily have to be.

You're never getting "about 20 volts from the stator". You're getting "20.3 ACV from line 1 to line 2".
 
  • Like
Likes jim hardy
  • #17
NascentOxygen
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
9,244
1,072
I am somewhat experiencing some doubt as to what line current actually means.
Line current is the current in the line. :wink: Trite but true!

Whether the load is star or delta is immaterial to how you measure line current.

If everything is balanced (and in most exam questions it always is :smile: ) then all line currents will have the same magnitude. As I believe Jim said, you measure line current by imagining you have an ammeter in series with the line. You can take your pick whether you choose red, blue, or yellow when the load is balanced. It is always a good idea to mark on the circuit exactly how and where you will connect any meter, before you perform the task.

3ɸ outlets can provide fearsome sparks.
i0om5.gif
 
  • Like
Likes jim mcnamara
  • #18
jim mcnamara
Mentor
3,913
2,306
i0om5.gif
+++ for Sparky the gif-ted electrician. I was equally careless one time. Never again.
 
  • #19
dlgoff
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,824
1,759
proxy.php?image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.imgur.com%2Fi0om5.gif
+++ for Sparky the gif-ted electrician.
This Smilie would come in handy at times here in the EE Forum. Maybe Greg would like to add it to the "Old School" Smiles; if there's no copyright problems.

This one would be good for the Chemistry Forum. :devil:

chemist-smiley-emoticon.gif
 
  • Like
Likes jim hardy
  • #20
255
80
I think this is really about convention

In the power industry in the UK (for example), the convention for three-phase power is:

Line voltage is the voltage across two phases
Phase voltage is the voltage across a single phase (referenced to earth neutral)

The relationship between this is sqrt3 which is most easily shown geometrically

In a delta system,
Line and phase voltage are the same
Line current is sqrt3 * phase current

In a star system
Line voltage is sqrt3 * phase voltage
Line current = phase current
 

Related Threads on Star Delta Line/Phase Voltage Confusion

Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
734
Replies
5
Views
6K
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
3K
Top