Stiffness factor for member in beam

5 replies · 4K views · last reply
fonseh
Messages
521
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


In this question , I don't understand why the KBC is 4EI / L ...

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I was told that for the far end pinned or roller supported , the K = 3EI / L , so shouldn't the KBC = 3EI / L.. Is the author wrong ?

In the 3rd photo , we can see that for far end pinned supported , k = 3EI / L , not 4EI / L
 
Attachments
  • Textbook figures for moment distribution: Fig. 12-9 shows a beam with an unlocked joint at one end and a locked joint at the other; Fig. 12-10 shows a real beam with a pin at far end B and its conjugate beam with supports V_A' and V_B'; plus the derivation K = 3EI/L for a far end pinned member.
    P861M.png
    37.6 KB · Views: 859
  • Textbook page showing Example 12.1 solution: stiffness factors KAB = 4EI/12, KBC = 4EI/12 (circled in red), KCD = 4EI/8, plus distribution factors and fixed-end moments for a beam.
    vRd8Z.png
    45.2 KB · Views: 723
Last edited:
fonseh said:
for the far end pinned or roller supported , the K = 3EI / L , so shouldn't the KBC = 3EI / L.. Is the author wrong ?
BC is only a segment of the beam ABCD. The "far end" of BC from B is D.
Think about it: if D were just a pin then the beam could rotate a bit about D, allowing it equally to rotate a little about C. But with D fixed, it is much harder for there to be any rotation about C.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: fonseh
haruspex said:
BC is only a segment of the beam ABCD. The "far end" of BC from B is D.
Think about it: if D were just a pin then the beam could rotate a bit about D, allowing it equally to rotate a little about C. But with D fixed, it is much harder for there to be any rotation about C.
So , in this problem , the far end of AB is D , as D s pinned , so the KAB is 3EI / L ? If D is fixed , then KAB would be 4EI / L ?
 
Attachments
  • Textbook example figure: a continuous beam with supports at A, B, C and D under a 4 k/ft triangular load, spans 15 ft, 20 ft and 15 ft, followed by the solution with stiffness factors and distribution factors and a moment table.
    583.png
    80.5 KB · Views: 1,700
fonseh said:
So , in this problem , the far end of AB is D , as D s pinned , so the KAB is 3EI / L ? If D is fixed , then KAB would be 4EI / L ?
That's my understanding. But please bear in mind that my entire knowledge of the subject comes from the textbook extracts you have posted.
 
haruspex said:
That's my understanding. But please bear in mind that my entire knowledge of the subject comes from the textbook extracts you have posted.
May I know which part ? Can you highlighted it ?
 
fonseh said:
May I know which part ? Can you highlighted it ?
I have not noticed an actual definition of "far end" but just thinking about how I would expect a beam to behave it is clear that if any part of a beam is unable to rotate at all it will make the beam stiffer at all joints. Hence that is how I interpret the term.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: fonseh