Superconductivity for light beams?

39 replies · 6K views · last reply
StandardsGuy said:
As I recall, someone on this forum said that light doesn't require a medium. I argued, and put forth a "theory" of how vacuum was a medium. My post was deleted by an "official" of this forum.
Sounds appropriate. Personal speculation is not allowed here. If you had a problem with the Moderation, per the PF Rules you should contact the Mentor involved. [/off-topic]
 
StandardsGuy said:
As I recall, someone on this forum said that light doesn't require a medium. I argued, and put forth a "theory" of how vacuum was a medium.

I'm not impressed. "theories" like that are a dime a dozen on the 'net. Publish it, then you can boast about it on here. Otherwise, join the queue.

Something no one mentioned is that non-focused light dissipates as the square of the distance, even if there is no loss from the medium.

What does this have anything to do with a "medium"? It is simply a geometric effect due to 3D space. An electrostatic field from a point source has the same 1/r2 dependence. Has nothing to do with space being a medium or not.

Zz.
 
rumborak said:
I'm a bit surprised to not see the obvious answer here: the most lossless medium for current and radiation is ... space.
No, space is not a good conductor of electric current at all.
 
phinds said:
No, space is not a good conductor of electric current at all.

that's correct, but it doesn't stop a stream of electrons flowing ( controlled or otherwise) between two points in a vacuum :smile:
 
davenn said:
that's correct, but it doesn't stop a stream of electrons flowing ( controlled or otherwise) between two points in a vacuum :smile:
But is that current? Can it do work? (particularly sustained work?)
 
phinds said:
But is that current? Can it do work? (particularly sustained work?)

yes it's current ... how do you think an tube works ?

Photo of an EL34-B power vacuum tube with a glass envelope, internal grid and plate structure, and a brown bakelite base with pins, labelled Electron Tube and MADE IN CHINA.
or the older TV picture tube ?

Cutaway diagram of a colour CRT television picture tube showing the electron gun with three filaments and cathodes, accelerating grids, focus grid, scanning coils (yoke), high voltage anode, electron beams, shadow mask and phosphor coating.


There is a current flowing from the cathode to anode across the vacuum :smile:Dave
 
phinds said:
AAAGGG. Tubes. I hate tubes. Bah humbug.

They were wonderful things for keeping the radio shack warm on cold winter nights :smile:
 
davenn said:
They were wonderful things for keeping the radio shack warm on cold winter nights :smile:
Yes, and they were TERRIFIC in Mcintosh amps and preamps but I still hate them. It's a long story.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: davenn