Tantalum vs Ceramic Capacitors

  • Thread starter wzheng1837
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Capacitors
In summary, ceramics have lower ESR and higher ripple current, and so are good for bypass caps. They also change capacitance when AC voltage is high enough. Tantalums generally have lower operating voltage compared to ceramics, and so they have less energy storage ability as a technology. They also are polarized and have higher leakage. Tantalums are good when you need to introduce some ESR such as in LDO designs that the data sheet requires you to use a tantalum output capacitor for regulation stability.
  • #1
wzheng1837
10
0
Hi Guys,

I'm doing a research on capacitors and wondering if someone would be so kind to give me some help.

I understand that both tantalum and ceramic capacitors can be used in smartphone/tablets.

I'm wondering:

1) What's the advantage of one versus the other?
2) What is the market trend today? (tantalum caps replacing ceramic caps in cellphones? or the other way around?)

Thanks in advance for help!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
wzheng1837 said:
Hi Guys,
I'm doing a research on capacitors and wondering if someone would be so kind to give me some help.
I understand that both tantalum and ceramic capacitors can be used in smartphone/tablets.
I'm wondering:
1) What's the advantage of one versus the other?
2) What is the market trend today? (tantalum caps replacing ceramic caps in cellphones? or the other way around?)
Thanks in advance for help!


they have very different uses, for a start tantalum ones are polarised like the aluminium can type that we have already discussed in your other thread
ceramic capacitors are not polarised.
therefore they are not interchangeable in a circuit, so your comment about tant's replacing ceramics is incorrect.
Tantalum caps as had been also discussed in your other thread are more commonly replacing aluminium can caps because in general they are available in much smaller SMD sizes to suit miniature electronics as found in cellphones etc

Dave
 
  • #3
Try Wikipedia for descriptions of each.
 
  • #4
Ceramics have lower ESR and higher ripple current, and so are good for bypass caps. Ceramics are known to produce voltage spikes at transients that are near their rated voltage and need to be derated. They also change capacitance when AC voltage is high enough.

Tantalums generally have lower operating voltage compared to ceramics, and so they have less energy storage ability as a technology. They also are polarized and have higher leakage. Tantalums are good when you need to introduce some ESR such as in LDO designs that the data sheet requires you to use a tantalum output capacitor for regulation stability.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
DragonPetter said:
Ceramics have lower ESR and higher ripple current, and so are good for bypass caps. Ceramics are known to produce voltage spikes at transients that are near their rated voltage and need to be derated. They also change capacitance when AC voltage is high enough.

Tantalums generally have lower operating voltage compared to ceramics, and so they have less energy storage ability as a technology. They also are polarized and have higher leakage. Tantalums are good when you need to introduce some ESR such as in LDO designs that the data sheet requires you to use a tantalum output capacitor for regulation stability.

This is true, but a ceramic can work if a low valued series resistor is added. A ceramic in series with a 0.22 ohm resistor or so, is more predictable than relying on the tantalum inherent esr. The cap vendor only specifies a maximum esr. The actual value is not very consistent or predictable.

I agree that the inherent esr in a tantalum can be an advantage. A ceramic has such a low esr, that when it is combined with an inductor in an L-C filter, the Q can be very high. Such high Q values can result in under-damped transient response, i.e. "ringing". An R-C damper can be added to lower the Q, or a series resistor can be added to the inductor.

Claude
 
  • #6
In my experience this has been an evolving story.
About 15 years ago we began a transition from aluminium electrolytics to tantalums because of their smaller size per uf. Lately we have shifted from tantalums to ceramics for several reasons:
1 - tantalum prices rose significantly and lead times became quite long.
2 - MLCC ceramic capacitor technology advanced to the point where large "bulk" capacitor values became available at low cost.
3 - we had several instances of high failure rate of tantalums due to surge current. Tantalums are prone to this failure, ceramics are not.

The increase in price and lead time of tantalums was due to several factors including competition with high value ceramics which had become available, and tantalum being listed as a "conflict mineral".

This does not mean that ceramics are a panacea. We have had issues with microfracturing of large ceramic capacitors. We recently substituted a tantalum in place of a ceramic to mitigate a microphonics issue caused by the piezoelectric behavior of the large ceramic part. We are also noticing that the capacitance value of large ceramic capacitors is strongly dependent on the DC voltage applied, so we have to consider derating more carefully.
 
Last edited:

1. What are the main differences between tantalum and ceramic capacitors?

Tantalum capacitors are made of a metal called tantalum, while ceramic capacitors are made of a ceramic material. Tantalum capacitors are polarized, meaning they have a positive and negative lead, while ceramic capacitors are non-polarized. Tantalum capacitors have a higher capacitance and can handle higher voltages, but are more expensive. Ceramic capacitors have a lower capacitance and voltage rating, but are more cost-effective.

2. Which type of capacitor is better for high frequency applications?

Ceramic capacitors are better suited for high frequency applications due to their low inductance and low impedance at high frequencies. Tantalum capacitors have higher inductance, which can cause issues with high frequency circuits.

3. How do the materials used in tantalum and ceramic capacitors affect their performance?

The materials used in tantalum and ceramic capacitors have different dielectric constants, which affect their capacitance values. Tantalum capacitors have a higher dielectric constant, resulting in a higher capacitance. Ceramic capacitors have a lower dielectric constant, resulting in a lower capacitance. This also affects their voltage ratings, as ceramic capacitors are only suitable for lower voltages due to their lower dielectric strength.

4. What are the advantages and disadvantages of using tantalum and ceramic capacitors?

The advantages of tantalum capacitors include their high capacitance, high voltage rating, and low leakage current. However, they are more expensive and have a lower temperature tolerance compared to ceramic capacitors. Ceramic capacitors are more cost-effective, have a wider temperature range, and are suitable for high frequency applications. Their disadvantages include lower capacitance and voltage ratings, as well as the risk of microphonic noise due to their piezoelectric properties.

5. Which type of capacitor is more commonly used in electronic devices?

Ceramic capacitors are more commonly used in electronic devices due to their cost-effectiveness and versatility. They are suitable for a wide range of applications and are often used in high volume production. Tantalum capacitors are typically used in more specialized or high-performance applications, where their specific properties are required.

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Electrical Engineering
2
Replies
41
Views
5K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top