The force of 9.8 Newtons. torque equated to watts

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the feasibility of using a hydro gravity generator powered by buoyancy to achieve 800 watts of energy. The original poster seeks to understand how much air needs to be released to generate this power, but the responses highlight that the proposed method resembles a perpetual motion machine, which violates conservation of energy principles. It is noted that traditional hydroelectric systems are much more efficient, and the calculations suggest that achieving 800 watts would require significant buoyancy and specific ascent rates. The conversation emphasizes that while using buoyancy for energy generation is theoretically possible, the practicality and efficiency of such a system are questionable. Ultimately, the method proposed is not considered a viable energy storage solution.
thesleeper000
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Im makeing a hydro gravity genoratetor I need to no how much air to release to give 800w
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
thesleeper000 said:
Im makeing a hydro gravity genoratetor I need to no how much air to release to give 800w

Welcome to the PF.

Since it's a hydro generator, why are you asking about air? Not understanding the question so far...
 
the air is conpressed down 30 feet of pipe in water released into a bag connected to a bike chain the air rises in the water turning a cogg connected to a genorator.
How much air do i need to release to achive 800w. Or how many kg of force/air to achive 1w of power
 
thesleeper000 said:
the air is conpressed down 30 feet of pipe in water released into a bag connected to a bike chain the air rises in the water turning a cogg connected to a genorator.
How much air do i need to release to achive 800w. Or how many kg of force/air to achive 1w of power

That's not how hydro generators work...
 
I no
This is a generator that uses water and gravity .What would you call It ?
Do you no the answer or not ?
 
thesleeper000 said:
I no
This is a generator that uses water and gravity .What would you call It ?
Do you no the answer or not ?

I do know what a hydroelectric generator is. You are talking about using pumped air for something, so that would be called something different. It also sounds very inefficient. Standard hydroelectric power generation is very efficient (~90%):

www.usbr.gov/power/edu/pamphlet.pdf

Why would you want to have to power an air pump to try to tap power out of your arrangement?
 
This looks a lot to me like a buoyancy-based perpetual motion machine:

Step 1: Air compressor inflates a bag underwater.
Step 2: Bag rises, pulling a cable or chain, which turns an electric generator, which powers the air compressor and produces excess energy.
Step 3: Balloon reaches the surface, deflates, and sinks. Go to Step 1.

Is this what you are trying to do, thesleeper? If so, it is not possible, as it clearly violates conservation of energy.

However, the power calculation: power is buoyant force times the ascent rate of the bag. The problems are:
1. Buoyant force is variable, since the bag expands as it rises.
2. Ascent rate is difficult, since it depends on the drag of the water and is probably going to want to be a pre-selected value to give you constant RPM in your generator.

Figure for a rough guess, you'll want the bag to rise at most 1 m/s, so you'll need 800N of buoyancy, which based on water's weight density requires .08 cubic meters of displacement. Pressure is determined by starting depth.

And if this is about perpetual motion, we'll probably need to lock the thread...
 
Last edited:
Hi Russ
This is not a perpetual motion machine .
The compresser is powered by a wind turbine and sola panel.
Charging a 12 v battery .
The bouyancy power is an alternative when no wind or sola.
In theory can bouyancy force run a asinchronised generator to power a microwave 800w if so how much air needs to be released at 10m to achive 800w.
Or should I work backwards shaft torque is x bouyancy force is y ascent rate is z start depth 10m so y + z = x
 
thesleeper000 said:
how much air needs to be released at 10m to achive 800w.
.08 cubic meters, at any depth. But it'll need to be deep in order to give you more than a few seconds of power.

This is not a great way to store energy.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top