Thermodynamics -- Internal Energy

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a thermodynamics problem involving the internal energy of a gas, its expansion, and the calculations of work done, final volume, and final pressure. Participants are attempting to solve a homework problem related to the principles of thermodynamics, specifically focusing on the relationships between pressure, volume, and internal energy during an expansion process.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses confusion about the correct formula to use for calculating the final volume and pressure, indicating a need for clarification on the relationship between internal energy and work done.
  • Another participant requests a detailed calculation of the work done, specifying the need to clarify whether it is the work done by the gas or on the gas.
  • There is a discussion about the sign convention for work done, with one participant stating that the work done is negative due to the expansion of the gas.
  • Participants explore the integral form of work done during expansion, with one participant rewriting the equation based on the given condition of pv² being constant.
  • One participant claims to have found the correct final volume and pressure after performing calculations, while another participant seeks clarification on how to arrive at the same results.
  • There is a request for substitution details to verify the calculation of the final volume, with participants sharing their attempts and results, leading to further discussion about potential errors in calculations.
  • One participant corrects another regarding the units used in their calculations, suggesting that a conversion from kJ and kbars is necessary for accurate results.
  • Another participant acknowledges a mistake in their calculations after receiving feedback, indicating a collaborative effort to refine understanding and correct errors.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the calculations, as there are multiple attempts to derive the final volume and pressure, with some participants arriving at different results. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the correct approach and calculations needed to achieve the expected outcomes.

Contextual Notes

There are limitations in the discussion regarding the assumptions made about the constants and the specific conditions of the gas expansion. Participants express uncertainty about the correct application of formulas and the implications of sign conventions in their calculations.

BurningUrge
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
I've read back and forth in my chapter and tried consulting with my formula sheet, but I cannot seem to find the correct formula. I bet I am looking at this question wrong, but I am fairly sure I need to use the -100 kJ for something to find the final volume and pressure , along with the given pv2=constant.

Basically, given the information below, how would you go about starting to solve this?

Homework Statement


A mass of gas at an initial pressure of 28 bar, and with an internal energy og 1500 kJ, is contained in a well-insulated cylinder of volume 0.06m3. The gas is allowed to expand behind a piston until it's internal energy is 1400 kJ; the law of expansion is pv2=constant. Calculate:

1) the work done (Already calculated, -100kJ)
2) the final volume
3) the final pressure

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
Please show your calculation of the work done, specifying whether it is the work done by the gas on the surroundings, or the work done by the surroundings on the gas.

Chet
 
Okay, so the work done is by the internal energy as it expands.

So Q + W = U1-U2. Since there is no heat transfer, only work done, it's basically only W = U1-U2.

W = 1500 kJ - 1400 kJ => W = 100 kJ. But since it's an expansion done BY the internal energy as it is allowed to expand, it's -100kJ.
 
BurningUrge said:
Okay, so the work done is by the internal energy as it expands.

So Q + W = U1-U2. Since there is no heat transfer, only work done, it's basically only W = U1-U2.

W = 1500 kJ - 1400 kJ => W = 100 kJ. But since it's an expansion done BY the internal energy as it is allowed to expand, it's -100kJ.
The equation should be Q + W = U2-U1. That's why W is negative (using the sign convention that W represents work done on the system).

Now you need to develop another equation for expressing the work in terms of the pressure and volumes. What is the equation you learned for determining the work as an integral involving pressure and volume?

Chet
 
That would quite probably be this nifty little thing;

W = -∫pdV , from position 1 to 2. (Couldn't find the icon for definite integral)

Since pv2 = Constant, I rewrite the equation to -> -∫ c/V2 dV, => -c ∫ 1/V2 dV => -p1V12 ∫ 1/V dV.

When I can't write the correct definite integral it looks abit messy, but the finished integration should look like this;

-p1V12 (-1/V2-(-1/V1)

Finishing this off with :

-p1V12 (-1/V2-(-1/V1) = -100kJ

Am I currently on the right path?
 
BurningUrge said:
That would quite probably be this nifty little thing;

W = -∫pdV , from position 1 to 2. (Couldn't find the icon for definite integral)

Since pv2 = Constant, I rewrite the equation to -> -∫ c/V2 dV, => -c ∫ 1/V2 dV => -p1V12 ∫ 1/V dV.

When I can't write the correct definite integral it looks abit messy, but the finished integration should look like this;

-p1V12 (-1/V2-(-1/V1)

Finishing this off with :

-p1V12 (-1/V2-(-1/V1) = -100kJAm I currently on the right path?
Yes. I haven't checked your "arithmetic," but you're on the right path.

Chet
 
Okay, so I did that. And I came up with the right answers.

V2=0.148m3

And using that I could find the pressure as well with p1V12=p2V22

Ending at p2=4.6 bar.

Greatly appreciate your time and help!
 
BurningUrge said:
That would quite probably be this nifty little thing;

W = -∫pdV , from position 1 to 2. (Couldn't find the icon for definite integral)

Since pv2 = Constant, I rewrite the equation to -> -∫ c/V2 dV, => -c ∫ 1/V2 dV => -p1V12 ∫ 1/V dV.

When I can't write the correct definite integral it looks abit messy, but the finished integration should look like this;

-p1V12 (-1/V2-(-1/V1)

Finishing this off with :

-p1V12 (-1/V2-(-1/V1) = -100kJ

Am I currently on the right path?
I tried substituting into this formula you used but am not getting V2=0.148,am getting different answer.can you show your working here on how you got V2= 0.148 given the intial pressure and volume
 
Welcome to the PF. :smile:
Kc emefo said:
I tried substituting into this formula you used but am not getting V2=0.148,am getting different answer.can you show your working here on how you got V2= 0.148 given the intial pressure and volume
This thread has been inactive for 5 years, but perhaps @Chestermiller can offer his thoughts...
 
  • #10
berkeman said:
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

This thread has been inactive for 5 years, but perhaps @Chestermiller can offer his thoughts...
Thank you,can you help me out with the appropriate substitution to arrive at the given answer V2=0.148m @berkeman
 
  • #11
Kc emefo said:
Thank you,can you help me out with the appropriate substitution to arrive at the given answer V2=0.148m @berkeman
Please show us the details of what you have done so far.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU
  • #12
Substituting with the value of P1=28bar V1=0.06 and n=2 into the given equation:
2.8× 10^6×0.06^2(1/V2-1/0.06)=-100
Opening bracket:
10080(1/V2-1/0.06)=-100
10080/V2-1/0.06=-100
10080/V2-16.66=-100
Cross multiple and make V2 subject of formula:
10080-16.66=-100V2
10063.34/-100=-100V2/-100
V2=-100.6334
That is what am getting, please correct me if am wrong
 
  • #13
You are working in kJ and kbars. So that 2.8x10^6 should be 2.8x10^3.
 
  • #14
Chestermiller said:
You are working in kJ and kbars. So that 2.8x10^6 should be 2.8x10^3.
Oh I got that,jus substituted 2.8×10^3 instead of 2.8×10^6 and my V2=1.5792 which is wrong,am still not getting the suppose as V2=0.148
 
  • #15
Kc emefo said:
Oh I got that,jus substituted 2.8×10^3 instead of 2.8×10^6 and my V2=1.5792 which is wrong,am still not getting the suppose as V2=0.148
check your math
 
  • #16
Chestermiller said:
check your math
Oh thank you very much sir,I just figured out my mistake and corrected it
Am grateful for that correction
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
12K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
23
Views
5K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
9K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K