TI-83 from 1997 worth an upgrade?

  • Context: Calculators 
  • Thread starter Thread starter dimensionless
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    ti-83
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the potential upgrade from a TI-83 calculator, believed to be from 1997, to a newer model, particularly the TI-89. Participants explore the performance, features, and utility of these calculators in various educational contexts, including high school and college mathematics.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions the necessity of upgrading from a TI-83, asking if newer models offer significantly better performance or features.
  • Another participant expresses a preference for the TI-89, highlighting its capabilities in symbolic math, which the TI-83 may lack.
  • Some participants mention that the TI-89 can perform advanced functions like differentiation, integration, and matrix algebra, which may be beneficial for higher-level math courses.
  • Concerns are raised about the use of calculators in exams, with one participant noting that calculators are not allowed in math classes but may be permitted in physics.
  • Several participants share personal experiences with the TI-89, emphasizing its utility for checking work and solving complex problems, while also noting that it may not show the work involved in solving problems.
  • One participant suggests that while the TI-89 is powerful, the attitude of needing it for success in college could be misleading and potentially harmful.
  • Another participant reflects on their positive experience with both the TI-83 and TI-89, using them for different purposes, including homework and quick calculations.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of opinions regarding the necessity and utility of upgrading from the TI-83 to the TI-89. Some advocate for the upgrade due to the advanced features of the TI-89, while others argue that the TI-83 may still suffice for certain tasks. The discussion remains unresolved with multiple competing views on the topic.

Contextual Notes

Participants acknowledge that the effectiveness of a calculator may depend on the specific math course requirements and personal study habits. There are also mentions of limitations regarding calculator use in exams, which may influence the decision to upgrade.

dimensionless
Messages
461
Reaction score
1
I have a TI-83 that I got way back in high school. My best guess is that it is from 1997. Given the huge advance in computing technology, is there any good reason to upgrade itr? Do the new ones have significantly better performance? significantly better features?
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
I love my TI-89. If there's any routine math thing that I don't want to spend time doing manually, it will probably do it. I don't know what a TI-83 does differently, never having owned one. I don't think it makes a difference that you got it in 1997--probably the only thing that matters is the model.
 
Are you allowed to use calculators beyond high school maths?

Something worth considering if upgrading for college...
 
Yes, just not in math class.
 
It depends. The 89 has a lot of symbolic math it can do (almost anything from first year calculus, and then some), which is very useful sometimes. But as far as number crunching goes, not a lot of improvement. Mostly I like having the 89 to check my work on more difficult integrals or differential equations (it can do both symbolically).
 
The 89 can also do matrix algebra, statistics and a lot of other stuff and is easier to program. I used to have an 86 and I think I remember that graphing is a lot faster on the 89.
 
Not sure if the TI-83 can differentiate or integrate, but I know my TI 89 can and it helps a lot to check my answers and save me from tough times.
 
I have a solar t-83 from I think around 1988, it has never failed on me and I still use it a lot. It does statistics but not symbolic, calculus, or matrices. Is there a solar version of the t-89? I might pop for one of those.
 
I got a ti89 in high school cause my friend got one, and i needed a graphing calculator to fit in...cause everyone had those ti83 and i wanted one to so i could play games...cause a calculator that can play games is cool somehow... Anyways my friend got a ti89, and when i saw the kinda games that thing i could play... i knew i had to have one to... when i bought it, i could of had a ti92...the price was same cause store was going out of buisness, but i wouldn't of been allowed to use a ti92 on any real test like sat...

anyway to sum it up... i didn't know about the ti89's abilities to factor and expand and do derivatives and integrals and solve stuff like this solve(x + 2 = 3,x) and it tells me x = 1... or more complicated situations like solve(x+y = 1 and x = 1,x) and it says x = 1 and y = 1...

So anways as i got into higher and higher math, i learned more and more about what it could do... even in college I'm still finding out about things it can do.

o yea, did i mention i was using a ti89 when i was like a sophmore in high school... was great in algebra 2 and trignometry and geometry... was made even better cause i had the black link cable (so i could send games to it) which allowed me to send math programs to it... some of which i had on the thing since i downloaded them years ago...and still getting use out of them!

I really suggest you get a ti89 titanium... it has a faster processor and more memory then my hardware version 1 original ti89. Also it can use a regular usb cable to send files to it.

I can't stress this enough...you are going to need a ti89 in college... it will help you learn... and a ti89 needs years to stumble through all it's features so sooner you get it the better.

I should also add that in college, I'm not allowed any calculator on any math exam! and I've had lots of them, however physics let's me use a ti89, or any calculator... they say its cause physics is not a test of your math solving capabilities... it's about your capability to do physics.

Did i mention...get a ti89 titanium!

o yea you totally need to get this program on ti89 asap, if you get one: http://www.technicalc.org/packages/eqw/eqw.htm

its a program for symbolic entering of math formulas... bets pants off of doing it manually for let's say, a 3x3 matrix... god linear algebra sucks with all the matrixes :P
 
  • #10
FocusedWolf said:
I got a ti89 in high school cause my friend got one, and i needed a graphing calculator to fit in...cause everyone had those ti83 and i wanted one to so i could play games...cause a calculator that can play games is cool somehow... Anyways my friend got a ti89, and when i saw the kinda games that thing i could play... i knew i had to have one to... when i bought it, i could of had a ti92...the price was same cause store was going out of buisness, but i wouldn't of been allowed to use a ti92 on any real test like sat...

anyway to sum it up... i didn't know about the ti89's abilities to factor and expand and do derivatives and integrals and solve stuff like this solve(x + 2 = 3,x) and it tells me x = 1... or more complicated situations like solve(x+y = 1 and x = 1,x) and it says x = 1 and y = 1...

So anways as i got into higher and higher math, i learned more and more about what it could do... even in college I'm still finding out about things it can do.

o yea, did i mention i was using a ti89 when i was like a sophmore in high school... was great in algebra 2 and trignometry and geometry... was made even better cause i had the black link cable (so i could send games to it) which allowed me to send math programs to it... some of which i had on the thing since i downloaded them years ago...and still getting use out of them!

I really suggest you get a ti89 titanium... it has a faster processor and more memory then my hardware version 1 original ti89. Also it can use a regular usb cable to send files to it.

I can't stress this enough...you are going to need a ti89 in college... it will help you learn... and a ti89 needs years to stumble through all it's features so sooner you get it the better.

This is exactly the kind of attitude I would advise against. It is a very powerful and useful tool, but the attitude that you 'need' one is not only incorrect, but dangerous.
 
  • #11
It's just odd to blow 100 something dollars on a ti83 which is nothing more then a regular calcuator + some math functions and way to graph in 2d.

The thing is the ti89 doesn't show you the work to solve stuff... its just answers which is always not enough on a math or physics test, unless it's something multiple choice. Also the answers would only be for a solve(), or factor(), or expand()... or whatever the ti83 can tell you todo...and it graphs in 3d which is nice in calc3.

The point is you still need to know how to do the problems and having a ti89 is not enough.

My college doesn't even let anyone take any form of calculator into a math exam...and yet i still find my ti89 indispensable.

In college the ti89 feels inadaquate most of the time, unless your doing something simple like adding a vector, or doing a quick crossproduct.. It's good for doing simple stuff you know how to do...fast...when showing the work doesn't matter...and checking your work on things your learning... like my first calc homework i can remember was about taking the derivative of stuff and i'd do the work and pop the problem into my calc to see if my answer matched.
 
Last edited:
  • #12
I remember buying my 83 off of some senior when I was a freshmen in high school. I bought it for 20 bucks... Best purchase I have ever made. Anyway, last year I bought a Ti-89 because it was something like 50 dollars off (it was an amazing deal, when compared to what it usually cost... even with that 50 dollars off it's a rip off considering what you can REALLY buy for that amount of money...) and I love it. I use it strictly for checking my work and everything has been awesome. I love having my Ti-83 next to me at my computer desk as well, as it is very useful when calculating something that pops into my head... Also, I loved having my 89 during my differential equations course when doing the homework. Sometimes when I did not have enough time to do a lot of the homework, I skipped through the easy parts of the problems by solving them on the calculator and simply making sure that I knew how to do the actual new parts...
 
  • #13
FocusedWolf said:
In college the ti89 feels inadaquate most of the time, unless your doing something simple like adding a vector, or doing a quick crossproduct..

Then you've become overly dependent on it. You should never use a calculator to do anything you can't do by hand. The calculator should only to be a tool to verify answers, and at times expedite number crunching. Nothing more.
 
  • #14
89 is horrible for graphing in 3d IMHO. You need shading and color to properly view something in 3d.

If you are choosing between an 89 and an 83 go with the 89. The 83's a joke compared to the 89.
 
  • #15
If you are an engineer, forget about Ti-83. Unless you don't mind wasting exam time solving matrices, cross and dot products, solving bunch of equations by hand for your mechanics classes.
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
7K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
9K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
29K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
9K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
11K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
6K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
6K