# Topology help

#### kiriyama

Give an example of a set X with two topologies T and S such that the identity function from (X,T) to (X,S) is continuous but not homeomorphic.

I always struggle with these because I get overwhelmed by the generality that it has. Any ideas would be very much appreciated.

#### AKG

Homework Helper
What are the definitions of "continuous" and "homeomorphic"? Also, this post should be in the Homework Help section.

#### kiriyama

i apologize i am new here....just looked for the first place that seemed appropriate

and i assume the definitions to be the standard ones....

continuous:
T and S are topologies and F:X->Y; for each S open subset V of Y, f^-1(V) is a T open subset of X

and homeomorphic:
f is one to one, onto, continuous, and open

#### AKG

Homework Helper
Okay, and if I is the identity function from (X,T) to (X,S), V is a subset of X, what is I-1(V)? If U is a subset X, what is I(U)? Now if I is not a homeomorphism, it has to fail to have at least one of the four properties you listed under the definition of homeomorphic. If we are trying to find an example when I is continuous, then there is in fact only one of those four properties of homeomorphism that I would fail to have. Which is it?

#### kiriyama

i believe youre over complicating this

im looking for an example of a set X that has two topologies T and S that has an identity function from (X,T) to (X,S) that is continuous but not homeomorphic

i already know that given any space X and two topologies T and S, (X,T) and (X,S) are never homeomorphic.

im just looking for an example of this

#### mathwonk

Homework Helper
you are looking for a set with two topologies, one contained in the other. ho hum.

try a 2 point set.

#### kiriyama

using a particular point topology?

or what?

can you please explain

i mean i get where youre headed but im trying to find the missing step in between

#### kiriyama

nvmd...i got it....took a little longer than i hoped but i got it now

thanks for the help

### The Physics Forums Way

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving