- #1
girts
- 186
- 22
This is a thought experiment so the mentioned values are only for example purpose.
I was wondering about an electrical train. So here is the setup, we have rails and an electric train with an overhead wire. In one case the train gets its power from DC and in the other case the train is powered by AC say 50hz.
Now to make the idea simpler let's suppose that in both cases the train is traveling in a vacuum and the speed of the E field is the speed of light - c, as opposed to the speed of the E field being a fraction of c in other mediums like metal wire under Earth's atmosphere.
In the case of DC power the voltage is uniform across the length of the wire and there are no changes in voltage or current so no matter how fast the train runs it always feels a constant voltage and field strength from the wire correct?
What interests me is what happens in the case of AC, now the frequency is low only 50hz but as we know the changes in E field travel at c in a vacuum, so every time the current changes direction in the AC sinewave that change in direction travels along the wire at the speed of c.
Now what happens if our train also travels at c along the tracks? (I do realize it is impossible but just for the argument) Say the train somehow got synchronized with the moment when the current and voltage was zero on the sine crossing the middle point in the cycle, and this change travels along the wire at c but so does the train travel along at c, does that mean that from the trains perspective there is no power at all in the overhead wire along the whole length of the wire?
If I am correct in my question can this then be compared to the "slip" in the asynchronous induction motor where the rotor doesn't get any induced current if it turns at the same speed as the field rotates in the stator field coils?
Only in the induction motor case the rotor doesn't rotate anywhere near the speed of which the E field changes in the wires but instead it rotates at the speed of which one coil becomes deenergized while another one becomes energized which is normally 50/60hz.
I do realize that this is a complicated question and maybe not the best writing from my part but I thank you for any insights.
I was wondering about an electrical train. So here is the setup, we have rails and an electric train with an overhead wire. In one case the train gets its power from DC and in the other case the train is powered by AC say 50hz.
Now to make the idea simpler let's suppose that in both cases the train is traveling in a vacuum and the speed of the E field is the speed of light - c, as opposed to the speed of the E field being a fraction of c in other mediums like metal wire under Earth's atmosphere.
In the case of DC power the voltage is uniform across the length of the wire and there are no changes in voltage or current so no matter how fast the train runs it always feels a constant voltage and field strength from the wire correct?
What interests me is what happens in the case of AC, now the frequency is low only 50hz but as we know the changes in E field travel at c in a vacuum, so every time the current changes direction in the AC sinewave that change in direction travels along the wire at the speed of c.
Now what happens if our train also travels at c along the tracks? (I do realize it is impossible but just for the argument) Say the train somehow got synchronized with the moment when the current and voltage was zero on the sine crossing the middle point in the cycle, and this change travels along the wire at c but so does the train travel along at c, does that mean that from the trains perspective there is no power at all in the overhead wire along the whole length of the wire?
If I am correct in my question can this then be compared to the "slip" in the asynchronous induction motor where the rotor doesn't get any induced current if it turns at the same speed as the field rotates in the stator field coils?
Only in the induction motor case the rotor doesn't rotate anywhere near the speed of which the E field changes in the wires but instead it rotates at the speed of which one coil becomes deenergized while another one becomes energized which is normally 50/60hz.
I do realize that this is a complicated question and maybe not the best writing from my part but I thank you for any insights.