Truss Prob: finding the force in a member

5 replies · 3K views · last reply
lazypast
Messages
83
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The diagram is attached. I must solve using method of sections the force in member HG.



Homework Equations


ƩF(y) = 0, ƩF(x) = 0, ƩM = 0


The Attempt at a Solution



My hand-drawn pic shows the section.
Solving vertically, ƩF(y) = 0
F(DG)cos45 = 10
F(DG) = 14.1kN

Moments about E
10(2) + 2F(DG)cos45 + 2F(HG) = 0
Dividing by 2 and rearranging:
F(HG) = -10 - 14.1cos45 = -20kN



I don't think I'd have a problem if there wasn't a pulley system and I can only assume the reason I'm not getting the correct answer for F(HG) is because I'm not taking into account the effect the pulley has.

Can anyone advise a nudge in the right direct... ?
 
Attachments
  • Labelled truss diagram (a) of a crane-like frame with joints A to K, members dimensioned 2, 2, 2 and 2.5 m, a pulley at H and F, a cable hanging a 1000 kg load, and a pinned support at C and K.
    IMG00048-20121126-1330.jpg
    21.5 KB · Views: 758
  • Hand-drawn truss section diagram on grid paper: a triangular frame with a 45 degree angle, a pulley at the lower right with a cable running to a 10kN load, and cut forces labelled FDE, FDG and FHG marked along a dashed section line.
    IMG00049-20121126-1336.jpg
    53 KB · Views: 619
Well, what effect does the pulley have on the truss? Can the pulley be replaced by equivalent forces at the end of the truss?
 
Your free body diagram looks right. Now take a moment around G to find what member DE is. Next, sum the forces in x and y to find DG and GH.

Was I helpful to you with this? I really struggled with trusses in statics and now have a really good understanding of how to solve these problems.
 
In your free body diagram you need to identify the value of the horizontal force at the top of the pulley. What do think that is? (in theory, and in reality)
 
I have attached my workings out to find the reactions at the supports. Originally I was taking the total external forces at face value (i.e 10kN vertically down) but now I can see because the pulley system support is not connected to the structure there are extra forces.



Going back to the original FBD, I'll add and resolve with a horizontal force of 10kN in there, too. I've attached my workings out.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten free-body diagram of a rigid frame with 2 m spans, two 10 kN point loads at the top right, reaction labels Hc, Rc and Rk, and moment-about-C working giving Rk = 40 kN up and Rc = 20 kN down.
    Reactions.jpg
    20.2 KB · Views: 606
  • Handwritten equilibrium working: sum of Fy = 0 gives F1 + F2 cos45 + F3 + 10 = 0; sum of Fx = 0 gives F2 cos45 = 10, so F2 = 14.14 kN; sum of Mo = 0 gives F3 = (-20 - 20 - 20)/2 = -30 kN.
    IMG00051-20121129-0907.jpg
    21.8 KB · Views: 588
Reactions look good, but meanings of F1 F2 and F3 not well-defined.