Twin Paradox with radioactive twins

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
31 replies · 3K views
PAllen said:
I’ve always considered that many muons are created at much lower altitude than 10 km, where the atmosphere is denser. However, looking at the density as a function of altitude, it does appear 10 km would be a reasonable median creation altitude. But there is also the question of muon energy. I think many are created with ##\gamma## greater than 5, some much greater (even over 100).
Actually, I just checked and found the average muon energy at creation is well over 4 GeV, which is a ##\gamma## of over 40. Thus, my statement was correct. For some reason, hyperphysics is using a plausible creation altitude, but a way too low energy. There are even substantial numbers of muons created with ##\gamma## of 40,000 or more.

[edit: as a further aside, I note that the cosmic ray muon spectrum is regularly measured out to 100 TEV, which corresponds to a ##\gamma## of 1 million. For such a muon, it would appear only 1 cm of atmosphere passed by before the ground hits.]
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and jbriggs444
Physics news on Phys.org
PAllen said:
Actually, I just checked and found the average muon energy at creation is well over 4 GeV, which is a ##\gamma## of over 40. Thus, my statement was correct. For some reason, hyperphysics is using a plausible creation altitude, but a way too low energy. There are even substantial numbers of muons created with ##\gamma## of 40,000 or more.

[edit: as a further aside, I note that the cosmic ray muon spectrum is regularly measured out to 100 TEV, which corresponds to a ##\gamma## of 1 million. For such a muon, it would appear only 1 cm of atmosphere passed by before the ground hits.]
And this page of hyperphysics has the correct number - no idea why the muon experiment page uses misleading numbers:

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Particles/muonatm.html