Two Functions with the Same Derivative

In summary, the poster is attempting to prove that two different functions with the same derivative differ only by a constant, without using the mean value theorem. The poster has defined a function T(x) with a derivative of 0 and is attempting to prove that this implies T(x) is a constant function. However, they are encountering difficulties and there may be a requirement for continuity in the proof.
  • #1
Bashyboy
1,421
5

Homework Statement


I am trying to prove without using the mean value theorem that two different functions with the same derivative differ only by a constant. Is it possible to do this without the mean value theorem? If so, would someone help guide me towards the right solution.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



Let ##f'(x) = h(x)## and ##g'(x) = h(x)##. Define the function ##T(x) = h(x) - g(x)##, which has the derivative ##T'(x) = 0## for all ##x##. If I could prove that the derivative of a function being identically zero implies that the function is a constant, then I would be finished; however, even this is giving trouble.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
What's wrong with the mean value theorem approach?
Use the definition of a derivative on T.
 
  • #3
Because the mean value theorem isn't available to me.

##T'(x) = \lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} \frac{f(z_n) - f(x)}{z_n -x} = 0##

I am not certain how this would be helpful. I know that ##T'(x)## exists because both ##h'(x)## and ##g'(x)## exist, and therefore the limit exists for every sequence ##\{z_n\}## that converges to ##x##. If I could write

##\lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} \frac{f(z_n) - f(x)}{z_n -x} = 0##

as

##\frac{f(z_n) - f(x)}{z_n -x} = 0##

through some argument, then I could arrive at

##f(z_z) = f(x)##.

Because the limit exists for every sequence, I could chose the sequence ##\{z_n\}## so that ##z_n \in [a,b]## for every ##n \in \mathbb{N}## and passes over every point in ##[a,b]##. This would mean that, for any two points in ##[a,b]##, the function ##T(x)## is equal to itself, which would mean it is a constant function. However, I am not sure to make these arguments precise, nor am I certain it is even possible.
 
  • #5
The definition of derivative used on that webpage is one I cannot use; I have to use the sequence definition. Furthermore, I don't need the implication that if f(x) is a constant function, then its derivative is zero; rather, I need the converse--namely, if the derivative of a function is zero, then the function must be a constant one. Those are two different statements.
 
  • #6
I don't need the implication that if f(x) is a constant function, then its derivative is zero; rather, I need the converse--namely, if the derivative of a function is zero, then the function must be a constant one. Those are two different statements.
I know that. One of the ways of proving something is to assume something else and disprove it.
If you know how to find the derivative of a function - then go through the process but set the answer to zero ... then find out which function satisfies that answer.

The sequence definition makes it harder ... but the fact that a derivative of zero means a constant function is a consequence of the definition of the derivative, so you should be able to deduce it from that with some work. The alternative is to use a definition of the anti-derivative.
 
  • #7
So, you are suggesting a proof by contradiction?
 
  • #8
Well, if we suppose the contrary, then statement becomes ##T'(x) = 0## for all ##x \in [a,b]## but ##T(x) \ne k##, where ##k## is some constant. If ##T(x) \ne k##, then it must involve at least one variable term, say ##x##; hence, ##T(x) = x + ...##. The derivative would be ##T'(x) = 1 + ... > 0##, which contradicts the fact that ##T'(x) = 0##.

Obviously this would not suffice as a proof.
 
  • #9
Bashyboy said:
The definition of derivative used on that webpage is one I cannot use; I have to use the sequence definition. Furthermore, I don't need the implication that if f(x) is a constant function, then its derivative is zero; rather, I need the converse--namely, if the derivative of a function is zero, then the function must be a constant one. Those are two different statements.

People make suggestions to you and you say you are not allowed to use those results/methods. What ARE you allowed to use? Are you, for example, allowed to look in a book for some results that have not yet been covered in class, and use them? If you are not allowed to use results not yet proved in class, are you allowed to "copy" out the proof and then use the result? I really do not understand why so many restrictions are being placed on you, or even what those restrictions are.
 
  • #10
Obviously this would not suffice as a proof.
... why is that not sufficient? Can you be explicit?
I think the difficulty you have encountered here is that you have not sufficiently defined your terms.

@Ray: He does not want to use the mean value theorem for derivatives. The definition of the derivative cited is very closely related to the mean value theorem.
I suspect that any attempt at this problem will end up amounting to using the mean value theorem, just starting from a different place. Either that or any useful definition of the derivative will be ruled out, making the problem impossible since what is to be found is no longer defined.
 
  • #11
Bashyboy said:

Homework Statement


I am trying to prove without using the mean value theorem that two different functions with the same derivative differ only by a constant. Is it possible to do this without the mean value theorem? If so, would someone help guide me towards the right solution.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



Let ##f'(x) = h(x)## and ##g'(x) = h(x)##. Define the function ##T(x) = h(x) - g(x)##, which has the derivative ##T'(x) = 0## for all ##x##. If I could prove that the derivative of a function being identically zero implies that the function is a constant, then I would be finished; however, even this is giving trouble.
Maybe what you're trying to prove isn't true.

You may have to specify something about the continuity of the functions
 

1. What does it mean for two functions to have the same derivative?

Two functions having the same derivative means that the rate of change of both functions at any given point is equal. In other words, the slope of their tangent lines at any point on the graph is the same.

2. Can two different functions have the same derivative?

Yes, two different functions can have the same derivative. This is because the derivative only describes the rate of change of a function, and not the specific values of the function itself. For example, both f(x) = 2x and g(x) = x^2 have a derivative of 2, even though they are different functions.

3. How can you tell if two functions have the same derivative?

To determine if two functions have the same derivative, you can take the derivative of both functions and set them equal to each other. If the resulting equations are equivalent, then the two functions have the same derivative.

4. Does having the same derivative mean that two functions are equal?

No, having the same derivative does not necessarily mean that two functions are equal. Two functions can have the same derivative but still have different values at certain points. For example, f(x) = x^2 and g(x) = x^2 + 1 both have a derivative of 2, but they are not equal.

5. Why is it important for two functions to have the same derivative?

It is important for two functions to have the same derivative because it allows us to find the relationship between the two functions. This can be helpful in solving problems involving rates of change and optimization. Additionally, if two functions have the same derivative, we can use the derivative rules to manipulate one function to get the other.

Similar threads

  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
8
Views
300
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
129
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
848
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
588
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
697
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
646
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
15
Views
1K
Back
Top