Two Variable PDE in Open Domain Plane
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
8 replies · 4K views
Discussion
Physics news on Phys.org
TylerH
- 729
- 0
I'd like to know the answer myself. Does [itex]\frac{xU_x}{U}-\frac{xV_x}{V}=\frac{yU_y}{U}-\frac{yV_y}{V}[/itex] make it any easier? I've only dabbled in PDEs myself, but that seems like a separation of variables problem, when rephrased like that.
EDIT: Mathematica gives an error saying the answer is indeterminate, because there are more dependent variables than equations.
EDIT: Mathematica gives an error saying the answer is indeterminate, because there are more dependent variables than equations.
Last edited:
Science Advisor
- 3,385
- 760
TylerH said:I'd like to know the answer myself. Does [itex]\frac{xU_x}{U}-\frac{xV_x}{V}=\frac{yU_y}{U}-\frac{yV_y}{V}[/itex] make it any easier? I've only dabbled in PDEs myself, but that seems like a separation of variables problem, when rephrased like that.
EDIT: Mathematica gives an error saying the answer is indeterminate, because there are more dependent variables than equations.
U = x V = K/x sort of works but doesn't allow the origin or the y axis.
Also the answer is a little trivial.
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 4,662
- 372
So you have:
x d/dx ln (U) -y d/dy ln(U) -1 = xd/dx ln (V) -y d/dy ln(V) +1
x d/dx (ln(U/V))=y d/dy (ln(U/V))+2
Now make a guess of a function of the type U/V = exp(F(x,y))
to get:
x d/dx F = y d/dy F +2
so you have x d/dx F -y d/dy F =2
d/dx (xF) - d/dy (yF) = 2
Don't see how to solve this, though.
p.s the derivatives above are partial btw.
x d/dx ln (U) -y d/dy ln(U) -1 = xd/dx ln (V) -y d/dy ln(V) +1
x d/dx (ln(U/V))=y d/dy (ln(U/V))+2
Now make a guess of a function of the type U/V = exp(F(x,y))
to get:
x d/dx F = y d/dy F +2
so you have x d/dx F -y d/dy F =2
d/dx (xF) - d/dy (yF) = 2
Don't see how to solve this, though.
p.s the derivatives above are partial btw.
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 1,891
- 170
lavinia said:In an open domain in the plane
(xU[itex]_{x}[/itex]-yU[itex]_{y}[/itex]-U)/U =
(xV[itex]_{x}[/itex] - y V[itex]_{y}[/itex]+V)/V
I would rewrite this as
[tex]x \partial_x (\log U) - y \partial_y (\log U) - 1 = x \partial_x (\log V) - y \partial_y (\log V) + 1[/tex]
or
[tex]x \partial_x (\log U - \log V) - y \partial_y (\log U - \log V) = 2[/tex]
Define some function [itex]e^f = U/V[/itex] and you have
[tex]x \partial_x f - y \partial_y f = 2[/tex]
which should be easy to solve by characteristics. Mathematica gives
[tex]f = 2 \log x + C x y[/tex]
for arbitrary C. Then U and V can be any functions satisfying
[tex]\frac{U}{V} = x^2 e^{C x y}[/tex]
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 1,891
- 170
I don't know, I taught myself the method of characteristics when I started running across problems in my research that needed it.
Science Advisor
Gold Member
- 4,662
- 372
Sometime I wonder why I even bother answering. :-/
Science Advisor
- 3,385
- 760
I thank you for this solution and feel that I should explain where this equation came from.
To learn some differential geometry I posed the question of what vector fields on a surface can be tangent to geodesics for some Riemannian metric. Computation led to the condition that a unit length vector field V is tangent to geodesics if its Lie bracket with iV, the unit vector field orthogonal to it, is a multiple of iV (and that this multiple satisfies a differential equation along the geodesic that relates it to the Gauss curvature of the metric).
For the vector field xd/dx - yd/dy in a neighborhood of the origin in the plane, one gets the differential equation in this post. I think your solution shows that the field of hyperbolas y = k/x can be geodesics and that iV can be chosen to be x[itex]^{2}[/itex]d/dx + e[itex]^{-xy}[/itex]d/dy.
So it seems that a vector field of index -1 around a singularity can be a geodesic flow.
I think the Gauss curvature is -1 for this example but I haven't yet done the ugly calculation.
To learn some differential geometry I posed the question of what vector fields on a surface can be tangent to geodesics for some Riemannian metric. Computation led to the condition that a unit length vector field V is tangent to geodesics if its Lie bracket with iV, the unit vector field orthogonal to it, is a multiple of iV (and that this multiple satisfies a differential equation along the geodesic that relates it to the Gauss curvature of the metric).
For the vector field xd/dx - yd/dy in a neighborhood of the origin in the plane, one gets the differential equation in this post. I think your solution shows that the field of hyperbolas y = k/x can be geodesics and that iV can be chosen to be x[itex]^{2}[/itex]d/dx + e[itex]^{-xy}[/itex]d/dy.
So it seems that a vector field of index -1 around a singularity can be a geodesic flow.
I think the Gauss curvature is -1 for this example but I haven't yet done the ugly calculation.
Last edited:
Similar threads
Graduate 1st order PDE, quadratic in derivatives, two variables analytic solution?
- Syntheta
- · Replies 4 ·
- Differential Equations
- Replies
- 4
Finding minimum value of function with two variable
- gevni
- · Replies 7 ·
- Calculus
- Replies
- 7
Undergrad An attempt to find the total differential of a two-variable function
- Kashmir
- · Replies 6 ·
- Calculus
- Replies
- 6
High School Looking for free graphing calculator for two-variable inequality
- Hornbein
- · Replies 4 ·
- General Math
- Replies
- 4
Undergrad Approximation of a function of two variables
- AAMAIK
- · Replies 3 ·
- Calculus
- Replies
- 3
High School Understanding the Quadratic Form Identity in Two-Variable Equations
- Heidi
- · Replies 6 ·
- Topology and Analysis
- Replies
- 6
Can I treat x as constant when differentiating ∫₀ˣ x·sin(t) dt?
- The Head
- · Replies 3 ·
- Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
- Replies
- 3
Solve the Global Minima Problem in Two Variable Functions
- Archimedess
- · Replies 3 ·
- Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
- Replies
- 3
Graduate Ortogonality of two variable functions
- LagrangeEuler
- · Replies 3 ·
- Topology and Analysis
- Replies
- 3
Undergrad Limit of a two variable function
- Drako Amorim
- · Replies 40 ·
- Calculus
- Replies
- 40