Umbrella fabric and diffraction pattern

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Orthoceras
Messages
133
Reaction score
55
It is sometimes said that a distant street lamp seen through a dark coloured umbrella fabric appears like dotted diffraction pattern, as in figure A. However, I have tried several umbrellas but all of them produce a blurred cross, as in figure B. The umbrella fabric superficially looks like a regular 2D grating, with warp and weft threads crossing at right angles, as in figure C.
I guess modern umbrella fabric is somehow different from old umbrellas cloth. What might be the difference? Does anyone happen have an umbrella that produces the dotted diffraction pattern?

Three panels: A shows a dotted diffraction pattern of coloured spots in a regular grid with cross-shaped streaks; B shows a blurred bright cross of light; C shows a close-up of woven fabric beside a ruler marked 0 and 1.

The image of a dotted diffraction pattern at the left is from an image at wikimedia commons
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and Keith_McClary
I had an umbrella that produced a pattern. The five I have access to now do not. I have some fabric with about the same thread count (that was a coat liner) that does produce a pattern. I speculate that there could be a waterproof coating on the newer umbrellas.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: vanhees71 and hutchphd
Waterproof fabric was invented by Charles Macintosh in 1823, I doubt that any 20th century umbrellas would have had no coating.

Another explanation might be the composition of the thread. I put the umbrella fabric under a microscope. It turns out each thread of the umbrella fabric is composed of more than 10 filaments. This type of fabric is called a taffeta, apparently. In the photo, possibly more light passes through the B-areas than through A-areas. Then the diffraction pattern is dominated by the filaments. The filaments are not spaced very regularly. As a result, The diffraction pattern due to B dominates, and it is much wider and more blurred than the diffraction due to A.
Microscope photo of woven umbrella fabric showing a grid of threads with dark and bright crossing areas, labelled A and B, and a thread bundle with filaments annotated on the right.
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: Keith_McClary