Understanding Fundamentals of Electronics: Solving an Electric Charge Problem

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a self-created electric charge problem related to a 1 cm³ iron cube connected to a battery. Key points include the relationship between charge, voltage, and capacitance, with relevant formulas provided for calculating the charge based on the cube's geometry. Participants clarify that grounding affects potential differences and that applying high voltage can lead to electron ejection from the metal. Corrections are made regarding the capacitance formula for the cube, emphasizing the need for ideal conditions in calculations. The conversation highlights the complexities of capacitance measurement and the theoretical underpinnings of electron behavior in electric fields.
vasya
Messages
46
Reaction score
11
Homework Statement
How many electrons will flow into the cube, connected to the 1.5v battery negative terminal, with positive being grounded
Relevant Equations
i dont know
It's not a homework. I came up with this problem myself. Trying to understand fundamentals of electronics. Do you know how to solve it? Is voltage somehow related to electron energy levels? What knowledge should I gain to be able to solve problems like that? Thank you!

If we ground the cathode (+) of a battery with, for example, 1.5v, and connect the anode (-) to an iron cube of 1 cm³

(26 protons in the nucleus,
density - 7.874 g/cm³
Atomic mass - 55.845 (g / mole)
chemical count - 0.1409 mole
atoms - 0.848 *10^22
protons - 22.06 *10^22 and the same number of electrons with zero charge)

How many electrons will flow into the cube, or what will be the charge in it?

ps: the electrostatic field of the Earth does not change, so it's not a capacitor, right?

By the way, if we will apply very high voltage to the cube, electrons will start to jump out of crystal lattice and fly away right?
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello @vasya,
:welcome: ##\qquad ##!​
Good questions, not so easy to answer at an appropriate level (which level that is in your case, isn't really known to us).

There is a relationship between charge and voltage$$Q = CV$$ with Q the charge, V the voltage and C the so-called capacitance. For the shape of the cube it's rather difficult, but for a sphere the capacitance can be shown to be ##C = 4\pi\varepsilon_0 R##, so that we get $$Q=4\pi\varepsilon_0 R \, V\ .$$A 1 cm3 sphere has a radius of 6.2 mm, so with 1 V we get a charge of 6.9 1013 Coulomb, which is about 4300 electrons.

[Edit]yes, 6.9 times ten to the minus 13 Coulomb, of course. Sorry.
:smile: at first I had the 'Coulomb' inside the exponent and concentrated on fixing that...##\ ##
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes vasya, Delta2 and Lord Jestocost
vasya said:
Homework Statement:: How many electrons will flow into the cube, connected to the 1.5v battery negative terminal, with positive being grounded
Relevant Equations:: i don't know

How many electrons will flow into the cube, or what will be the charge in it?

ps: the electrostatic field of the Earth does not change, so it's not a capacitor, right?

By the way, if we will apply very high voltage to the cube, electrons will start to jump out of crystal lattice and fly away right?
This will have capacitance. Roughly it will be given by ##C= {4\pi{\epsilon}_0}\frac a 2 ## where a is side of cube. Then Q=VC

Given enough voltage (the work function) the electrons will be ejected from the metal. Usually they will bounce back but If this happens at a high enough rate and energy to cause ionization of the air a spark cascade will develop.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Delta2 and vasya
thank you all!
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Interesting problem you came up with, considering that you now beginning your studies to electricity/electromagnetism.
In my opinion both of the above answers are very good, just to ask @hutchphd , the formula for the cube must have a typo, it must be ##C=4\pi\epsilon_0\frac{a}{2}## and to emphasize that it is an approximation and not exact as in the case of a sphere.

Also to add that for your problem we must consider some assumptions:
  1. That the grounded electrode has exactly 0V potential
  2. The battery is ideal, and can maintain always 1.5V potential difference between the electrodes
  3. The electrodes behave as ideal conductors.
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd
BvU said:
A 1 cm3 sphere has a radius of 6.2 mm, so with 1 V we get a charge of 6.9 1013 Coulomb, which is about 4300 electrons.
It must be ##6.9\times 10^{-13}## right? (negative exponent I mean)
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Likes BvU and kuruman
Delta2 said:
That the grounded electrode has exactly 0V potential
I don't understand this requirement .
Thanks for the correction to my original post...I saw how badly I screwed it up immediately and think I corrected it before yours dropped. (Thought I had gotten away un-noticed.l...!)
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
hutchphd said:
I don't understand this requirement .
Yes well i would better say that "The potential of each electrode is not affected by the charge of the other electrode".
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd
Here is a paper on the numerical capacitance of a unit cube.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/239582798_UNIT_CUBE_CAPACITANCE_CALCULATION_BY_MEANS_OF_FINITE_ELEMENT_ANALYSIS
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd and Delta2
  • #10
hutchphd said:
.I saw how badly I screwed it up immediately and think I corrected it before yours dropped. (Thought I had gotten away un-noticed.l...!)
The number of electrons too needs a correction.
 
  • #11
Also, it would be interesting to do a capacitance measurement of a 1 cm cube vs. a similar sphere at some DC voltage. Since it would not by a typical 2 pole capacitor, any suggestions as how to do it? My initial guess would be to hook the negative terminal of a battery to the electrically isolated cube or sphere and the other terminal to ground. Would the capacitance be measured en between the cube or sphere and ground? Fluke digital multimeters have a capacitance setting and I was thinking of using that.
 
Last edited:
  • #12
Correcting an earlier error I made, the average distance from the center to an edge of a unit cube is actually 0.640395!

Screen Shot 2022-04-11 at 1.46.55 PM.jpg


This suggests ##C≈4 \pi \epsilon_0 (0.6404) a## where ##a## is the cube length.

The paper (no full access but the results are in the abstract) referenced below computes capacitance for a cube as; $$C=4 \pi \epsilon_0 (0.6606±0.0001) a$$
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0304388604001044#:~:text=Our final result for the,therefore the best available value.

Another paper (check out the neat 3D plot of surface charge distribution!) with similar results;

https://www.cs.fsu.edu/~mascagni/papers/RIJP2003_6.pdf
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Back
Top