Using Kirchhoff's laws for multiple batteries and resistors

3 replies · 3K views · last reply
Bolter
Messages
262
Reaction score
31
Homework Statement
See full question below
Relevant Equations
Kirchhoff 1st and 2nd law
Hey everyone!

Had an attempt at this circuit question, but wanted to check if I got the set up right in order to find the current in the 3rd wire?
Printed exam question text: two batteries of emf 10 V and 3 V with internal resistances 2 ohm and 3 ohm, wires of 4 ohm, 2 ohm and a 3 ohm connecting wire; parts (b)(i) to (iii) ask for a circuit diagram, loops and loop equations, and the current in the third wire.


Here is what I have done
Handwritten working for a two-loop circuit with 10V and 3V batteries and resistors of 2, 3, 4 and 3 ohms; loop equations 10 = 8I1 + 3I2 and 3 = 3I1 + 9I2 are solved to give I1 = 9/7 A, I2 = -2/7 A and the third-wire current 25/21 A, about 1.19 A.


Thanks!
 
You have done well, showing the internal resistance in each battery as an explicit external resistor in series.

However, there is a problem with the depiction of the "mid-point" connections. The three ohm wire connects at the midpoints of the two ohm and the four ohm wires. It would be best to split the two ohm "resistor" at its midpoint and to do the same for the four ohm "resistor".

Because the drawing is misleading, the equations you constructed from it are not correct.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Bolter
jbriggs444 said:
You have done well, showing the internal resistance in each battery as an explicit external resistor in series.

However, there is a problem with the depiction of the "mid-point" connections. The three ohm wire connects at the midpoints of the two ohm and the four ohm wires. It would be best to split the two ohm "resistor" at its midpoint and to do the same for the four ohm "resistor".

Because the drawing is misleading, the equations you constructed from it are not correct.

So would this be a much preferred circuit diagram then?

Hand-drawn circuit schematic on lined paper with a 10V battery and 3V battery, resistors of 2, 1, 1, 3, 2 and 2 ohms, and a 3 ohm resistor forming a middle branch between two junctions.


I think my loop equations will be the same as before if I use Kirchhoff's law on left & right loop
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jbriggs444
Very nice drawing. And now that I look again your equations were correct to start with.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Bolter