Velocity of a slider connect to a wheel

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the velocity of a slider connected to a wheel that is rolling without slipping. Participants explore the relationships between the velocities of different points on the system, particularly focusing on the geometry and kinematics involved in the motion of the slider B and point A connected to the wheel. The context includes both theoretical and mathematical reasoning.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests that the slider B will initially move to the left, indicating a negative velocity due to the pulling action of point A.
  • Another participant proposes determining the velocity vector for point A, noting that it moves in a circular path around point C.
  • There is a discussion about the direction of velocity for point A, with some participants asserting it is perpendicular to line CA.
  • One participant introduces the idea of treating the problem as the center O translating at constant speed while the wheel rotates, suggesting this may simplify the analysis.
  • A calculation is presented where the angular velocity of OA is derived, leading to a computed velocity for point A, which is then used to find the velocity of slider B using trigonometric relationships.
  • Another participant recommends expressing the velocity of point A as a vector and using coordinates to relate the positions of points A and B over time, emphasizing the need for careful consideration of direction.
  • There is a mention of a computed velocity for slider B that is slightly greater than the previously calculated velocity for point A, but the method used to arrive at this value is questioned by another participant.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the correct approach to calculating the velocities involved, with no consensus reached on the final values or methods. Some calculations are agreed upon, while others are challenged or deemed incorrect.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the complexity of the problem due to the need for precise directionality in the velocity calculations and the potential for errors in assumptions about the motion of points A and B. The discussion includes unresolved mathematical steps and dependencies on geometric interpretations.

Jonski
Messages
42
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


problem.gif

A wheel of radius 42 mm is rolling without slipping and its centre O has a velocity 7.2 m/s in the direction shown.

The slider B is driven by the link AB and A is connected to the wheel.

If AC= 28.9 mm, AB= 73.9 mm and angle ACB= 73°, what is the velocity of the slider B? Take the right-hand side direction positive.

Homework Equations


va = vb + va/b
velocity at edge of circle in line with O = sqrt(2)*v
Vc = 0

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
My initial thoughts are that B first has to move to the left as A is going to pull it rather than push. (So the answer will be negative)
I first constructed the triangle ABC, but without angle CAB or side CB, I don't know how to complete it.Any help would be greatly appreciated, Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Suggestion is to try to determine the velocity vector for the point A. Do you see that the point A is going to be instantaneously moving in a circle centered at point C? Once you figure out how point A moves, go to point B and try relating the coordinates of B (to first order in ## \Delta t ## ) to the coordinates of A.
 
Would A be moving straight down as that would be perpendicular to OA?
 
Jonski said:
Would A be moving straight down as that would be perpendicular to OA?
The pivot point is at C and the radius is CA. The direction of ## v_A ## will be perpendicular to CA.
 
Charles Link said:
The pivot point is at C and the radius is CA. The direction of ## v_A ## will be perpendicular to CA.
Just an an additional comment is you could also treat the problem as the center at O translating at constant speed with the wheel rotating about O at a rate that will make it roll without slipping. Considering it as pivoting about point C is a shortcut that should get you the same answer.
 
Charles Link said:
Just an an additional comment is you could also treat the problem as the center at O translating at constant speed with the wheel rotating about O at a rate that will make it roll without slipping. Considering it as pivoting about point C is a shortcut that should get you the same answer.

So could I say that the instantaneous centre of OA is at C:
7.2/0.042 = 171.429 rad/s = Woa
Va = 171.429*0.0289 = 4.954 m/s
Then we can construct a right angle trigangle of Va, Vb and Va/b with angle 73 degrees. Then for Vb it would be Va/sin(73) = 5.18m/s => -5.18m/s (right is positive)
However, this is still wrong any tips on what I did incorrect.
 
First I recommend you express ## v_A ## as a vector with x and y components. Use C as your origin. Find the location of ## A ## coordinates (x,y) at time t=0. Then at time ## \Delta t ## , ## A'=A_0 +v_A \Delta t ##. Also write location ## B ## (at t=0) in terms of ## A ##, and then ## B' ## (at ## t=\Delta t ## ) in terms of ## A' ##. (Both of these steps are simple=uses Pythagorean theorem.) First get the exact expression for ## B' ## and then expand and simply keep first order term in ## \Delta t ##. Finally, ## B'-B=v_B \Delta t ##. ## \\ ## One helpful hint for the direction of ## v_A ## : CA is perpendicular to ## v_A ## and points in direction (unit vector) ## \hat{t}=\cos(\theta)\ \hat{i} +\sin(\theta) \hat{j} ##. The perpendicular to this is (unit vector) ## \hat{n}=\sin(\theta) \hat{i}-\cos(\theta) \hat{j} ## which will be your direction for ## v_A ##. (Notice that ## \hat{t} \cdot \hat{n}=0 ## ). ... editing... I agree with your result for the amplitude of ## v_A=4.954 \, m/sec ##, but unless the direction of ## v_A ## is horizontal, the computation for ## v_B ## is non-trivial. The method I presented above for finding ## v_B ## should work... editing... I did get an answer that I think is correct and it (edited=first time I didn't compute it precisely) just slightly greater than +4.954 m/s and in the "+" direction=to the right.
 
Last edited:
Charles Link said:
First I recommend you express ## v_A ## as a vector with x and y components. Use C as your origin. Find the location of ## A ## coordinates (x,y) at time t=0. Then at time ## \Delta t ## , ## A'=A_0 +v_A \Delta t ##. Also write location ## B ## (at t=0) in terms of ## A ##, and then ## B' ## (at ## t=\Delta t ## ) in terms of ## A' ##. (Both of these steps are simple=uses Pythagorean theorem.) First get the exact expression for ## B' ## and then expand and simply keep first order term in ## \Delta t ##. Finally, ## B'-B=v_B \Delta t ##. ## \\ ## One helpful hint for the direction of ## v_A ## : CA is perpendicular to ## v_A ## and points in direction (unit vector) ## \hat{t}=\cos(\theta)\ \hat{i} +\sin(\theta) \hat{j} ##. The perpendicular to this is (unit vector) ## \hat{n}=\sin(\theta) \hat{i}-\cos(\theta) \hat{j} ## which will be your direction for ## v_A ##. (Notice that ## \hat{t} \cdot \hat{n}=0 ## ). ... editing... I agree with your result for the amplitude of ## v_A=4.954 \, m/sec ##, but unless the direction of ## v_A ## is horizontal, the computation for ## v_B ## is non-trivial. The method I presented above for finding ## v_B ## should work... editing... I did get an answer that I think is correct and it (edited=first time I didn't compute it precisely) just slightly greater than +4.954 m/s and in the "+" direction=to the right.
Additional comment=your answer ## v_B=+5.18 \, m/sec ## is close to the numerical answer I got, but your method of computing it from the ## v_A ## I believe is incorrect.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 32 ·
2
Replies
32
Views
8K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K