Voltage Division for AC Circuits: Why Isn't My Calculation Working?

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
Ammar w
Messages
28
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Hi,
We have this cut. :

AC circuit schematic: 100 0° V source feeds a 4 Ω resistor, then a node with a j5 Ω inductor to ground and a 10 Ω resistor in series with a -j5 Ω capacitor.


and in the image below, I10 is calculated by using current division :

Worked AC circuit solution: Zin = 4 + j5(10 - j5)/10 = 6.5 + j5 ohms; Is = 100/(6.5 + j5) = 12.194 angle -37.57 A; Ps,abs = -483.3 W; P4,abs = 297.4 W boxed; Pcabs = 0 boxed; I10 = 6.097 angle 52.43 A.


The Attempt at a Solution



I tried to find it using voltage division but the answer is wrong :
Vx(of the upper node) = 100 * [tex]\frac{j5}{4+j5}[/tex] = 60.98 + j48.78 V

=> I10 = [tex]\frac{Vx}{10 - j5}[/tex] = 2.93 + 6.34 = 6.98 [itex]\ 65.2[/itex]

which is wrong, WHY?

thanks
 
Ammar w said:

Homework Statement


Hi,
We have this cut. :

AC circuit schematic with a 100 0° V voltage source feeding a 4 Ω resistor, then a node with a j5 Ω inductor branch to ground, and a 10 Ω resistor in series with a -j5 Ω capacitor.


and in the image below, I10 is calculated by using current division :

Handwritten AC circuit calculation: Zin = 4 + j5(10 - j5)/10 = 6.5 + j5 ohms; Is = 100/(6.5 + j5) = 12.194 angle -37.57 A; P_s,abs = -483.3 W; P_4,abs = 297.4 W; P_cabs = 0; I10 = 6.097 angle 52.43.


The Attempt at a Solution



I tried to find it using voltage division but the answer is wrong :
Vx(of the upper node) = 100 * [tex]\frac{j5}{4+j5}[/tex] = 60.98 + j48.78 V

=> I10 = [tex]\frac{Vx}{10 - j5}[/tex] = 2.93 + 6.34 = 6.98 [itex]\ 65.2[/itex]

which is wrong, WHY?
Your voltage division isn't taking into account the impedance of the 10Ω and -5j capacitor branch that's also connected at the Vx node. You might try applying nodal analysis to find Vx...
 
Last edited: