Water treatment experiment design

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the design of an experimental setup for a water treatment project, specifically focusing on reverse osmosis (RO) membrane fouling reduction using magnetic treatment as a pretreatment step. Participants explore various parameters and configurations for the experiment, including water velocity, pipe diameter, and flow rates.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • One participant outlines a basic experimental setup involving a 50L feed water tank, a pipe with variable parameters, and two RO systems for water treatment.
  • Another participant asks clarifying questions regarding the purpose of the experiment, the parameters to be investigated, expected flow rates, and budget considerations.
  • It is proposed that the experiment will test the effectiveness of magnetic treatment on reducing RO membrane fouling, with specific focus on magnetic flux density, magnet configuration, contact time, and pipe diameter.
  • Participants discuss the need for high flow rates in the RO system and the importance of adjusting pH and temperature during the process.
  • Concerns are raised about the feasibility of using magnets alone for purifying seawater, with clarifications that magnets will be used as a pretreatment method rather than the sole purification technique.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying levels of understanding regarding the role of magnetic treatment in the water purification process. Some participants question the effectiveness of magnets alone, while others clarify that they will be used in conjunction with RO systems. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the overall efficacy and design specifics of the proposed setup.

Contextual Notes

Participants have not reached a consensus on the total volume to be processed per trial, and there are uncertainties regarding the specific configurations and parameters that will yield the most effective results.

rawan
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
hello
this is the first time I'm using this forum so I hope that my post is in the right sub-forum
I'm working now on a project for water treatment , I don't know exactly how to design the setup of the experiment.
what is needed
1- 50l feed water tank connected with a pipe , I have to use different water velocity,pipe diameter and flow rate on this pipe.
2- at the end of the pipe part of the water will be directed toward tank , and the rest will be directed to 2 RO (reverse osmosis ) .
3- the product water from RO will collected in a tank.
I need economic and effective setup ,with proper distribution for pumps , valves and if any other equipment is required.
the attached image is a sketch for the set up.
regards
 

Attachments

  • expmag.jpg
    expmag.jpg
    16.6 KB · Views: 572
Engineering news on Phys.org
Firstly, welcome to PF.
I notice you have no specific question, or a size scale. So I will start by asking you some questions.

1. Why are you doing this experiment?
2. What parameters will you be investigating experimentally?
3. What sort of total volume will you process per trial?
4. What flow rates do you expect?
5. Are those magnets shown in your diagram?
6. What is your budget for this experiment?

Successful experimentation involves asking yourself questions, and answering them.
The best answers are the ones that destroy the question.
 
rawan said:
hello
this is the first time I'm using this forum so I hope that my post is in the right sub-forum
I'm working now on a project for water treatment , I don't know exactly how to design the setup of the experiment.
what is needed
1- 50l feed water tank connected with a pipe , I have to use different water velocity,pipe diameter and flow rate on this pipe.
2- at the end of the pipe part of the water will be directed toward tank , and the rest will be directed to 2 RO (reverse osmosis ) .
3- the product water from RO will collected in a tank.
I need economic and effective setup ,with proper distribution for pumps , valves and if any other equipment is required.
the attached image is a sketch for the set up.
regards

Welcome to the PF.

Yeah, magnets are not going to do very much in the way of water treatment, unless all you are trying to do is remove iron filings or something...?
 
I would also start with the end in mind. What specification do you want your water to meet?

Drinkable?
De-ionised?
USP 29?
 
first of all thanks all for your kindly reply , and I'm sorry that the post idea is not clear but this the first time I work in water field , here is what I'm going to do

1- I have to work on a project for RO membrane fouling reduction , I will apply anti-scale magnetic treatment as pretreatment step for feed water , so the feed water will pass in a magnetic field then it will directs to RO.
2- most of the parameters that will be tested relating to magnetic water step and it is as follow
a- magnetic flux density by increasing the number of magnets (the magnets will be arranged on the out surface of the pipe).
b- magnets configuration by changing the geometry of the magnets according to the north and south pole.
c- contact time this is a critical parameter ,which is The amount of time water is in contact with the magnetic field as it runs through a pipe for this 15 minutes , 10 minutes, 5 minutes will be tested.
d- pipe diameter ( 1 inch, 0.5 inch,0.25 inch).
e- for RO system I need high flow rate , I will change pH and temperature.
f- for the total volume per trial I don't know exactly I need advice.
g- the budget is not so much it will be 1500-2000 $.
h- the feed water will be saline water with high EC , I will test for different ECs , the final product water is drinkable.
I hope now you catch the idea , thanks again
regards
 
rawan said:
first of all thanks all for your kindly reply , and I'm sorry that the post idea is not clear but this the first time I work in water field , here is what I'm going to do

1- I have to work on a project for RO membrane fouling reduction , I will apply anti-scale magnetic treatment as pretreatment step for feed water , so the feed water will pass in a magnetic field then it will directs to RO.
2- most of the parameters that will be tested relating to magnetic water step and it is as follow
a- magnetic flux density by increasing the number of magnets (the magnets will be arranged on the out surface of the pipe).
b- magnets configuration by changing the geometry of the magnets according to the north and south pole.
c- contact time this is a critical parameter ,which is The amount of time water is in contact with the magnetic field as it runs through a pipe for this 15 minutes , 10 minutes, 5 minutes will be tested.
d- pipe diameter ( 1 inch, 0.5 inch,0.25 inch).
e- for RO system I need high flow rate , I will change pH and temperature.
f- for the total volume per trial I don't know exactly I need advice.
g- the budget is not so much it will be 1500-2000 $.
h- the feed water will be saline water with high EC , I will test for different ECs , the final product water is drinkable.
I hope now you catch the idea , thanks again
regards

Maybe I'm misunderstanding. You are going to use only magnets to purify seawater into drinking water?
 
berkeman said:
Maybe I'm misunderstanding. You are going to use only magnets to purify seawater into drinking water?

no at all, I will use magnets as pretreatment method to reduce RO membrane fouling , salinity water will pass through magnetic field then it will be directed to RO.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
50
Views
8K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
5K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 51 ·
2
Replies
51
Views
4K