Ways to generate clean electricity?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jacquesl
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    clean Electricity
AI Thread Summary
Generating clean electricity without fossil fuels is a challenging endeavor, particularly when considering methods like electrolysis to produce hydrogen and oxygen from water. While the idea of using this hydrogen as fuel is appealing, the process is inefficient, with electrolysis typically yielding only about 40% efficiency, meaning more energy is consumed than produced. Alternative clean energy sources such as solar, wind, and hydroelectric power are recommended for stationary power generation. The discussion highlights the fundamental principle of thermodynamics, emphasizing that energy cannot be created from nothing. Ultimately, pursuing efficient and sustainable energy solutions requires understanding these scientific limitations.
Jacquesl
Messages
136
Reaction score
1
Ways to generate clean electricity?
I’ve been working long on this one, I’m working on a project to generate electricity from every but fossil fuels, don’t want to pollute our world any more with Carbon dioxide //CO2

What about using water to convert to hydrogen and oxygen and then use that to fuel my combustion engine.
Will that work or will it only make things run in loops and get no where

I’ve tried a test with water it takes up 10 sec @28v //0.30A to generate hydrogen and oxygen and then one spark to pop of the lid from the small container, will that be possible to generate electricity from that.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
So, you propose to use electrolysis to convert water into hydrogen and oxygen, then ignite this mixture to produce water again?
 
Yip, your 100% correct and in the process I’ll probably could capture some energy, will it work
 
No unfortunately not, electrolysis is only around 40% efficient (if memory serves); you would use more energy obtaining the hydrogen and oxygen than would be produced when you ignite it. Sorry to burst your bubble :frown:
 
The easiest, allmost clean fuel to use in cars would probably be ethanol.
Allmost all petrol cars can use it with very small modification.

But if you want stationary power generation there are other clean ways like sun power, wind power, water power or combinations of those.
 
Last edited:
Jac, there is a question you should ask yourself: Where did you obtain the electrical energy to separate the water? Was it from a coal power plant?
 
Clearly, Jac believes that you don't need a coal power plant to make the hydrogen (except perhaps for startup), you just use the electricity from your generator.

Jac, the chemical process goes like this:

2H2O + E -> 2H2 + O2 (electrolysis)
2H2 + O2 -> 2H2O + E (combustion)

Notice that the equations are exactly the same, but reversed. So even if all of your various devices were 100% efficient (and they aren't anywhere near 100% efficient), you'd only ever get out of this what you put into it.

There is no free lunch. That's the first law of thermodynamics.

Variations of this question are so common, so simple (you learned this in 8th grade), and so useless (people often spin their wheels for lifetimes trying to beat the first law of thermo), we don't discuss it here. It is a waste of your time and ours.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top