netqwe
- 22
- 0
What cause the atomic orbitals electron configuration ?
Thanks in advance
Thanks in advance
The discussion revolves around the causes of atomic orbitals and electron configurations, exploring the underlying principles that govern these concepts. It touches on theoretical aspects, historical models, and the complexities of quantum mechanics.
Participants express differing views on the adequacy of the Bohr model versus the Schrödinger equation for explaining electron configurations. There is no consensus on which model is more appropriate or sufficient for the discussion at hand.
Participants note that the discussion may depend on the definitions of terms like "orbital" and "electron configuration," and the complexity of the concepts may vary based on the audience's prior knowledge.
The Bohr model by itself cannot explain electronic configuration. And while it may be historically interesting, the Bohr model has actually nothing to do with the the best representation we currently have of atoms, which is given by quantum mechanics, through the Schrödinger equation. One needs to learn how the Schrödinger equation is solved to ultimately understand the electronic structure of atoms.Perq said:Quantization of energy levels.
Think you want to read this one https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr_model
It might be easier to understand, but it is false! For the complete novice, it helps to understand how quantization can come about and why atoms have discrete absorption/emission spectra, but that's about it. Even then, it is not very complicated to explain orbitals and quantum numbers without directly showing how the Schrödinger equation is solved.Perq said:It is far easier to understand simple Bohr model, than start with solving Schrödinger equation, don't you think?
Can it explain why the ground state electronic configuration of carbon is 1s22s22p2? You need to add artificial rules (e.g., the octet rule).Perq said:And yes, it does explain electronic configuration. (electron energy levels)
He used the terms "orbital" and "electron configuration", which are quite specific.Perq said:I think OP is asking for the most basic stuff.
. I've corrected it, so let's wait for an answer from him to figure out the correct level of response.