Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around determining the appropriate current and voltage output needed to charge a Varley Redtop 8 battery (12V, 8Ah) using thermoelectric generators (TEGs) in a formula student car. Participants explore the requirements for charging while the battery is simultaneously powering the vehicle's electrical systems, including the ignition and dashboard.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- One participant suggests matching the charger output of 12V and 2.7A, questioning if more current is needed due to simultaneous battery drain.
- Another participant notes that the open circuit voltage is 14.4V and suggests using two TEGs in series to achieve the required charge voltage.
- Participants discuss the difficulty of measuring the car's current needs due to the vehicle being disassembled, with one proposing to estimate based on known electrical components.
- It is mentioned that the charger would take over three hours to fully charge the battery, which may not suffice for repeated engine starts.
- One participant emphasizes the importance of providing all necessary current for the vehicle's operation, including the ignition system and lights, and suggests estimating current based on the ratings of the electrical components.
- Another participant proposes reducing power requirements by replacing inefficient light bulbs with LEDs and discusses the need for a temperature regulator for the TEGs.
- Questions arise about the current required for the ignition system of a single-cylinder engine, with estimates around one amp being suggested.
- Discussion includes the potential for using a smaller alternator that could be disengaged once the exhaust reaches the necessary temperature for the TEGs.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express varying opinions on the current requirements and the feasibility of using TEGs versus an alternator. There is no consensus on the exact current needed for the vehicle's systems or the best approach to charging the battery while it is in use.
Contextual Notes
Participants acknowledge the complexity of estimating current needs without direct measurements, and the discussion includes assumptions about the temperature conditions for TEG operation and the efficiency of various electrical components.