cRaZiRiCaN
- 1
- 0
Is the only way to find a material's or compound's behavior at the nano scale through experiment or can we deduce its characteristics through some other way or theories?
The discussion revolves around the definition of nanoparticles and the methods for determining their properties at the nanoscale. Participants explore whether experimental methods are the only means to understand material behavior at this scale or if theoretical and computational approaches can also provide insights.
Participants express differing views on the necessity of experimentation versus simulation for understanding nanoscale properties, and there is no consensus on the definition of nanoparticles, particularly regarding size and the characteristics that qualify a material as a nanomaterial.
Participants highlight the complexity of defining nanoparticles and the conditions under which larger particles might also be considered nanomaterials, indicating that definitions may depend on specific properties and contexts.
The only way to determine a material's properties at ANY scale is through experimentation. Theory that is well established can make very good predictions of said properties, but such predictions need to be verified by experiment. It is the measurement of the property that is the final arbiter. This is just as true in the nanoscale as it is in the mesoscale or macroscale.cRaZiRiCaN said:Is the only way to find a material's or compound's behavior at the nano scale through experiment or can we deduce its characteristics through some other way or theories?