What do you think of the Canadians on PF?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Smurf
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around perceptions and stereotypes of Canadians and Americans, with participants expressing mixed feelings about Canadians. Some participants feel a mild animosity towards Canadians, while others argue that this sentiment stems from misunderstandings due to cultural differences and the predominance of American-centric discussions. The term "Asian-style" is debated, with one participant suggesting that certain behaviors among Canadians resemble those of Asian cultures. There are also discussions about the representation of Canadians in online forums, with some feeling that Canadians come off as condescending or overly critical of Americans. The conversation touches on the complexities of national identity, with participants acknowledging that stereotypes can be overly simplistic and do not reflect the diversity within each country. Ultimately, the thread highlights the challenges of cross-cultural communication and the importance of understanding different perspectives.

How do you feel about Canadians on PF

  • They're awsome

    Votes: 14 35.9%
  • They suck

    Votes: 7 17.9%
  • No strong opinion

    Votes: 8 20.5%
  • What's a Canadian?

    Votes: 10 25.6%

  • Total voters
    39
  • Poll closed .
Smurf
Messages
442
Reaction score
3
Me? I generally find myself feeling mild animosity towards most of them. With a few exceptions.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Smurf said:
Me? I generally find myself feeling mild animosity towards most of them. With a few exceptions.
what exceptions ?
I personally find them to be a bit more of Asian style in some ways, with a few exceptions, those who live near the Can-US border.
 
What does Asian-style mean? :confused:
 
What's a Canadian?
 
why can:t you just answer my question to you first ?

Ok, It means 20% of their lifestyle and especially ways they behave and talk is just similar to those of Asian people, am I wrong ?

Are Chinese really that good in Canada and the US ? I doubt really much about this.
 
I'm not going to say who I like because then I'll insult everyone else. Danger is one of the few that has earned my respect though, better than that last quebecois kid who was here.
Emieno said:
Ok, It means 20% of their lifestyle and especially ways they behave and talk is just similar to those of Asian people, am I wrong ?

Are Chinese really that good in Canada and the US ? I doubt really much about this.
Yeah, I think you are wrong, personally. I see huge differences between east asians and Canadians.
 
I asked so because I find that most of them occupy a lot of high positions in famous schools, organizations in North America, ...
 
Smurf said:
What does Asian-style mean? :confused:
Aheem, :blushing: :blushing:
No, I really can't say what it means..
 
what happened to the poll?
 
  • #10
it's... right there...
 
  • #11
Its spelled Canadicans... duh
 
  • #12
This is opening up a can of whoopass... but it makes for good discussion. I don't think being Canadian has that much to do with it except for the fact that perhaps a lot of the topics that get discussed are American oriented and Canadians (who, no matter how closely related, are not part of the american system or specific way of life) will not be able to have more than an outsiders :) perspective. Therefore a lot of misunderstanding and oversimplified speak (cuz this is the Internet) will cause some emotions in some and thus the feeling of anamosity. I am new here, but I find that quite a few debates go off topic and become debates over individual credibility and it's very disappointing.
 
  • #13
outsider said:
will cause some emotions in some and thus the feeling of anamosity. I am new here, but I find that quite a few debates go off topic and become debates over individual credibility and it's very disappointing.
But.. I'm Canadian too.
 
  • #14
Smurf said:
But.. I'm Canadian too.

yes, I can see that... so my point is that - you don't know what it really means to be american, and therefore you will not be able to fully assess something from the outside looking in.
 
  • #15
outsider said:
yes, I can see that... so my point is that - you don't know what it really means to be american, and therefore you will not be able to fully assess something from the outside looking in.
:confused: so... Americans are better at understanding Canadians than Canadians?

Or do you mean Americans get along with Canadians better than Canadians?
:confused: :confused: :confused:
 
  • #16
Smurf said:
:confused: so... Americans are better at understanding Canadians than Canadians?

Or do you mean Americans get along with Canadians better than Canadians?
:confused: :confused: :confused:

U are pretending to be confused, and that's just too bad :rolleyes:

As I stated earlier:

"alot of the topics that get discussed here (on PF) are American oriented issues and Canadians will not be able to have more than an outsiders :) perspective. "

therefore: how can one fully assess something from the outside looking in?

I've read your other posts, and perhaps the anomosity may stem from a personal perspective rather than a cultural one. It seems as you are one of the prominent Canadian threadmongers - since you can't change the past, maybe you might want to think about how you are representing your country in your future postings :zzz: gnite
 
  • #17
outsider said:
I don't think being Canadian has that much to do with it except for the fact that perhaps a lot of the topics that get discussed are American oriented and Canadians (who, no matter how closely related, are not part of the american system or specific way of life) will not be able to have more than an outsiders :) perspective. Therefore a lot of misunderstanding and oversimplified speak (cuz this is the Internet) will cause some emotions in some and thus the feeling of anamosity.

I got a misunderstanding for ya. What does this have to do with liking Canadians? Sure SOME Canadians will come in and act like they know more about America then Americans do... but why would that make you feel bad or good about em. Sure it can be considered a "trait"... but there's so many other traits that tell you more about what kind of person it is your talking to. Grammar nazis piss me off to a whole new level compared to Canadians. Plus of course there's the trait where people can turn any simple or humorous topic into a political thread. Boy do they ruin the day...*cough* Art *cough*.

And of course, why are we judging people based on where they live? Surely a few peoples mannerisms don't reflect an entire nation? Just because a few Brits think their breakfast and oddly named jams are the reason they are the greatest empire in history doesn't mean everyone thinks that way or acts that way. Just because a few French think they are one step above the evolutionary ladder then us "humans" doesn't mean everyone thinks that way. Just because a few Australians like basically any band that will go on Carson Daily's show doesn't mean their entire country is full of braindead slobs... although lately I've had my doubts :-p

So let's all come together, tear down the walls of race and ethnicity and unite as the human race on this great planet Earth and let us forever criticize Australia's taste in music.
 
  • #18
I really enjoy my Canidian friends here.
 
  • #19
I vote last option. I didn't know there were Canadians over here...hahahaha! :smile: :smile: :smile:
 
  • #20
Who's Danger? :smile:
 
  • #21
Smurf said:
I'm not going to say who I like because then I'll insult everyone else.
But then you go right into saying who you like:
Danger is one of the few that has earned my respect though,
And who you don't:
better than that last quebecois kid who was here.
Maybe this pseudo-poll would better have been titled: "I Don't Like The Quebecois Kid."
 
  • #22
Gee, I was looking forward to some good ol' Canadian bashing, but you guys have ruined the mood with all of this serious talk.
 
  • #23
Let's have a north-american war now:
Maple syrup is better than a Big Mac..:approve:
 
  • #24
Mr. Dressup kicks Mr. Rogers ass.
 
  • #25
outsider said:
U are pretending to be confused, and that's just too bad :rolleyes:

As I stated earlier:

"alot of the topics that get discussed here (on PF) are American oriented issues and Canadians will not be able to have more than an outsiders :) perspective. "

therefore: how can one fully assess something from the outside looking in?

I've read your other posts, and perhaps the anomosity may stem from a personal perspective rather than a cultural one. It seems as you are one of the prominent Canadian threadmongers - since you can't change the past, maybe you might want to think about how you are representing your country in your future postings :zzz: gnite
No, really, I'm quite confused. Firstly I don't agree with you at all, secondly even if you are right what the hell does it have to do with my liking Canadians!? :confused:
 
  • #26
And who you don't:
So? He's not here anymore so he's not going to bloody care now is he? Provided someone actually knows which quebecois kid I'm talking about.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #27
Pengwuino said:
So let's all come together, tear down the walls of race and ethnicity and unite as the human race on this great planet Earth and let us forever criticize Australia's taste in music.

I couldn't agree more.
 
  • #28
Smurf said:
No, really, I'm quite confused. Firstly I don't agree with you at all, secondly even if you are right what the hell does it have to do with my liking Canadians!? :confused:

to clarify your previous question... in general:

Canadians will know more about being / living in Canada than an American
Americans will know more about being / living in U.S. than a Canadian

I thought that was just obvious.

And who you like is your business... race and culture have nothing to do with who you can be friends with.
 
  • #29
I though Smurf and Danger were from Tasmania, i don't know why. :confused:
 
  • #30
wolram said:
I though Smurf and Danger were from Tasmania, i don't know why. :confused:
:smile: Do I come across as Australian? I mean, I can see the connection with Danger, but not me.
 
  • #31
But on the other hand i thought Lisa had escaped from Ivan seekings lab,
i will have to ask him is he has lost any thing.
 
  • #32
(American) football is better than hockey. :approve:
 
  • #33
I think Canadians are cute.
 
  • #34
honestrosewater said:
(American) football is better than hockey. :approve:
That's such bullcrap.
Evo said:
I think Canadians are cute.
Well, at least this one is. (I have my doubts about Danger)
 
  • #35
Maybe this pseudo-poll would better have been titled: "I Don't Like The Quebecois Kid."

We know that Western Canadians, Ontarians, Maratimers, Conservatives and Leafs fans don't like us. It's not secret, it's called jealousy. We're smarter than them, not to mention better looking. :rolleyes:

Provided someone actually knows which quebecois kid I'm talking about.

Yeah, cause this place is just running rampant with those damn Quebecois kids!
 
  • #36
Smurf said:
That's such bullcrap.
American profanity is better too. :biggrin:
 
  • #37
Dagenais said:
We know that Western Canadians, Ontarians, Maratimers, Conservatives and Leafs fans don't like us. It's not secret, it's called jealousy. We're smarter than them, not to mention better looking. :rolleyes:
As you can see honestrosewater, you're typical quebecois is a pathological liar with a megalomania disorder. Recent studies suggest these are a result of speaking psuedo-french and being Montreal fans.
Yeah, cause this place is just running rampant with those damn Quebecois kids!
There are at least 2 others besides you and Danger that I knew of, neither of them post any more.
 
  • #38
Dagenais said:
Yeah, cause this place is just running rampant with those damn Quebecois kids!

There used to be three of us. Wonder were thunderfvck went?
:wink:
 
  • #39
honestrosewater said:
American profanity is better too. :biggrin:
tart the message you have entered is too short. Please lengthen it to at least 10 characters.
 
  • #40
Smurf - Jackass
Danger - Cool
Most of the other Canadians here - Jackasses
Some of the other Canadians here - Cool

Kind of depends, generally though I think most Canadians online are jackasses, but that does not mean all!
 
  • #41
I think the Canadians on PF are mostly condescending, cynical, and try way too hard to sound cool.
 
  • #42
loseyourname said:
I think the Canadians on PF are mostly condescending, cynical, and try way too hard to sound cool.

as does everyone else here who takes jabs at other cultures... it's not a Canadian thing... perhaps it's a Smurf thing (i haven't been around that long, but he doesn't represent all of Canada)...

let's remove barriers, tackle issues, question authority, and seek understanding.
 
  • #43
Everyone be nice!

No being mean to people or Canadians. I mean, Canadians are people too.

Nevermind. Just be nice. :devil:
 
  • #44
No being mean to people or Canadians.

Except for Leafs fans.
 
  • #45
outsider said:
let's remove barriers, tackle issues, question authority, and seek understanding.

screw that, i feel we should all stick to laughing at australians and I am sure everyone on this forum would agree with me
 
  • #46
Dagenais said:
Except for Leafs fans.
Yeah, leaf fans are always fair game.
 
  • #47
Smurf, what motivated you to start this thread in the first place? I don't have any feelings one way or another because I don't take nationality into consideration when deciding who I like and don't like around here (and you really have to try hard for me to not like you). I do enjoy visiting Canada...as long as it's summertime! :biggrin:
 
  • #48
what is the point of this thread? Canada is awsome and you know it. it's fun to joke about other countries, but some here seem to be making actual stabs at us. Canadians are condescending? what the heck is that all about. Americans are just angry because they are the super power but still rank crap on the list of worlds best countries compared to Canada where we are about the least super power of them all.

PS. Canada rules :)
 
  • #49
Pengwuino said:
screw that, i feel we should all stick to laughing at australians and I am sure everyone on this forum would agree with me

as per before.. i couldn't agree more... :smile:
 
  • #50
What's a leafs fan?
 
Back
Top