What does gravitational potential mean ?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of gravitational potential and gravitational potential energy between two masses, exploring the definitions, relationships, and implications of these concepts in physics. Participants examine the mathematical expressions involved and the conditions under which they apply, focusing on both theoretical and conceptual aspects.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants clarify that gravitational potential energy is given by the equation ##-{G\times M\times m\over R}##, but question whether this represents the total gravitational potential energy of both objects or just one.
  • Others argue that gravitational potential is a different concept from energy and should be defined as the potential of one mass in the gravitational field of another, specifically noting that the potential at distance ##R## from mass ##M## is ##-\frac{GM}{R}##.
  • A later reply emphasizes that the gravitational potential energy is indeed the energy associated with the gravitational interaction between two masses, but the interpretation may vary depending on the relative sizes and movements of the masses involved.
  • Some participants propose that if both masses are comparable, the potential should be interpreted as an interaction potential, leading to a more complex formulation involving center-of-mass and relative coordinates.
  • There are corrections regarding the terminology used, with some participants noting that gravitational potential should not be conflated with gravitational potential energy.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the definitions of gravitational potential and gravitational potential energy but express differing views on their implications and interpretations in specific scenarios. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the total gravitational potential energy when both masses are comparable.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the dependence on the assumption of mass sizes and movements, as well as the need for clarity in distinguishing between gravitational potential and gravitational potential energy. The discussion does not resolve the mathematical steps involved in different scenarios.

Buffu
Messages
851
Reaction score
147
Gravitational potential energy between 2 objects is ##-{G\times M\times m\over R}.##
My question is, does the value of this equation of this equation mean total gravitational potential energy of both objects ?
i.e, say the gravitational potential energy of object with mass ##M## is ##p## and, that of object with ##m## is ##P##.
So, ##p + P = -{G\times M\times m\over R}## or ##p + P = -{2G\times M\times m\over R}## ??
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
That is the gravitational potential energy of ##m## with respect to the gravitational field of ##M##. It is also the gravitational potential energy of ##M## with respect to the gravitational field of ##m##. The opening sentence of your post is not correct because it should not contain the word energy.

The gravitational potential is a slightly different concept and involves only one object. It is not energy, but needs to be multiplied by the mass of another object to give a potential energy.

The potential of the gravitational field of ##M## at distance ##R## from its centre of mass is ##-\frac{GM}{R}##. We call that number the 'gravitational potential at distance ##R## from ##M##'.

The potential of the gravitational field of ##m## at distance ##R## from its centre of mass is ##-\frac{Gm}{R}##. We call that number the 'gravitational potential at distance ##R## from ##m##'.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Brian_H
andrewkirk said:
That is the gravitational potential energy of ##m## with respect to the gravitational field of ##M##. It is also the gravitational potential energy of ##M## with respect to the gravitational field of ##m##.

The gravitational potential is a slightly different concept and involves only one object. It is not energy, but needs to be multiplied by the mass of another object to give a potential energy.

The potential of the gravitational field of ##M## at distance ##R## from its centre of mass is ##-\frac{GM}{R}##. We call that number the 'gravitational potential at distance ##R## from ##M##'.

The potential of the gravitational field of ##m## at distance ##R## from its centre of mass is ##-\frac{Gm}{R}##. We call that number the 'gravitational potential at distance ##R## from ##m##'.
God i am really sorry, i meant potential energy not just potential. That is the reason why you should do physics at 2 am morning. Sorry i will edit my question.
 
No, you are right. What you've given is indeed the potential of the gravitational force on a test mass ##m## outside a spherically symmetric mass distribution at rest around the origin of your reference frame with total mass ##M##. The potential indeed is
$$V(r)=-\frac{G M m}{r},$$
and the force is
$$\vec{F}=-\vec{\nabla} V=-V' \vec{\nabla} r=-\frac{G M m}{r^2} \frac{\vec{x}}{r}.$$
 
vanhees71 said:
No, you are right. What you've given is indeed the potential of the gravitational force on a test mass ##m## outside a spherically symmetric mass distribution at rest around the origin of your reference frame with total mass ##M##. The potential indeed is
$$V(r)=-\frac{G M m}{r},$$
and the force is
$$\vec{F}=-\vec{\nabla} V=-V' \vec{\nabla} r=-\frac{G M m}{r^2} \frac{\vec{x}}{r}.$$

should this read 'the potential energy of mass m at a distance r from mass M is $$V(r)=-\frac{G M m}{r},$$'
 
Both is correct: The potential of a vector field is a scalar field, whose gradient gives the vector field (supposed there exists a potential for the vector field). If a force has a potential that does not explicitly depend on time, then energy is conserved, i.e., for a particle subject to this force you have
$$E=\frac{m}{2} \vec{v}^2+V(\vec{x})=\text{const}.$$
In this context ##V(\vec{x})## is called "potential energy" of the particle.
 
Buffu said:
Gravitational potential energy between 2 objects is ##-{G\times M\times m\over R}.##
My question is, does the value of this equation of this equation mean total gravitational potential energy of both objects ?
i.e, say the gravitational potential energy of object with mass ##M## is ##p## and, that of object with ##m## is ##P##.
So, ##p + P = -{G\times M\times m\over R}## or ##p + P = -{2G\times M\times m\over R}## ??

It depends on whether you take ##M >> m## and assume that ##M## does not move. In that case, ##m## has all the PE of the system, which is indeed:

##V(r) = -\frac{GMm}{r}##

But, if you take the case where ##M## is not so large and both masses move, then the above is the total PE of the system and, for example, if ##m = M## then each mass has half the PE.
 
andrewkirk said:
That is the gravitational potential energy of ##m## with respect to the gravitational field of ##M##. It is also the gravitational potential energy of ##M## with respect to the gravitational field of ##m##. The opening sentence of your post is not correct because it should not contain the word energy.

The gravitational potential is a slightly different concept and involves only one object. It is not energy, but needs to be multiplied by the mass of another object to give a potential energy.

The potential of the gravitational field of ##M## at distance ##R## from its centre of mass is ##-\frac{GM}{R}##. We call that number the 'gravitational potential at distance ##R## from ##M##'.

The potential of the gravitational field of ##m## at distance ##R## from its centre of mass is ##-\frac{Gm}{R}##. We call that number the 'gravitational potential at distance ##R## from ##m##'.

You need to be careful, as these are fields valid for a "test mass" and, if you have two masses, ##M## and ##m##, they cannot be test masses for each other simultaneously.

The OP's question arose from a problem where ##m = M##, and so neither was a test mass for the other.
 
If the masses are close, then you should rather interpret the potential as an interaction potential,
$$V(\vec{x}_1,\vec{x}_2)=-\frac{GmM}{|\vec{x}_1-\vec{x}_2|}.$$
Then it's convenient to introduce center-of-mass and relative coordinates
$$\vec{R}=\frac{m \vec{x}_1+M \vec{x}_2}{M+m}, \quad \vec{r}=\vec{x}_1-\vec{x}_2.$$
Then the center of mass moves with constant velocity, and the equation of motion for the relative coordinates is that of a particle with mass
$$\mu=\frac{mM}{m+M},$$
the reduced mass, and force potential
$$V(\vec{r})=-\frac{GmM}{|\vec{r}|}.$$
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: PeroK

Similar threads

  • · Replies 46 ·
2
Replies
46
Views
5K
  • · Replies 29 ·
Replies
29
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
4K
  • · Replies 27 ·
Replies
27
Views
12K
  • · Replies 54 ·
2
Replies
54
Views
7K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K