What happens to magnetic fields when poles are near each other?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the behavior of magnetic fields when similar and dissimilar magnetic poles are placed near each other over time. Participants explore the implications of magnetic interactions, including attraction and repulsion, and consider the potential for practical applications, such as a proposed vehicle engine design utilizing magnets.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • One participant inquires about the effects on magnetic fields when like poles (NN or SS) and unlike poles (NS or SN) are placed near each other for extended periods.
  • Another participant explains that when attracting poles are close, the field lines merge, and they behave as a larger magnet, while repelling poles create a repelling force, but generally, nothing significant happens to the magnets themselves unless coercivity is exceeded.
  • Temperature is noted as a significant factor affecting coercivity, with rare-earth magnets having high coercivity compared to Alnico magnets, which are easier to demagnetize.
  • A participant proposes a design for a six magnet vehicle engine, suggesting it could generate electricity indefinitely by utilizing the repelling forces of magnets, although this idea is met with skepticism.
  • Another participant reiterates the basic principles of magnet behavior, stating that like poles repel and unlike poles attract.
  • The proposal for the vehicle engine is ultimately dismissed, and the thread is locked due to site guidelines regarding discussions of perpetual motion machines.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the basic principles of magnetic interactions, but there is disagreement regarding the feasibility of the proposed vehicle engine, which is ultimately deemed against site guidelines.

Contextual Notes

The discussion includes assumptions about the behavior of magnets under specific conditions, such as coercivity and temperature effects, but does not resolve the practical implications of the proposed engine design.

Newtype
Messages
39
Reaction score
0
What happens when same magnetic poles (i.e., NN or SS) are next to each other for say an hour or more - will the magnetic fields of those magnets become weaker or stronger?

What happens when different magnetic poles (i.e., NS or SN) are next to each other for say an hour or more - will the magnetic fields of those magnets become weaker or stronger?

Please provide formulas and examples, thank you.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Simple question, complicated answer:

For practical purpose, in the attracting pole case, nothing interesting happens. The field lines merge and the two smaller magnets effectively behave as a larger magnet. For practical, permanent magnets, usually nothing happens to the magnets themselves. (more on this in a moment).

In the repelling case, the field lines bend away from each other, and the magnets create a repelling force. Again, in most cases, nothing interesting happens to the magnet.

Okay, now let's step away from the "most cases" qualifier.

Magnets have two key properties: remnance and coercivity. Remnance is a description of how intense a field the magnet produces. Coercivity is a description of how hard it is to demagnetize the material (actually, to 50% reverse-magnetize it, but for our purposes we can be a little sloppy). Now, as long as we don't exceed the coercivity, nothing will happen - and for various measurements we have done, time is not a function in the equation. Leave it for an hour, two hours...there will be no useful difference. Temperature is a big factor - warming a magnet up can reduce the coercivity.

Having said all that, your typical rare-earth magnets have very high coercivities, and are really hard to demag with another permanent magnet. Alnico magnets, on the other, are notoriously easy to flip or change.

No formulas, but there are some examples there. Hope it helps.
 
Thank you, MagnetDave. So basically I could design a six magnet vehicle engine. This would be a good way to reduce global warming and dependence on oil. Here's how this machine I wrote up the plans for works: Two inner moving bar magnets (mounted in frames) repel each other along tracks. Next, two outer stationary bar magnets repel the two inner moving bar magnets back to each other. This process works infinitely. While the inner moving bar magnets are moving they each turn a gear. Each of those gears turns an axle and each of those axles turns a horseshoe magnet inside of a coil of wire generating electricity. Thus electricity can be produced forever using this machine. It would require diodes to convert the alternating currents into direct currents. With power amplifiers this machine might possibly electrically power a house (each house might have one of these generators and modified if desired) and a vehicle (a person might have his/her car powered by one of these generators). Would this six magnet vehicle engine work? If so, how long?

NS---SN---NS----SN
___Gear__Gear
____Axle__Axle
____NS___SN
____Coil__Coil
 
Last edited:
I coincide with above explanations. If we take two bar magnets near to each other, then like magnet poles repel each other and dislike poles attract each other.-narasimha charyulu
 
Newtype said:
So basically I could design a six magnet vehicle engine. This would be a good way to reduce global warming and dependence on oil. Here's how this machine I wrote up the plans for works: Two inner moving bar magnets (mounted in frames) repel each other along tracks. Next, two outer stationary bar magnets repel the two inner moving bar magnets back to each other. This process works infinitely. While the inner moving bar magnets are moving they each turn a gear. Each of those gears turns an axle and each of those axles turns a horseshoe magnet inside of a coil of wire generating electricity. Thus electricity can be produced forever using this machine. It would require diodes to convert the alternating currents into direct currents. With power amplifiers this machine might possibly electrically power a house (each house might have one of these generators and modified if desired) and a vehicle (a person might have his/her car powered by one of these generators). Would this six magnet vehicle engine work? If so, how long?

NS---SN---NS----SN
___Gear__Gear
____Axle__Axle
____NS___SN
____Coil__Coil

One word.

No.

Discussion of PM machines is against site guidelines.

Thread locked.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 42 ·
2
Replies
42
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K