What happens to us/earth if the earth suddenly stops rotating?

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Gaute Huus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Earth Rotating
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion explores hypothetical scenarios regarding the consequences of the Earth suddenly stopping its rotation, including the effects on humans and the planet itself. Participants consider various aspects of physics related to inertia, gravitational forces, and the implications of such an event, with a focus on theoretical reasoning rather than practical likelihood.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that if the Earth stopped rotating suddenly, objects not fixed to the ground would continue moving at the initial rotational velocity of approximately 1000 mph due to inertia.
  • Others argue that the scenario of the Earth stopping for a brief moment and then resuming rotation would lead to varying outcomes depending on the specifics of the stop and start process.
  • A participant notes that the Earth cannot simply stop rotating without an external force acting upon it, and that any such scenario would violate established physical laws.
  • Another viewpoint discusses the implications of gravitational forces and pseudo forces on objects during such a hypothetical event, suggesting that buildings and structures could be damaged if the apparent gravitational force changes significantly.
  • Some participants reference literary works that explore similar themes, indicating that while the scenarios may not be scientifically grounded, they can inspire creative thought.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally do not reach a consensus on the outcomes of the proposed scenarios. There are multiple competing views regarding the implications of the Earth stopping its rotation, with some focusing on the physical laws involved and others emphasizing the speculative nature of the questions.

Contextual Notes

Participants express uncertainty regarding the feasibility of the scenarios and the assumptions underlying their discussions. The conversation reflects a mix of theoretical physics and imaginative speculation, with no definitive conclusions drawn.

Gaute Huus
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Okay, so I present to you three different "scenarios". I'm pretty new to physics, and I can't seem to think this out for myself. Please ask questions, and excuse my english.

I've been wondering for some time what would happen to us (and the earth) if the Earth suddenly stopped rotating, like in a blink. I understand Earth has friction, and that we (humans) are held in place by inertia.

Also I've been wondering what would happen if the Earth stopped completely for, say one tenth of a second, and then accelerated instantly again to its 1000 mph rotation. (Supposed to be a question)

And lastly, what would happen if the Earth suddenly changed it's rotation and started rotating a 1000 mph to the west instead of to the east?

I know probably none of these scenarios are very likely (if even possible).

- Gaute Huus
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If the Earth suddenly stopped rotating, then according to Newton's first law, any object not attached to the ground would carry on traveling parrallel to the ground at an initial velocity of 1000mph.
 
Last edited:
Gaute Huus said:
Okay, so I present to you three different "scenarios". I'm pretty new to physics, and I can't seem to think this out for myself. Please ask questions, and excuse my english.

I've been wondering for some time what would happen to us (and the earth) if the Earth suddenly stopped rotating, like in a blink. I understand Earth has friction, and that we (humans) are held in place by inertia.

Also I've been wondering what would happen if the Earth stopped completely for, say one tenth of a second, and then accelerated instantly again to its 1000 mph rotation. (Supposed to be a question)

And lastly, what would happen if the Earth suddenly changed it's rotation and started rotating a 1000 mph to the west instead of to the east?

I know probably none of these scenarios are very likely (if even possible).

- Gaute Huus

Welcome to PF. There's a problem with your question; you are essentially asking "If we imagine violation of physics X what would the laws of physics have to say?" This is not a good approach to science.

It is not possible for the Earth to just stop rotating. Some action is required to stop it and depending on what this action is will affect the answer to your question.
 
Gaute Huus said:
Okay, so I present to you three different "scenarios". I'm pretty new to physics, and I can't seem to think this out for myself. Please ask questions, and excuse my english.

I've been wondering for some time what would happen to us (and the earth) if the Earth suddenly stopped rotating, like in a blink. I understand Earth has friction, and that we (humans) are held in place by inertia.

Also I've been wondering what would happen if the Earth stopped completely for, say one tenth of a second, and then accelerated instantly again to its 1000 mph rotation. (Supposed to be a question)

And lastly, what would happen if the Earth suddenly changed it's rotation and started rotating a 1000 mph to the west instead of to the east?

I know probably none of these scenarios are very likely (if even possible).

- Gaute Huus

H. G. Wells wrote a delightful short story about this scenario:

http://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/w/wells/hg/w45mw/
 
Thank you for all of your answers. The result can be various different things, depending on which way the Earth is "stopped". I'm going to try speculating more with that information in mind.

And thanks again!
 
Gaute Huus said:
Okay, so I present to you three different "scenarios". I'm pretty new to physics, and I can't seem to think this out for myself. Please ask questions, and excuse my english.

I've been wondering for some time what would happen to us (and the earth) if the Earth suddenly stopped rotating, like in a blink. I understand Earth has friction, and that we (humans) are held in place by inertia.

Also I've been wondering what would happen if the Earth stopped completely for, say one tenth of a second, and then accelerated instantly again to its 1000 mph rotation. (Supposed to be a question)

And lastly, what would happen if the Earth suddenly changed it's rotation and started rotating a 1000 mph to the west instead of to the east?

I know probably none of these scenarios are very likely (if even possible).

- Gaute Huus

Earth can't just stop rotating or orbiting around the Sun due to gravitational forces, unless the Sun suddenly disappears or another body 'rolls up' into our solar system in a certain area and then we would start orbiting that said body - Newton said we would straight away go off course if the sun suddenly disappears - But according to Einstein, we would have to wait 8 minutes (the time it takes for gravity to take effect at our distance from the Sun) then we would go off course. For the human part we would eventually die since it would get bloody cold.

We wouldn't feel the 'stop and go' due to the Theory of Relativity, since we are not accelerating (but I think that only applies if the rate of speed at which we are rotating is constant).

(Sorry if any of this is wrong, I'm only 14 :L)
 
ryan_m_b said:
Welcome to PF. There's a problem with your question; you are essentially asking "If we imagine violation of physics X what would the laws of physics have to say?" This is not a good approach to science.

Andy Resnick said:
H. G. Wells wrote a delightful short story about this scenario:

http://ebooks.adelaide.edu.au/w/wells/hg/w45mw/

It's not a good approach to science, but it does make for a very entertaining short story.

As does Isaac Asimov's "The Billiard Ball". This has the entire short story collection (including the great story, "Nightfall"), but you can go to "The Billiard Ball" by scrolling up to the beginning of the document, clicking on the navigation icon and then on "The Billiard Ball".

http://www.polvoestelar.com.mx/babilonia/Libros/Isaac%20Asimov/English/Short%20Stories/Isaac%20Asimov%20-%20The%20Best%20of%20Isaac%20Asimov.pdf
 
Last edited by a moderator:
before answering your question,there are some essential things that you should know.
1)than due to rotation,our Earth becomes an accelerated frame,so as long as we are on it we experience a pseudo force that has a value of mv2/r.here r depends on our coordinates as at defferent places on Earth there are different associated radius of rotation.
2)the resultant of the main core gravitational force and pseudo force decides the apparent g.all the buildings and architectural habituals are made on the basis of this apparent g.if the value of this g changes by a margin,then these builings may collide.

now let us answer your questions:-
ans1)if Earth suddenly stops rotating,all objects not fixed on its place will move in outer space with a particular velocity(i.e the linear rotational velocity at that instant).this objects will be influenced bythe gravitational force.those objects facing more air drag will move towards Earth and all other in outer space.as discussed in point 2,the apparent g will return it's value as normal g,and hence where this change is big,buildings and other things will break and may move out in outer space.
ans2)in this questions those thing that move in outer space will move out with 1000mph and all fixed objects will get damaged due to actin of non constant force in small interval of time(i.e gravity+pseudo,then only pseudo,and then gravity and pseudo again).the acceleration for achieving 1000mph again will further effect the apparent g for that interval of time.
ans3)the mixture of ans1 and ans2 will happen in this case.

note:-as centre of mass doesn't changes due to rotation,so don't consider that concept..
hope it might help you..
nice question...
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 40 ·
2
Replies
40
Views
5K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
6K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
1K
  • · Replies 31 ·
2
Replies
31
Views
4K