What if earth's rotation stopped

  • Thread starter Bandarigoda
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Rotation
In summary, stopping the rotation of the Earth would have catastrophic consequences, with buildings and objects near the equator being crushed and objects being hurled great distances. The force exerted on objects would be comparable to crashing a jet plane into the ground. The Earth's rotation plays a role in determining gravity, so if it were to stop, objects near the equator would weigh more. The Earth's rotation also affects the tides, so if it were to stop, the Moon would stop receding from Earth. Additionally, there would be strong winds and flooding due to the inertia of the atmosphere and ocean. However, this scenario is impossible and we do not have to worry about it.
  • #1
Bandarigoda
36
0
If that happened,
Will it affect to the gravity?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Every building and object would be instantly be crushed near the equator and gradually reduce in damage as it was nearer to the north or south pole. Objects in the equator are moving at around 1674 kilometers per hour so if the Earth immediately stopped it would be like crashing a jet plane into the ground. As for the centrifugal force, it wouldn't really be noticeable. From the link below, people on the equator weighs about 0.3% less due to the centrifugal force exterted on them. You can read more about it on the link I provided below about the Earth rotation and the effect on gravity.

http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?number=310 [Broken]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #3
For one, we'd die because one side would freeze without sunlight, and the other would be too hot.

beamthegreat said:
Every building and object would be instantly be crushed near the equator and gradually reduce in damage as it was nearer to the north or south pole. Objects in the equator are moving at around 1674 kilometers per hour so if the Earth immediately stopped it would be like crashing a jet plane into the ground.
As for the centrifugal force, it wouldn't really be noticeable. From the link below, people on the equator weighs about 0.3% less due to the centrifugal force exterted on them. You can read more about it on the link I provided below about the Earth rotation and the effect on gravity.

I don't think so. How would you get a crushing force (towards the center of the earth) from stopping rotation?

Also, a jet plane into the ground? Energy? Force? What?
 
  • #4
No, the force will be exerted sideways when the Earth stopped moving. So, buildings would be crushed upon itself and objects would be hurled great distances relative to the ground. I am assuming that the Earth stopped almost instantaneously so you can imagine how devastating the impact would be.

The acceleration of all things on the surface would be:
(400 m/s - 0 m/s) / infinitesimally small time

This acceleration we perceive in this scenario could be comparable to driving a jet plane (at 1600 km/h) and then crashing in into the ground.

As for the second part, the Earth rotation plays a role in determining the gravity on the surface of the Earth (due to centrifugal force) so if the Earth stopped moving, objects near the equator would weigh more than it would now by around 0.3%.
 
  • #5
Maybe some things would "fly" but it wouldn't crush and buildings since the buildings are "bolted" to the Earth and the entire thing would be a rigid body. Even if we don't consider them absolutely bolted, there are frictional forces to consider, as well as the strength of their fondation.

I still don't buy the jet plane angle. You need to consider things like the time it takes the plane to crash and how massive it is... A jet crash would actually deliver a much smaller impluse.
 
  • #6
Ok ill admit the jet plane part was a bit too simplified. My point is that if the Earth were to stop instantly it would certainly be devastating to everything on earth. Also, I believe the structural strength of the building is enough to cause it to collapse upon itself but I could be wrong.
 
  • #7
Then also tsunamis will be happen?
Will it affect to moon? What about the air? A fastest air should be start, then might affects to air planes, and other objects on the land. Am I correct?

I'm just a high-school student. Our teacher, the physics teacher doesn't know anything about this.
 
  • #8
Gravity wouldn't be affected.

There is a big question mark over how the Earth could be stopped without destroying it. You mention tsunamis, which presumably you think would occur due to the inertia of the water, but that's the least of your problems. If you tried to stop the planet rotating by applying a force to the surface of the Earth there is the inertia of the rest of the planet to worry about. The inside would try to keep spinning. Is the Earth strong enough to take the braking forces? If you can figure out a way to stop the whole planet spinning at once then stopping the little bit of water on the outside and the atmosphere spinning should be easy by comparison.
 
  • #9
beamthegreat said:
My point is that if the Earth were to stop instantly it would certainly be devastating to everything on earth.
Some unknown physics are needed to make the Earth stop rotating. You apparently are assuming that this unknown physics pertains to rocks only. Why? Certainly you could also assume that the same magic that works on rocks also works on water, buildings, people, etc.

This is one of those "what do the laws of physics say would happen if the laws of physics are wrong" kinds of questions.
 
  • #10
This is one of those "what do the laws of physics say would happen if the laws of physics are wrong" kinds of questions.

Well said.
 
  • #11
Bandarigoda said:
Then also tsunamis will be happen?

Yes, the ocean would still be moving and would flood most of Earth's landmass.

Will it affect to moon?

Nothing would happen immediately, but the long term effects would be that the Moon stops receding from Earth. This happens because, without rotation, the Earth cannot transfer its angular momentum to the moon through the tides.

What about the air?

Lots of wind. LOTS of wind.

A fastest air should be start, then might affects to air planes, and other objects on the land. Am I correct?

I don't understand what you said. "A fastest air should be start" doesn't make any sense.Luckily for us, none of this will ever happen, as it is impossible, so we don't have to worry about any of it.
 
  • #12
Drakkith said:
Yes, the ocean would still be moving and would flood most of Earth's landmass.
Why?

Lots of wind. LOTS of wind.
Once again, why do you say this?

It would require magic to suddenly make the Earth stop rotating. Why are you assuming the magic only works on rocks? It's magic. It can do anything it wants.
 
  • #13
Drakkith said:
Nothing would happen immediately, but the long term effects would be that the Moon stops receding from Earth. This happens because, without rotation, the Earth cannot transfer its angular momentum to the moon through the tides.

The moon is still orbiting the Earth so we'd still have tides. They'd just rise and fall twice a month instead of twice a day.
 
  • #14
The original post did not say that that Earth rotation must stop suddenly, that is clearly physically impossible as all rotational energy would have to be removed through the very thin crust.

In short, gravity will not change.

The Earth's figure, an oblate spheroid, will without rotation become spherical. At an astronomical distance gravity should not change as the mass of a spherical Earth is identical to the entire Earth's mass being located at the centre of the Earth's sphere. If there is still local density variation within the Earth then there will still be minor local variations in gravity on the Earth's surface.

The Earth's rotation is slowing down now due to the presence of the Moon releasing the tidal energy we see twice each day. The Moon has already ceased to rotate and has locked one face to the Earth. With time the Earth will lock a fixed face to the Moon. The Earth now has a rotational period of 24 hours, that will become a period of one month when the Earth's face finally locks to the Moon. So the Earth cannot completely stop rotating, except relative to the Moon.

Most atmospheric winds are caused by Earth rotation so they will cease as rotation stops. Only katabatic winds would remain as they are caused by local variation in density of the atmosphere as sunlight heats one side and the other side cools.
 
  • #15
Nugatory said:
The moon is still orbiting the Earth so we'd still have tides. They'd just rise and fall twice a month instead of twice a day.

Which, interestingly, would start to accelerate the Earth's rotation, since the energy transfer would now be from the moon's orbit to the Earth's rotation (rather than the other way, as it is currently). It would also cause the moon's orbit to spiral inwards.
 
  • #16
D H said:
Why?


Once again, why do you say this?

It would require magic to suddenly make the Earth stop rotating. Why are you assuming the magic only works on rocks? It's magic. It can do anything it wants.

Okay. Let's assume it works on everything. Then nothing interesting will happen and we won't have any discussion and no one will learn anything about things like conservation of momentum and energy.

Nugatory said:
The moon is still orbiting the Earth so we'd still have tides. They'd just rise and fall twice a month instead of twice a day.

Of course, I never meant to imply we wouldn't, only that the Moon would stop receding from the Earth.
 
  • #17
Drakkith said:
Of course, I never meant to imply we wouldn't, only that the Moon would stop receding from the Earth.

And because we still have tides, the angular momentum transfer processes will still be at work, just operating at more slowly. The moon's recession continues.
 
  • #18
Nugatory said:
And because we still have tides, the angular momentum transfer processes will still be at work, just operating at more slowly. The moon's recession continues.
It would work the other way around, though. Angular momentum transfer would be from the Moon's orbit to the Earth's rotation if the Earth wasn't rotating or if its rotation rate was longer than a lunar orbit. The Moon would slowly spiral in rather than out.
 
  • #19
D H said:
It would work the other way around, though. Angular momentum transfer would be from the Moon's orbit to the Earth's rotation if the Earth wasn't rotating or if its rotation rate was longer than a lunar orbit. The Moon would slowly spiral in rather than out.

D'oh. Thanks.
 
  • #20
I'm not sure what answer the OP was looking for. But I guess it is something like "would we all feel a lot stronger gravity". And the answer is no, not really. We would feel slightly more gravity, but it would only be a small amount. This is because the Earth is not really rotating fast enough to be on the same order of magnitude as gravity.
 
  • #21
Hi,
I understood the things guys. Thanks for answering me. :thumbup:
 
  • #22
Bandarigoda said:
If that happened,
Will it affect to the gravity?
Ignoring questions of HOW the rotation would be stopped and all the devastation due to "conservation of momentum", the force of gravity would not change at all- that depends only on the mass and radius of the earth. A person at the equator would feel a little heavier because how heavy you "feel" is the force of gravity minus the centrifugal force necessary to keep you on the surface of the Earth as it spins.
 

What if Earth's rotation stopped?

The idea of Earth's rotation stopping is a common topic in science fiction, but what would happen if it actually occurred?

1. Would the days and nights be longer?

Yes, if Earth's rotation stopped, the length of a day and night would become equal to the length of one year, meaning each day and night would last 365 Earth days.

2. What would happen to the Earth's atmosphere?

If Earth's rotation stopped, the atmosphere would still be in motion due to the Earth's own rotation around the sun. However, the winds would become much stronger, causing extreme weather patterns.

3. How would this affect the Earth's climate?

The lack of rotation would cause temperature differences between the light and dark sides of the Earth to become extreme. This would result in extreme weather patterns and temperature changes, making it difficult for life to survive.

4. What would happen to gravity?

Earth's rotation creates a centrifugal force that counteracts the pull of gravity. Without this force, gravity would become stronger, resulting in a decrease in weight for objects on the surface of the Earth. This would also cause the Earth to become slightly more oblong in shape.

5. Could life still exist on Earth?

It is highly unlikely that life could survive on Earth if its rotation stopped. The extreme weather changes, lack of day and night cycle, and changes in gravity would make it difficult for any living organism to survive. However, some deep-sea organisms or bacteria may be able to adapt to these extreme conditions.

Similar threads

Replies
0
Views
474
  • Mechanics
Replies
9
Views
175
Replies
9
Views
837
Replies
14
Views
219
Replies
2
Views
709
  • Mechanics
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
19
Views
1K
Back
Top