Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the request for process and instrumentation diagrams (P&ID) specifically for water treatment plants. Participants explore the availability of such diagrams, their confidentiality, and the specificity required for different plants and processes.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant requests P&ID diagrams for water treatment plants, expressing frustration over the difficulty in obtaining them.
- Another participant questions whether "used water" refers to wastewater, suggesting resources like Wikipedia and technical societies for initial research.
- Several participants argue that detailed P&ID diagrams are typically specific to individual plants and processes, reflecting local standards and produced by engineering companies for specific clients.
- One participant mentions that while generic plans could be created, they would require fine-tuning to meet specific needs.
- Another participant shares concerns about the confidentiality of P&ID diagrams, noting that they are often marked "Confidential" and that sharing them could lead to legal issues.
- It is noted that engineering companies have a proprietary interest in protecting their designs, which limits the availability of such diagrams.
- One participant highlights that the engineering work involved in water treatment is highly specific and cannot be easily generalized due to varying contaminant loads and process requirements.
- A later reply mentions that the original poster has found a P&ID for a local wastewater treatment facility through a personal connection.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally agree that detailed P&ID diagrams are not readily available online and that they are specific to individual plants. However, there is disagreement regarding the feasibility of obtaining generic diagrams and the extent to which they can be adapted for different facilities.
Contextual Notes
Participants express limitations regarding the confidentiality of diagrams and the specific nature of engineering work in water treatment, which may not easily translate to generic applications.