What is the difference between a waveguide/horn and regular metal pipes?

In summary: Why we cannot buy some metal sheets or pipes on McMaster-Carr with very low price and make some microwave components by ourselves?There are a few reasons. The first is that the geometry of a waveguide is proprietary and is not generally available. The second is that waveguides are delicate and require special handling. The third is that waveguides are often fabricated in very small quantities and the costs of production add to the price.
  • #1
BlackPowder
14
2
What is the difference between those horns/waveguides and regular metal pieces with a same geometry? Why the microwave companies sell those parts at hundreds and thousands dollars? Why we cannot buy some metal sheets or pipes on McMaster-Carr with very low price and make some microwave components by ourselves?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
There is quite a lot of black magic talked about with waveguides, because the waves will go through any old copper pipe. However, a rectangular WG has the advantage that there is only one mode, so it avoids multiple signals which can be a problem for high bandwidth transmission of data or TV. It is also difficult to use ordinary pipe bends because a "proper" waveguide will have carefully chosen bending radius and will often have tuning screws to reduce unwanted reflections. I cannot see any problem in principle about using circular tubing, although more modes may spring up and polarisation may rotate due to imperfections. One issue is that it is hard to make WG to coax transitions, so that is why peope buy them and then stick to standard sizes. Incidentally, for 50 years it has been the practice for microwave links to use corrugated elliptical waveguide, which can to some extent be bent like a cable.
 
  • #3
BlackPowder said:
Why we cannot buy some metal sheets or pipes on McMaster-Carr with very low price and make some microwave components by ourselves?
We can and some do.

Losses in a waveguide are less than in coaxial cable because there is no dielectric. Losses in the waveguide are therefore due to the internal surface resistance. That suggests cheap aluminium or expensive copper tube, or a silver or gold plated base metal. But reactive metals gradually develop a surface film that becomes a lossy dielectric, which may also absorb water. Surface protective films are also lossy dielectrics at GHz frequencies. Filling the guide with dry nitrogen is sometimes used, but that is expensive and requires a seal or dielectric window at each end.

Aluminium is chemically too reactive, copper oxidises with losses gradually increasing over time, gold plating is more lossy than copper in the short term, but losses with gold do not increase with time, silver plating is usually a good compromise.
 
  • Informative
Likes berkeman and Klystron
  • #4
The first demonstrations of microwave transmission through waveguides were performed around 1930 by G. C. Southworth. He used round copper rain downspouts one mile long visible in the photo below.

George_Southworth_%26_waveguides.jpg

Southworth at Bell Labs in 1943 standing in front of experimental waveguide line he used in his original research into waveguides during the 1930s. (Wikipeadia)

As tech99 pointed out, however, round waveguides mix modes and polarizations, as do imperfections in rectangular guides. It's also true that pipe joints give poor electrical performance unless they are carefully soldered or welded. Commercial waveguides, on the other hand, have flanges with built-in quarter wave chokes that provide nearly lossless performance in a bolt-together joint.
1571975209365.jpeg
 
  • Like
  • Love
Likes Klystron, dlgoff and berkeman
  • #5
BlackPowder said:
What is the difference between those horns/waveguides and regular metal pieces with a same geometry?

At some fundamental level I suppose there isn't a huge difference but I would question if those pieces of metal are actually the same geometry. Precision matters. Horns and waveguides are manufactured to very tight tolerances and that is not cheap.

BlackPowder said:
Why the microwave companies sell those parts at hundreds and thousands dollars?

Let's consider some of the costs to the manufacturer. Many geometries are possible. After all pieces of metal come in many shapes and sizes. Someone has to pay an engineer to determine what geometry will solve the particular problem at hand and that costs money. The precision machining mentioned above costs money. And, very important and often left out, someone has to go an do the measurements that the design and particular part you will be sold meets the specification. Those measurements are often very expensive.

If the part is unique or exotic in some way there will not be many of them to amortize the costs over hence the high price. This is very typical as one gets away from the main stream, almost by definition.
 
  • Informative
Likes Klystron

1. What is a waveguide and how is it different from a regular metal pipe?

A waveguide is a type of transmission line used to guide electromagnetic waves, such as radio waves, from one point to another. It is typically made of metal and has a hollow, rectangular or circular cross-section. Unlike regular metal pipes, which are used for fluid or gas transport, waveguides are specifically designed to carry electromagnetic waves and have unique properties that allow them to do so efficiently.

2. What is a horn and how does it differ from a waveguide?

A horn is a type of waveguide that is flared at one end to allow for a wider range of frequencies to be transmitted. It is often used to connect a waveguide to an antenna or other device. While a waveguide has a uniform cross-section, a horn has a gradually increasing cross-section, which helps to reduce the loss of energy as the waves travel through the device.

3. Can regular metal pipes be used as waveguides or horns?

No, regular metal pipes are not suitable for use as waveguides or horns. They are not designed to guide electromagnetic waves and do not have the necessary properties to do so efficiently. Attempting to use a regular metal pipe as a waveguide or horn would result in significant energy loss and poor signal transmission.

4. What are the advantages of using a waveguide or horn over a regular metal pipe?

Waveguides and horns have several advantages over regular metal pipes. They have lower signal loss, higher power handling capabilities, and can transmit a wider range of frequencies. They also have better shielding properties, which helps to prevent interference from external sources. Additionally, their unique design allows for more precise control over the direction and polarization of the transmitted waves.

5. Are there any limitations to using waveguides or horns?

While waveguides and horns have many advantages, they also have some limitations. They are typically more expensive to manufacture and require precise design and construction to function properly. They also have a limited bandwidth, meaning they can only carry a specific range of frequencies. Additionally, they are more sensitive to environmental factors, such as temperature and humidity, which can affect their performance.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
2
Replies
46
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
32
Views
18K
  • DIY Projects
Replies
12
Views
6K
Replies
20
Views
3K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
22
Views
642
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
945
Back
Top