- #1

- 9

- 0

The result of my attempt was:

F= 4kqQb/((d^2/2)+b^2)^3/2

but I dont know if is

F= kqQb/(b^2+l^2/2)^(3/2)

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- Thread starter pr_angeleyes
- Start date

- #1

- 9

- 0

The result of my attempt was:

F= 4kqQb/((d^2/2)+b^2)^3/2

but I dont know if is

F= kqQb/(b^2+l^2/2)^(3/2)

- #2

- 7,930

- 818

Four charges of magnitude +q are placed at the corners of a square whose sides have a length d. What is the magnitude if the total force exerted by the four charges on a charge Q located a distance b along a line perpendicular to the plane of the square and equidistant from the four charges?

The result of my attempt was:

F= 4kqQb/((d^2/2)+b^2)^3/2

The above is almost right. Look again at the term d^2/2. Is it correct?

- #3

Andrew Mason

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

- 7,663

- 385

Perhaps you could explain your reasoning.

The result of my attempt was:

F= 4kqQb/((d^2/2)+b^2)^3/2

but I dont know if is

F= kqQb/(b^2+l^2/2)^(3/2)

What is the l as in l^2/2?

It appears to me that F= 4kqQb/((d^2/2)+b^2)^3/2 is incorrect. Check the d^2/2 term in the denominator. What is the distance of a charge from the centre of the square?

AM

- #4

- 9

- 0

F because of one charge=kqQ/(b^2+l^2/2) * cos(theta)

=kqQ/(b^2+l^2/2) *b/sqrt(b^2+l^2/2)

=kqQb/(b^2+l^2/2)^(3/2) (along the perpendicular )

as in plane parallel to the square net F=0

- #5

- 9

- 0

Perhaps you could explain your reasoning.

What is the l as in l^2/2?

It appears to me that F= 4kqQb/((d^2/2)+b^2)^3/2 is incorrect. Check the d^2/2 term in the denominator. What is the distance of a charge from the centre of the square?

AM

This is what i was thinking:

F because of one charge=kqQ/(b^2+l^2/2) * cos(theta)

=kqQ/(b^2+l^2/2) *b/sqrt(b^2+l^2/2)

=kqQb/(b^2+l^2/2)^(3/2) (along the perpendicular )

as in plane parallel to the square net F=0

- #6

- 9

- 0

The above is almost right. Look again at the term d^2/2. Is it correct?

this is what i was thinking

F because of one charge=kqQ/(b^2+l^2/2) * cos(theta)

=kqQ/(b^2+l^2/2) *b/sqrt(b^2+l^2/2)

=kqQb/(b^2+l^2/2)^(3/2) (along the perpendicular )

as in plane parallel to the square net F=0

- #7

- 36,175

- 6,795

That looks right to me, but I see I'm outvoted byF= 4kqQb/((d^2/2)+b^2)^3/2

- #8

- 7,930

- 818

That looks right to me, but I see I'm outvoted byAMandrude man. Maybe I'm missing something.

How about d^2/2 → (d/2)^2 = d^2/4 ?

- #9

- 36,175

- 6,795

No, why? As I read the OP, the point Q is distance b from theHow about d^2/2 → (d/2)^2 = d^2/4 ?

- #10

- 764

- 41

I tend to agree with haruspex :-)

- #11

- 7,930

- 818

No, why? As I read the OP, the point Q is distance b from thecentreof the square.

Curses, haruspex and barryj, you are right.

@Andrew Mason:

Locate the four charges at (d/2,d/2,0), (-d/2,d/2,0), -d/2,-d/2,0) and (d/2,-d/2,0) and the observation point at (0,0,b).

Then the distance from any charge is

sqrt[(d/2-0)^2 + (d/2-0)^2 + (0-b)^2] = sqrt{d^2/2 + b^2}.

My excuse: spatial relations was never my strong suit!

- #12

Andrew Mason

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

- 7,663

- 385

You are right. I was using the distance as √2d/2 and it got me a bit confused. Squared it is d^2/2. So I agree the OP's first answer was right. Sorry for any confusion!Curses, haruspex and barryj, you are right.

@Andrew Mason:

Locate the four charges at (d/2,d/2,0), (-d/2,d/2,0), -d/2,-d/2,0) and (d/2,-d/2,0) and the observation point at (0,0,b).

Then the distance from any charge is

sqrt[(d/2-0)^2 + (d/2-0)^2 + (0-b)^2] = sqrt{d^2/2 + b^2}.

My excuse: spatial relations was never my strong suit!

AM

Share:

- Replies
- 1

- Views
- 525

- Replies
- 2

- Views
- 8K