What Part of a Ball Hitting a Parabola Hits the Focal Point?

In summary, the discussion is about a 1" ball hitting the inside of a parabola and whether the edge or center of the ball would hit the focal point. There is no exact answer as it depends on the ball's trajectory and the parabola's shape. Under certain conditions, the ball can hit the focal point with its side. However, for a ball flying parallel to the axis, the only possible solutions are from the center to the side.
  • #1
Photon713
19
0
1" ball hitting Parabola

If a 1" ball hits the inside of a parabola, what part of the ball hits the focal point?
Is it the edge that strikes the inside of the parabola or the center of the ball?
Thank You
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


What are your thoughts on the matter?
 
  • #3


I think it would be the outer edge of the ball.
 
  • #4


I modeled the problem using rhino geometry. Attached 1 pic with a ball crossing the focus.
There is no exact answer.

If the ball follows the parabola axis it will hit dead center (obvious).
But in all other situations, the ball might cross the focus or even miss it completely.
The ball can hit the focus with it's side given certain conditions.
 

Attachments

  • Paraball.jpg
    Paraball.jpg
    12.3 KB · Views: 478
  • #5


Lok said:
I modeled the problem using rhino geometry. Attached 1 pic with a ball crossing the focus.
There is no exact answer.

If the ball follows the parabola axis it will hit dead center (obvious).
But in all other situations, the ball might cross the focus or even miss it completely.
The ball can hit the focus with it's side given certain conditions.
Cool. But I don't see from your diagram under what circumstances it would miss the focus completely.
 
  • #6


Thank You...

I am attaching an image that represents a 1" ball bearing hitting the inside of a parabola.
Which line represents the passage through the focal point, center or edge? Is the result always the same no matter where the bearing hits the side?
 

Attachments

  • Parabola7.7x4.jpg
    Parabola7.7x4.jpg
    8.3 KB · Views: 485
  • #7


DaveC426913 said:
Cool. But I don't see from your diagram under what circumstances it would miss the focus completely.

For ball flying parallel to the axis there are only center to side solutions. But for different angles it is not true. The problem did not specify parallelism though.
 
Back
Top