What's the superposition principle for group action?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the superposition principle for group actions, specifically in the context of vector transformations under simultaneous rotations represented by group functions. Participants explore how to derive a vector field from a given vector and two group functions acting on it over time.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant asks how to obtain a vector field ##v(t)## when two group functions ##G(t)## and ##G'(t)## act on a vector ##v(t_0)## simultaneously.
  • Another participant expresses confusion about the meaning of "acting on v at the same time" and suggests that clarification is needed regarding the intended meaning.
  • A participant provides an example of two rotations around different axes and questions the resultant vector field when both rotations are applied simultaneously.
  • Further clarification is sought on how to combine the effects of the two operators, with suggestions that it could involve different mathematical operations such as addition or multiplication.
  • One participant proposes using differential equations to describe the change in the vector field, suggesting a formula involving time-ordered products to account for the local changes due to the two infinitesimal rotations.
  • There is mention of the Lie product formula and the Trotter product formula, with one participant expressing skepticism about their applicability in this context.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express uncertainty and seek clarification on the meaning of simultaneous actions on the vector. There is no consensus on how to combine the effects of the two group functions or on the appropriateness of certain mathematical approaches.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight the need for precise definitions and assumptions regarding the operations involved in combining the group actions. The discussion reflects a variety of interpretations of simultaneous actions and their mathematical implications.

Jianbing_Shao
Messages
140
Reaction score
2
A very simple question: if given a vector ##v(t_0)## and two group functions ##G(t)## and ##G'(t)##, here ##t## is the parameter of time, the two group functions act on ##v(t_0)## simultaneously, then we can get a vector field ##v(t)##, then how to get ##v(t)##?
 
Science news on Phys.org
It is unclear to me what you mean. Can you be more specific?
 
Orodruin said:
It is unclear to me what you mean. Can you be more specific?

ok. for example,if ##G(t)=exp(\theta^1(t)X_1)## is a rotation around ##x^1## axis, and ##G'(t)=exp(\theta^2(t)X_2)## is a rotation around ##x^2## axis,
Now if we only act ##G(t)## on a vector ##v(t_0)##, we can get a vector rotate around ##x^1## axis, we act ##G'(t)## on ##v(t_0)##, we can get a vector rotate around ##x^2## axis,
If we act ##G(t)## and ##G'(t)## on ##v(t_0)## at the same time, then what vector field shall we get?
 
Jianbing_Shao said:
ok. for example,if ##G(t)=exp(\theta^1(t)X_1)## is a rotation around ##x^1## axis, and ##G'(t)=exp(\theta^2(t)X_2)## is a rotation around ##x^2## axis,
Now if we only act ##G(t)## on a vector ##v(t_0)##, we can get a vector rotate around ##x^1## axis, we act ##G'(t)## on ##v(t_0)##, we can get a vector rotate around ##x^2## axis,
If we act ##G(t)## and ##G'(t)## on ##v(t_0)## at the same time, then what vector field shall we get?
Again, it is unclear what you mean by ”acting on v at the same time”. I suspect that this is where your confusion lies. There are several things I could imagine this meaning. Which one you are after would depend on what exactly you are trying to do.
 
Orodruin said:
Again, it is unclear what you mean by ”acting on v at the same time”. I suspect that this is where your confusion lies. There are several things I could imagine this meaning. Which one you are after would depend on what exactly you are trying to do.

What I mean is that between time ##t## and ##t+\delta t##, the change of vector only contains two parts: ##v(t)exp((\partial_t(\theta^1(t))X_1)\delta t)## and ##v(t)exp((\partial_t(\theta^2(t))X_2)\delta t)##.
Do you think ”acting on v at the same time”can have other meaning?
 
Jianbing_Shao said:
What I mean is that between time ##t## and ##t+\delta t##, the change of vector only contains two parts: ##v(t)exp((\partial_t(\theta^1(t))X_1)\delta t)## and ##v(t)exp((\partial_t(\theta^2(t))X_2)\delta t)##.
Do you think ”acting on v at the same time”can have other meaning?
But how do combine the two parts into one?

In general if I have two operators A and B, combining them could mean AB or BA or A+B or something else.

Are you, perhaps, referring to the Lie product formula or the related Trotter product formula?
 
DrGreg said:
But how do combine the two parts into one?

In general if I have two operators A and B, combining them could mean AB or BA or A+B or something else.

Are you, perhaps, referring to the Lie product formula or the related Trotter product formula?

In my opinion. perhaps Lie product formula is also not valid here, I think we can use differential equations here,
to the example mentioned above, we can describe ##v(t)## in such a way:
$$\partial_t v(t)=v(t)(\partial_t\theta^1(t)X_1+\partial_t\theta^2(t)X_2)$$
Then we can get ##v(t)## in the formula of time-ordered product:
$$v(t)=v(t_0)T\{exp\int(\partial_t\theta^1(t)X_1+\partial_t\theta^2(t)X_2)dt\}$$
This formula can guarantee that the local change of vector field only contains two Infinitesimal rotations。
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
20
Views
4K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
1K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K