(?) Where do *untrained* ideas go?

  • Thread starter tgm1024
  • Start date
In summary, this individual has an informal education in physics and has a number of ideas about the theories of the universe that they would like to have gently beaten up by those formally trained. They are unable to find a forum that is the right place for them to share their ideas, and are seeking help from others.
  • #1
tgm1024
20
0
I have only an informal [self-]education in physics. But I have a number of ideas regarding the theories of the universe that I'd like to have gently beaten up by those formally trained.

To see where the bodies were buried, so to speak.

I am unable to see a forum that seem the right place for "empirical beginner attempting non-beginner ideas". I certainly don't want to jump in and muddy the waters of the forums by accident.

Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Unfortunately, Physics Forums is probably not the ideal place for what you wish to achieve. We could refer you to some other forums that are better suited to handling your situation.

One place that comes to mind is: scienceforums dot net, though I haven't checked them out in a long time, so am unfamiliar with their current policies. Maybe others here can give you better suggestions.
 
  • #3
tgm1024 said:
I have only an informal [self-]education in physics. But I have a number of ideas regarding the theories of the universe that I'd like to have gently beaten up by those formally trained.

To see where the bodies were buried, so to speak.

I am unable to see a forum that seem the right place for "empirical beginner attempting non-beginner ideas". I certainly don't want to jump in and muddy the waters of the forums by accident.

Thanks!

If you want to know where the bodies are buried you will probably need to do a lot of studying - perhaps ten or twelve years worth. You could ask specific questions about existing theory if you wish to understand what we know or think we know. Wouldn't it make sense to understand what we already know before trying to blaze new trails?

You are not allowed to push your theory here, but we have a lot of people who know a great deal about physics. Many of our members have a Ph.D. in physics [or some other subject of science], so it is a great place to learn.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
Ivan Seeking said:
If you want to know where the bodies are buried you will probably need to do a lot of studying - perhaps ten or twelve years worth. You could ask specific questions about existing theory if you wish to understand what we know or think we know. Wouldn't it make sense to understand what we already know before trying to blaze new trails?

You are not allowed to push your theory here, but we have a lot of people who know a great deal about physics. Many of our members have a Ph.D. in physics [or some other subject of science], so it is a great place to learn.

Without asking questions regarding my current understandings? Perhaps the phrase asking to gently beat up my ideas means I have established theories based on hooey and I challenge you all to disprove them? Regardless, I'll need to rephrase at least.

Ok, you've launched directly into two assumptions here that are unwarranted, that seem at least slightly emotionally charged. I would like to clear this up so that I can feel that my original question is properly asked.

1. Blaze new trails. Not attempting that, nor did I imply it. I am attempting to understand where the existing formalized concepts do not adhere to my current ideas. Substitute "understandings" for "ideas" if you believe I am postulating unfounded nonsense, but that should not be required. Ideas do not forum in a vacuum, they are formed from 35 years of listening, reading and gathering information from out-of-the-box thinkers.

2. Push my theory. Not attempting that, nor did I imply that either. These are not theories, but ideas. I have no "theory". My notions, or sub notions, are not pulled out of thin air, and are not ever to be intended to be "here is how I believe it to be". A better rendition of what I'm taking about is might be better phrased "does the current thinking allow for X?" or "which of the standard models (even if all) fly in the face of X?"

So I'm sorry if I was unclear before, but your reply does show that my intent was not properly read or at least conveyed by me.
 
  • #5
Gokul43201 said:
Unfortunately, Physics Forums is probably not the ideal place for what you wish to achieve. We could refer you to some other forums that are better suited to handling your situation.

One place that comes to mind is: scienceforums dot net, though I haven't checked them out in a long time, so am unfamiliar with their current policies. Maybe others here can give you better suggestions.

Ok, thanks, good idea: I'll go have a look. Not at all clear if what I want to achieve is understood but you've given me a good place to look. I'll go check it out.

Thanks!
 

Related to (?) Where do *untrained* ideas go?

1. Where do untrained ideas go?

Untrained ideas do not go anywhere. They remain in the mind of the individual who came up with them, waiting to be developed and refined.

2. Do untrained ideas have any value?

Yes, untrained ideas can still have value. They may not be fully formed or implemented, but they can serve as a starting point for further exploration and development.

3. Can untrained ideas be developed into successful projects?

Yes, with proper training and guidance, untrained ideas can be developed into successful projects. This requires critical thinking, creativity, and hard work.

4. How can one train their ideas?

One can train their ideas by actively seeking knowledge and skills related to their idea, seeking feedback and advice from others, and practicing critical thinking and problem-solving techniques.

5. Is it important to train ideas?

Yes, training ideas is important as it helps to refine and improve them. It also increases the chances of success when implementing these ideas into projects or solutions.

Similar threads

  • Feedback and Announcements
Replies
1
Views
865
Replies
6
Views
920
  • Feedback and Announcements
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
17
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
218
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
855
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top