Where to find answers for "Mechanical Vibration" textbook (Haym Baneroya)?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mohrcircle
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Textbook Vibration
AI Thread Summary
The discussion highlights concerns about a book lacking answers to its problems, making it challenging for self-studying students. The absence of a solution manual or numerical answers limits its usability. Suggestions include finding a similar textbook that provides solutions or approaching the book with a specific method: read, reflect, solve independently, and then verify answers. Verification can involve checking results through alternative methods or substituting back into original equations. Additionally, a "reasonableness check" is recommended to assess the validity of answers. Some participants express intent to use a different resource for problem-solving.
Mohrcircle
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
IF90wCIDL_Mpv-XAjFUl_OkJZZK7JDPy87p8VbAIwKKMpqkKkxKDTERxxcESlkBb9j6bpHNUiKNivhEbRUQxxIZl29ORLjhK.jpg

I really liked this book but the problems don't have answers at all (not even numerical one's at the back of the book). There is not even a solution manual to download or buy online. How am I supposed to use this book otherwise?
 

Attachments

  • IF90wCIDL_Mpv-XAjFUl_OkJZZK7JDPy87p8VbAIwKKMpqkKkxKDTERxxcESlkBb9j6bpHNUiKNivhEbRUQxxIZl29ORLjhK.jpg
    IF90wCIDL_Mpv-XAjFUl_OkJZZK7JDPy87p8VbAIwKKMpqkKkxKDTERxxcESlkBb9j6bpHNUiKNivhEbRUQxxIZl29ORLjhK.jpg
    5.5 KB · Views: 698
Physics news on Phys.org
Instructor Solution Manuals are not generally available to students (even those who are self-studying). Your best bet may be to find a similar textbook that does publish the solutions to half of the problems in the back of the book...
 
Mohrcircle said:
How am I supposed to use this book otherwise?

The intended use is this way: (1) you read the book, (2) you think carefully about what it says, (3) you work the problems on your own, and (4) you check your answers. You'll be amazed at how well it works and how much you will learn.
 
Dr.D said:
(4) you check your answers.
Check them by doing the problems two different ways? Is that what you mean?
 
Sometimes doing the problem by a second method is the best way. Other times, you can simply substitute your final results back into your initial equations to verify that you do in fact have a solution. This last presumes that you had the correct equations to start.

PS: The ot her check that should always be done is the "reasonableness check." Does the answer make sense, or is it out of the ball park?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes berkeman
I guess I will use good old inman book for problems for now. Thanks for help anyways.
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
TL;DR Summary: Book after Sakurai Modern Quantum Physics I am doing a comprehensive reading of sakurai and I have solved every problem from chapters I finished on my own, I will finish the book within 2 weeks and I want to delve into qft and other particle physics related topics, not from summaries but comprehensive books, I will start a graduate program related to cern in 3 months, I alreadily knew some qft but now I want to do it, hence do a good book with good problems in it first...
TLDR: is Blennow "Mathematical Methods for Physics and Engineering" a good follow-up to Altland "Mathematics for physicists"? Hello everybody, returning to physics after 30-something years, I felt the need to brush up my maths first. It took me 6 months and I'm currently more than half way through the Altland "Mathematics for physicists" book, covering the math for undergraduate studies at the right level of sophystication, most of which I howewer already knew (being an aerospace engineer)...

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
47
Views
5K
Replies
39
Views
7K
Replies
23
Views
5K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
34
Views
6K
Back
Top