Which of the following statements are IMPOSSIBLE?

  • Thread starter Thread starter traveler7
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Impossible
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around identifying which statements regarding physical principles are deemed impossible. The subject area includes concepts from fluid mechanics, thermodynamics, and properties of vacuums.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Conceptual clarification

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the implications of pressure differences in hydraulics, the concept of buoyancy, and the nature of temperature in a vacuum. Questions arise about the definitions and assumptions related to these statements, particularly regarding the behavior of substances during phase transitions and the conditions of a vacuum.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants questioning the validity of marked statements and offering insights into the nature of temperature in vacuums and phase changes. Some participants express confusion and seek clarification on specific concepts, while others provide reasoning to support their views.

Contextual Notes

There is a lack of consensus on the assumptions regarding the vacuum chamber's conditions, as well as the implications of temperature during phase transitions. Participants reference idealized scenarios versus real-world conditions.

traveler7
Messages
8
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Which of the following statements are IMPOSSIBLE? Choose all that apply.

___A perfectly functioning hydraulic had a pressure of 36 Pa in the fluid near the small piston and a pressure of 37 Pa in the fluid near the big piston.
___A 35 L container displaced 42 L of orange juice when partially submerged.
___A substance underwent melting during which its temperature remained constant at 33 °C.
___A 37 N brick was fully submerged in water. The buoyant force on the brick was 48 N. As a direct result, the brick was neutrally buoyant.
___Last Friday, the Sun heated the Moon via convection.
___The temperature inside a vacuum chamber was measured to be 3 °C.



Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



Based on what I have learned this is my attempt:

_x__A perfectly functioning hydraulic had a pressure of 36 Pa in the fluid near the small piston and a pressure of 37 Pa in the fluid near the big piston.
_x__A 35 L container displaced 42 L of orange juice when partially submerged.
___A substance underwent melting during which its temperature remained constant at 33 °C.
_x__A 37 N brick was fully submerged in water. The buoyant force on the brick was 48 N. As a direct result, the brick was neutrally buoyant.
_x__Last Friday, the Sun heated the Moon via convection.
___The temperature inside a vacuum chamber was measured to be 3 °C.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Try defining temperature in a perfect vacuum.
 
So what is your question? Can you provide reasoning why the ones you marked are impossible?
 
Saraphim said:
Try defining temperature in a perfect vacuum.
A vacuum chamber does not necessarily hold a perfect vacuum, in fact it never does, not to mention black body radiation.
 
kuruman said:
A vacuum chamber does not necessarily hold a perfect vacuum, in fact it never does, not to mention black body radiation.

You are of course right. I'm too used to idealized questions. :)
 
well a vacuum chamber has no air,
so would it be 0 K meaning their is no motion in the particles...

so the vacuum one would be impossible too?

My other question is:
is this possible:
A substance underwent melting during which its temperature remained constant at 33 °C
 
traveler7 said:
well a vacuum chamber has no air,
so would it be 0 K meaning their is no motion in the particles...
I know plenty of vacuum chambers that have air in them. The statement of the question is
"The temperature inside a vacuum chamber was measured to be 3 °C." There is no mention whether there is gas in it or not. Why do you assume that it contains a perfect vacuum which doesn't even exist?
My other question is:
is this possible:
A substance underwent melting during which its temperature remained constant at 33 °C
What happens to the temperature of a substance when it undergoes a phase transition from solid to liquid? Think of melting ice.
 
I asked my teacher about a vacuum chamber today and he said that it contains no air

and thanks for the other one I understand it now
 
OK. Assume that the vacuum chamber has not even a single molecule of air. You stick a mercury thermometer in it. Originally the thermometer reads 3 oC. Will the mercury column drop and indicate a lower temperaure?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
10K
Replies
2
Views
6K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
5K