Who in This Forum Has Earned a PhD?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robert Mak
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Forum Phd
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the experiences and perceptions of obtaining a PhD, particularly in fields like experimental nuclear physics and psychology. Participants share their personal journeys, with some humorously noting the challenges and time commitments involved in earning a PhD, which typically takes 4-6 years, especially if pursued directly after undergraduate studies. There’s a light-hearted exchange about the perceived value of degrees, with some joking about the ease of obtaining a PhD compared to other life challenges, such as parenting or working in high-stress jobs. Several contributors express skepticism about the necessity of a PhD for success in research and industry, emphasizing that practical skills and insights can sometimes outweigh formal qualifications. The conversation touches on the cultural differences in how academic credentials are viewed, particularly in the U.S. versus other countries. Overall, the thread highlights a blend of pride, humor, and critical reflection on the academic journey and the significance of advanced degrees in professional contexts.
  • #51
denverdoc said:
That explains those socialist views--classic case of a have-not sour grapes/grapes of wrath :approve: And to the last poster, no doubt. When I wanted advice on how to get an experiment done, first guy I talked with was our resident machinest who didn't even have a BS...but aptitude and imagination up the wazoo, plus the skills to actually build a working proto.

Not really, being poor explains that, and I am studying for a physics degree, I'm not a socialist, it's just that being liberal in England is practically akin to communism in the US, you don't have a political spectrum more of a political wing :biggrin:.

Sour grapes :confused: what gave you that impression? I'm a little offended by that I'll have to be honest, what gives you that impression? Do you think I'm wondering around going, damn literati, must be less like prole, and working my day around how I can get an edge on the more eductated? Because let me assure you I'm not? I'm like this with everyone; poor or rich, smart or stupid, ignorant or wise,educated or educationless lol I just can't resist poking fun at the foibles of people, it's ingrained in my culture I'm afraid :-p:smile:

Obviously the irony was a bit lost on some people. Me a socialist :smile: yeah right. I don't even like labour that much and there allegedly left wing. You crazy Yanks crease me up with your partisan politics :-p

Astronuc said:
I have never cared for titles, ranks, labels, . . .

Yeah like Dr.:wink::smile:

Don't worry I was just taking the P.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #52
Moonbear said:
You'll find that most of the people here with PhDs don't really flaunt it, so might not reply to this thread. That's not what we're here for. (I'm just one of the shameless ones.)
I'm waiting for the how many publications (if>0.3) do you have thread :-p
 
  • #53
mathwonk said:
starting 6 days early is way above average. you are a good guy. the student will appreciate any comments you are able to generate, no matter how hard it is to do so.

most people just walk in the oral and pass the guy, leaving all review to the advisor.

The last time I examined a PhD student, I managed to make her cry. I still passed her though.

This one I am reading now looks fine.
 
  • #54
Schrodinger's Dog said:
Not really, being poor explains that, and I am studying for a physics degree, I'm not a socialist, it's just that being liberal in England is practically akin to communism in the US, you don't have a political spectrum more of a political wing :biggrin:.

Sour grapes :confused: what gave you that impression? I'm a little offended by that I'll have to be honest, what gives you that impression? Do you think I'm wondering around going, damn literati, must be less like prole, and working my day around how I can get an edge on the more eductated? Because let me assure you I'm not? I'm like this with everyone; poor or rich, smart or stupid, ignorant or wise,educated or educationless lol I just can't resist poking fun at the foibles of people, it's ingrained in my culture I'm afraid :-p:smile:

Obviously the irony was a bit lost on some people. Me a socialist :smile: yeah right. I don't even like labour that much and there allegedly left wing. You crazy Yanks crease me up with your partisan politics :-p



Yeah like Dr.:wink::smile:

Don't worry I was just taking the P.

Man I was just teasing/using irony as in anyone who doesn't like the status quo is ... Sorry if it went taken the wrong way.
 
  • #55
denverdoc said:
Man I was just teasing/using irony as in anyone who doesn't like the status quo is ... Sorry if it went taken the wrong way.

You want to try using :wink: smillies then, sounded to me like you were serious. On the other hand you could just make what you say utterly absurd as in my first instant.:smile:

My mistake, probably something to do with me being a peon/prole :smile:
 
Last edited:
  • #56
To my way of thinking it was utterly absurd...and I tried using a smilie, just one of those things that went sideways on the net as they occasionally do.
 
  • #57
denverdoc said:
To my way of thinking it was utterly absurd...and I tried using a smilie, just one of those things that went sideways on the net as they occasionally do.

Aye no harm no foul, obviously. Forget about it.
 
  • #58
klusener said:
Oh my.

Is that YOU, Arun? This is Mr. X. :-p

Well you're Indian, so clearly I must know you from somewhere. No doubt you've heard one of my many pronouncements that "I have a degree in physics!" Just think how much a PhD would inflate my ego!
 
  • #59
To vary the question a little, does anyone have a PhD but no Masters? If so, why did you skip the Master?
 
  • #60
I do not have any education past year 10 or 15 years of age,I am not proud of it.I am limited by a lack of Mathematics and many other things,I can only try and think about things without being able to prove anything.Thats what I love about this forum I can see what you people who have put in the hard yards are thinking :confused:
 

Similar threads

Does Michel Guillen hold 3 PhD's?
Replies
3
Views
3K
Which Prominent PhD Astrophysicists Have Pursued Different Fields?
Replies
6
Views
2K
I got my first graduate interview invite
Replies
14
Views
2K
A new curious mind joins the forums
Replies
1
Views
398
When they first called you Dr.___________?
Replies
1
Views
1K
Why Pursue a PhD Despite the Challenges?
Replies
16
Views
2K
Is PhD the highest degree you can earn?
Replies
9
Views
3K
This forum is great for the learner. What's in it for the mentors?
2
Replies
70
Views
5K
Other Never too late Man earns PhD in Physics at 89
Replies
10
Views
2K
Are There Other Confirmed Geniuses in this Forum?
Replies
20
Views
2K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top