Who Would You Be After Death: The Revival Thought Experiment

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the philosophical implications of identity and consciousness in the context of clinical death and revival. It explores whether a person who is revived after death remains the same individual or becomes a "new experiencer." Participants argue that if a person retains their memories and brain function post-revival, they are fundamentally the same person, similar to the transporter problem in philosophy, which questions the continuity of consciousness. The conversation highlights the unresolved nature of consciousness and identity, emphasizing that even if a person's life processes stop temporarily, their identity remains intact as long as their brain and memories are preserved. Overall, the consensus leans toward the idea that revival does not create a new person, as the continuity of memory and thought processes is maintained.

Would it be you?

  • Yes

    Votes: 8 88.9%
  • No

    Votes: 1 11.1%

  • Total voters
    9
atjta
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
OK, let's say you died. For the sake of simplicity let's say the cause of your death was just your life processes suddenly stopping. All your memories, etc., remained in your brain. Now let's say you were revived by some new tech. QuestionL would it be YOU who were now experiencing in the body or some new "experiencer"?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What type of question is this? We are made up of our genetic make-up and experiences...nothing more.
 
atjta, I think you'll need to make a clear definition of "new experiencer" and why there would be one. Otherwise, we're not going to understand what you mean.

People do undergo clinical death, and they are revived. Barring significant brain damage, they are the same person as before the traumatic event. I don't know of any credible evidence that suggests otherwise.
 
Math Is Hard said:
People do undergo clinical death, and they are revived. Barring significant brain damage, they are the same person as before the traumatic event. I don't know of any credible evidence that suggests otherwise.

I think this is the same problem as the transporter problem - would a perfect copy of a person still have the same consciousness as the original?

I believe this boils down to the question of consciousness, which is unresolved, so there is no known correct answer. There is no way to know if the experiencer has changed or not; not even for the experiencer. For that matter, how do I know if my consciousness now is the same as it was two hours ago? Perhaps that person is for all practical purposes, dead, and I simply have the memory of it.
 
Math Is Hard said:
People do undergo clinical death, and they are revived. Barring significant brain damage, they are the same person as before the traumatic event. I don't know of any credible evidence that suggests otherwise.

Bingo. Still me.
 
If it's your brain, then no matter what happens to it, it's still you. If all the processes in your body stopped for some arbitrary amount of time, and then started up again, the person that awakes would be the same person as before.
 
With the same memories and thought processes and whatnot, would you even be able to differentiate between the "new" person and the old?
 
I think the question has been sufficiently answered. Thanks, all.
 
Back
Top