Why Did I Decide to Leave the Forums Despite My Contributions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Orthodontist
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
A junior Computer Science and Math student at UMass, with a GPA of 3.9, expressed disappointment after being banned from a forum for allegedly making false statements about a group known as SHARP. Despite contributing over 1,000 posts and receiving a Science Advisor badge, the user felt targeted and attacked, leading to their decision to leave the forums. They acknowledged crossing a line in discussions about free speech but maintained that their comments were not unreasonable. The ban was described as a result of perceived trolling behavior, including making unfounded claims and misrepresenting others' arguments. The user expressed sadness over the hostility experienced and indicated a desire to move on from the forum. Other members commented on the need for constructive dialogue and suggested avoiding contentious topics to foster a more civil environment.
Orthodontist
I am a junior CS & Math student at UMass. My GPA is 3.9. I liked these forums and felt I had something to contribute.

You have been banned for the following reason: I warned you to stop making things up

Date the ban will be lifted: 12-12-2006, 11:00 PM

I'm leaving these forums. In the past year I made over 1000 posts in my time here and someone thought I was deserving of the badge Science Advisor. I helped many people with their homework assignments, had many discussions that I thought were interesting, but I have been attacked and recently banned for 3 days for making a true statement about SHARP. I am sorry.

Information on SHARP may be found here. I was banned for claiming they are who they claim to be, namely skinheads. Also Evo has felt that I was unreasonable. I have to agree that I may have crossed the line when I wondered if she was opposed to free speech, though I tried to be as polite there as I could. But nothing else I said seems unreasonable to me. I guess you will have to judge for yourself, but I'm not coming back. It is too hostile here.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&client=opera&rls=en&hs=HLa&q=SHARP+skinhead&btnG=Search


This makes me very sad.

By the way, I am not a skinhead, in case anyone got that impression.

evo said:
You are nothing but a troll. Take advantage of your 3 day vacation and if you return, try not to make things up anymore. Trolling will not be tolerated here.

evo wants me to leave. I am going to. Why would I stay in a place where powerful people hate me? I am not a troll.

This makes me very sad. But I will find other things to do with my time.

Goodbye,

-0rthodontist
___________________________________
:)

Science is what we understand well enough to explain to a computer. Art is everything else we do. --Donald Knuth
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I gave you a 3 day vacation to stop and think about how you falsify arguments. You make a statement, then google to see if you can back it up. You create strawman arguments. You put words into people's mouths that clearly are not their intent. When this is pointed out to you,you press on with your fallacious arguments.

You are welcome here, but you need to stop making things up. If you can't argue against what someone actually says, then don't.

You have a 3 day cooling off period. Think about it. I'm not opposed to further discussion on this.
 
Last edited:
He'll be back, they always come back, muhhaahhahahahhahaahah.
 
I got to add one thing, when we were discussing a thread in the past (the tazing at UCLA (Please don't bring it back up, lol) you were doing the same thing that you did in the imam thread. You kept insisting that other people were not understanding your questions/responses and twisted a lot of words. So while I didn't really take offense or anything, it made it impossible to discuss/debate it with you.

I am definitely not saying you are a troll, but in some respects you acted like one, right? Insisting 3 times that people did not 'understand' your question is crazy dude. I just thought that I would remind you that you did the same thing recently and perhaps this issue has built up over a few threads. Anyways, I hope to see you back/get to know you, I think that you can solve this problem quite easily.
 
Last edited:
Better to just avoid the politics forum; there are a bunch of nuts there that never discuss anything in a civilized manner, and more often than not "discussions" turn into huge flame wars.
 
mattmns said:
Better to just avoid the politics forum; there are a bunch of nuts there that never discuss anything in a civilized manner, and more often than not "discussions" turn into huge flame wars.

Whoa, this discussion isn't about me buddy. Stay on topic.
 
Fools rush in where angels fear to tread

Meaning:

Foolish people are often reckless, attempting feats that the wise avoid. This saying is from “An Essay on Criticism,” by Alexander Pope.

Wait,that's my forum... :frown:
 
cyrusabdollahi said:
Whoa, this discussion isn't about me buddy. Stay on topic.
Everything is about you :smile: And by the way, you are not gold anymore :eek:
 
mattmns said:
And by the way, you are not gold anymore :eek:
:bugeye: It can't have been a year already?
 
Back
Top