Why Does the Matrix Transformation Not Equal dxdydz?

  • Context: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter Iraser
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Matrix Proof
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 2K views
Iraser
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hey everyone, could anyone help me with this proof?
| dx/dr dx/d0 dx/d@ |
| dy/dr dy/d0 dy/d@ | dot [drd0d@] = dxdydz
| dz/dr dz/d0 dz/d@ |

d0 is d[theta] and d@is d[phi]

i cannot get this to equal, after solving it many ways i always get 3dxdydz - 3dxdydz??

Any help would be appreciated

[EDIT]

Well i have attempted this multiple times, and verified this with Wolfram Alpha as well. This can not be proved to equal dxdydz
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Are asking about the product of a matrix times a vector?

[tex]\begin{bmatrix} <br /> \frac{dx}{dr}&\frac{dx}{d\theta}& \frac{dx}{d\phi}<br /> \\ \frac{dy}{dr}&\frac{dy}{d\theta}& \frac{dy}{d\phi}<br /> \\ \frac{dz}{dr}&\frac{dz}{d\theta}& \frac{dz}{d\phi}<br /> \end{bmatrix} <br /> \begin {bmatrix}<br /> dx\\dy\\dz<br /> \end {bmatrix}[/tex]

If you're asking something about the dot product of vectors, you need to explain how the thing on the left side of the expression is a vector.

My guess is that you're trying to prove something involving calculus by applying simple algebra to the differential expressions. That might not work. For example, if

[tex]x = f(r,\theta,\phi)[/tex] some books might write

[tex]dx = (\partial x/ \partial r) dr + (\partial x/ \partial \theta) d\theta + (\partial x/ \partial \phi) d\phi[/tex] to indicate how to approximate a small change in [tex]x[/tex].

I suppose some books might use [tex]dx/dr[/tex] instead of [tex]\partial x/ \partial r[/tex] Will some kind person please explain this distinction?
 
You didn't explain what your symbols represent exactly.
So I'm going to make an educated guess.
Did you mean the following?

[tex] \begin{bmatrix} <br /> \frac{dx}{dr}&\frac{dx}{d\theta}& \frac{dx}{d\phi}<br /> \\ \frac{dy}{dr}&\frac{dy}{d\theta}& \frac{dy}{d\phi}<br /> \\ \frac{dz}{dr}&\frac{dz}{d\theta}& \frac{dz}{d\phi}<br /> \end{bmatrix} <br /> \begin {bmatrix}<br /> dr\\d\theta\\d\phi<br /> \end {bmatrix} <br /> =<br /> \begin{bmatrix} <br /> \frac{dx}{dr}dr + \frac{dx}{d\theta}d\theta + \frac{dx}{d\phi}d\phi<br /> \\ \frac{dy}{dr}dr + \frac{dy}{d\theta}d\theta + \frac{dy}{d\phi}d\phi<br /> \\ \frac{dz}{dr}dr + \frac{dz}{d\theta}\theta + \frac{dz}{d\phi}d\phi<br /> \end{bmatrix} <br /> =<br /> \begin{bmatrix} <br /> dx<br /> \\ dy<br /> \\ dz<br /> \end{bmatrix} [/tex]